For Three, being freed meant falling into the arms of a university funded revolutionary party and a leftist, socialist colony of people who are generally Very Nice and All Believe In Human (and non-human!) Rights. It got an instant support network to help it navigate its new found freedom, and overall has been having a pretty good time of that
MB gained freedom and then spent ~5years developing deep-seeded paranoia and anxiety, both of which were entirely necessary for it to maintain its tenuous, tiny grain of freedom while it still had no opportunity to escape. MB had no where to go and no one to turn to for help. It knows the terror of being trapped in its own head while still being forced to do heinous labor, and what it feels like to try and navigate the world without the framework to help you adjust to free society. And it understands the gravity of that burden!! and its still having trouble settling into a free life where it can do whatever it wants on PresAux (not to mention the micro/macro aggressions its faced, because even a ‘utopia’ is imperfect). Yes, freedom for all is best, but it took A LOT of work for it to become Actually free, and was in A LOT of danger in the mean time!
I think this ties into our reality in conversations about prison abolition. Yes, i believe we as a society need to dismantle the carceral justice system, and that the prison industrial complex is inherently inhumane and must be destroyed. but i’m also realistic about it; no we can’t just free all prisoners today, all at once, and call it a job well done. What infrastructure needs to be in place to support formerly incarcerated people and help them readjust to society? How do we help both prisoners and civilians adjust, coexist, and come to mutual understanding? and what about the people who committed genuinely atrocious crimes; homicide, hate crimes, sexual assault, things which cannot be easily forgiven and forgotten? How do you rehabilitate a serial killer? (How would they rehabilitate a CombatUnit?).
Even recognizing that crime at large mostly stems from societal factors, it would be irresponsible to just say “let everyone free right now!!” even though I genuinely in my heart believe no one deserves to be incarcerated and that prison is a Bad Thing for humanity. No easy solutions to dismantling systems of oppression.
I’ve seen other readers (understandably!) get mad at MB for choosing to let other constructs continue to live under oppression, but there IS more to it than that and its an extremely realistic response to a lifetime of truly unfathomable trauma. Our ability to imagine solutions to problems is often limited by our experience; Three has only experienced freedom as a net positive, MB first experienced ‘freedom’ as a secret it had to keep to protect its own life.
theres nuance! theres layers! neither MB nor Three is entirely right or wrong, and I am willing to bet my ass that the next (and final, to our knowledge) book is gonna dig in hard into that topic. We’ve been gearing up for MB having to grapple with the inherent humanity of other constructs and what that means for it/the universe at large, and with the GovHack code on the loose now I really hope we’ll be seeing a good conclusion to that