Alright look, you can parallel Stanley and Mabel all you want, but you canât just ignore all the parallels between Stanley and Dipper
you canât call Mabel only Dipperâs protector when in every single dangerous instance he is always the one putting himself in front of her to protect her
and she is always the first person heâs worried about protecting
you canât ignore that the bully that calls Stanford a loser looks like Pacifica who calls Mabel a loser, and that Stanley and Dipper are always ready to defend their twins
Stanley and Dipper were bullied in the past, Stan for being weak and Dip for his birthmark. They are not anymore because they hide their insecurities instead of embracing them as Stanford and Mabel embrace theirs
âIt was terrible. I was the weakest kid on the playground.â
âKids used to make fun of my birthmark until I started hiding it all the time.â
and knowing that Mabel is a little odd and unashamed of it is what draws Stanford closer to her
âI like this kid! Sheâs weird.â
You cannot say that Dipper ditches Mabel to pursue the supernatural when he always wants her, just her, to come on adventures with him like Stanley just wants Stanford to go adventuring with him
âEverything was fine until you started bringing your friends around every night. I mean, hanging out with you this summerâs been fun. But, now youâre always with Candy and Grenda, and Iâm⌠like⌠just, left behind.â
and you cannot say that Dipper doesnât sacrifice his wants for Mabel because he sacrifices more than she does and this is what Bill Cipher literally knows and uses to manipulate Dipper in Sock Opera into making a very bad deal with him.
And the only thing that changes Mabelâs mind about giving Dipper up for her show is remembering everything Dipper has done for her.
Iâm not saying Mabelâs not like Stanley in some aspects; she obviously is. But letâs not ignore Dipperâs loyalty to Mabel, alright? Sock Opera was a really important episode. The twinsâ issues werenât really resolved here, and I feel like it was foreshadowing a lot to come, especially because some of the twinsâ dialogue parallels the Stansâ flashback down in the portal room.
Stanley: âYouâre selfish!â
Stanford: âIâm selfish? Look at you!â
Dipper: âYouâre obsessed!â
Mabel: âIâm obsessed? Look at you!â
looks an awful lot like this future confrontation between them