READING IS ENCOURAGING OVERCONSUMPTION.
BUT THAT IS ONE KIND I WILL ALWAYS SUPPORT.
I don't usually write posts on this blog about reading, or centred around reading, as I usually just post them to my book blog. However, something came to my attention recently and when I was deciding about addressing it, I thought I would rather post it here than to the reading blog. Why? I'm not entirely sure. I guess it is because, whilst the topic of conversation centres reading and books, the underlying message and tone feels much bigger than that.
I stumbled accidentally (yes, I was doomscrolling) upon a TikTok where an individual was talking about reading and how the book world is encouraging overconsumption. I would like to say that the TikTok itself bares no real relevance to this post or the topic, I am just using it as a jump off point, and that is why I am not mentioning the specific creator. There was nothing really that wrong with their video, they simply had an opinion I didn't agree with, and that's perfectly okay. But back to my opinion on this...
There were many points made within the video in which, on a surface level, I can say that to an extent I would agree with the creator. Where I find there is a little bit of a grey area is that, within reading and the book world, is acknowledging overconsumption the same as say acknowledging overconsumption in the mukbang space, the fashion space or even the maximalist space? As someone who enjoys reading, has an ever-growing book collection and also dabbles with interests in other spaces, I have to say the concrete answer for me is that they do not hold the same weight. And I'll explain why I think this.
For me, owning books and building up a book collection does not count as overconsumption in the same way as some other instances, simply because books typically will be owned for many years (if not forever) and when they do get discarded it's very very very rare an individual will just throw a book in the bin. I have no statistics here but I'd confidently say most discarded books are most likely donated, repurposed and sold on further to new owners. The creator did argue the point of being 'performative' within reading and owning books and sure, I do agree there is probably an element of consumerism within the act of buying books in bulk. Especially because it is possible that a lot of books go unread. But again, this circles back to the previous point I made that books are rarely discarded without care, even from people who have no interest in them.
One point that was raised in the book consumerism debate, (and I have seen this from many different creators), is the idea that we should not be reading purely for pleasure. The original creator did go on to say that they believe we should not be completely cutting out reading for pleasure either. I will never understand this point. Personally I think it is completely fine for people to read purely for pleasure. Reading for a lot of people has an escapism element and I would never want people to feel like they can't just read and move on from a book. Of course they can. Not every book serves to be analysed. Not every book is trying to tell you some deeper meaning or message. If you yourself want to read and analyse every book you pick up, you are free to do that. But that is not the case for every book, and it certainly isn't the case for everyone. In the world we live in today, and the ways in which we are spending our time as a society, I think reading in any capacity should be celebrated and encouraged. Sure there are reading habits that I disagree with, but reading is an individual experience and journey. And the art of reading is completely destroyed when people start policing it.
Circling back to the part of this topic that I mentioned in the title of this post, I guess all of the above points mentioned then contribute to something a lot of people have an opinion about and that is overconsumption. Overconsumption refers to the act of excessively using goods, resources or services beyond what is necessary. The google definition then goes on to explain that overconsumption occurs when the rate outpaces the ability to regenerate resources leading to severe consequences in many areas such as environmentally, socially and economically. Now here for me is the clear split. Not everyone is buying brand new books every week. Not everyone is purchasing new books at all. I follow many creators who I would say over half, maybe even three quarters of the books they read are second hand or from a local library. And this again circles back to previous points I made about how the majority of people are not getting rid of their books, and when they are unhauling they are donating them to charity shops, second hand stores or maybe even passing them onto family members and friends.
One way in which I do agree with the overconsumption idea within reading and the book world, and do think it has an effect, is the idea of bulk buying. This doesn't directly connect to the amount of books we own over time, but instead the amount of books we buy in a single instance. My reasoning for this being a defining factor for me is that I believe this to be the element of the reading world that is encouraging the mass unhauling of unread books. I have been guilty of this myself. I have never unhauled books (in recent years) and I have no plans to do so because, for me, my book collection will live with me for as long as it is possible. But what I have been guilty of over the years is the rate in which I was buying books was larger than the rate I was reading them and then, where I think this becomes an issue for some people is they do not have the want or pull to get around to reading them because the fascination has worn off. I personally have never bought a book for the sake of it. All the books I own are books that I have an interest in reading and therefore I won't be getting rid of them and I will (eventually) get around to reading them. But for the majority of people we do see unhauling books all the time, and I think the issue lies in other areas that are not specific to overconsumption. And instead they fall into what we struggle with as a society nowadays, in many areas other than just reading, which is our attention spans and interests have lowered by the time we get around to reading the books we buy in bulk. And this is why we should be looking at lesser hauls and more conscious choices, in my opinion.
I could go on to write an entire post about how I think we get bored of our books and why this has a bigger impact on the reading and consumption rates of books within the community, but I won't be going into it in this post. Instead I'll probably write a separate post for that on my book blog, because I feel there are elements of that topic in which I myself can be called out. So that is a conversation and topic for another time.
One thing the creator does mention that I whole heartedly do agree with is the fact that your love of books, love of reading and status as a reader is not proven by the amount of books you own. In a recent interview with book content creator Jack Edwards, Stephen Spielberg said that even though a lot of his films are adapted from books and inspired by prewritten stories, he himself is not a big reader. Of course, he has his own reasons for that but the point I am trying to make here is the fact that, him stating the fact he isn't a big reader doesn't take away from his reading that he does take part in, and it certainly doesn't take away from the fact he is able to adapt stories for the big screen very well. I'm sure we can all agree on that.
So, whilst I do think the book community has a consumption issue, fuelled by the exposure on social media and statuses books have within the community, I do not believe this overconsumption group is like the other forms of overconsumption we see within the world. Sure there is consumption, sure it can be excessive, but I think looking at things overall and considering all angles, I don't think this serves as much of an issue as we like to try and police peoples choices for. And I do strongly believe, in a media excessive world and a time of limited attention spans, someone reading (in whatever capacity) should be encouraged and not over analysed.




















