a little (slightly long) ramble.
i love jj but he was not the best written. honestly none of the things related to shane were very well done imo
i think jj is entitled to being hurt but he does not have any right to be mad at shane for not telling him about ilya. he is not owed facts about shane's relationships. even though jj had been supportive of shane being gay, the relationship between ilya and shane is between them. i do think jj is a pretty good friend with him going to the camps and helping coach, trying to help shane get over ilya, comforting shane when ilya's plane goes through complications. that does not mean anything! shane has a right to fully come out on his own terms. its not personal even if it may feel that way it isn't.
it's fine for jj to be hurt especially seeing that hayden knew because it feels like he's the odd one out. hayden knew that jj was trying to set shane up on dates and instead of dissuading him, he encourages jj. so finding out that hollanov were dating and hayden knew must've felt like they were mocking him. it sucks to find out that someone you thought you were close to never thought you were that close. but he still reacted too poorly bc shane has every right to keep this to himself.
he didn't even really tell hayden so much as hayden guessed accurately and shane confirms it. i hate that shane doesn't get to tell anyone on his own terms about his relationship (except maybe rose?). :(
his dad walks in on them and then he has no choice but to talk to his parents, ryan walks in on them, hayden already knew, and then he gets outed! and the worst part is SHANE DOESNT GET TO BE ANGRY!
again w/jj, he can feel hurt but man your friend is outed look outside yourself.
and to me the worst thing jj does doubt shane's integrity and commitment to hockey. even for a moment.
again! the thing i hate the most is shane doesn't get to be mad. he doesn't get to properly yell back and ream them (jj and the rest of the metros) out.
idk shane deserves to punch jj. like one good punch and then they hug it out.
i am a jj defender but I'm also a shane defender so this is what i got.
Oof I hear you. I've talked about this a lot (1, 2, 3, 4) but I will be talking about it more, especially when season 2 comes around. I'll talk about it endlessly if I have to.
My biggest problem is with how they're written, of course. Reid could have made JJ respond the exact same way she did, but just framed it differently - framed both JJ and Shane differently - and I could have really liked what she did, but of course, she framed it in the worst way. She made JJ out to be a villain for being hurt his friend didn't tell him something he told another friend, then never gave Shane the chance to properly defend himself. She made Shane forgive Hayden so easily and babied the fuck out of Hayden while showing no regard for how it would affect Shane at all, then made Shane and JJ makeup off page. I think the fact that Shane is never allowed to truly be mad, or freak out, offends me more than most about tlg. It shows how little Reid empathizes with Shane, how little she sees where he's coming from or what he's going through at all.
I hate everything about it beginning to end. The only solution to this, for me, is to not analyze from the in-universe. For me, this is a 100% out-of-universe problem. I don't blame JJ. I don't blame Shane. JJ shouldn't have responded the way he did even if he had a right to be hurt, but that's beside the point because Reid simply shouldn't have framed this issue the way she did. She somehow made both of them unempathetic and both of them villains even as the last fifty pages of tlg are basically Hayden apologia. She both villified JJ for being mad his friend didn't tell him about Ilya, and vilified Shane for not telling him. I don't even know how that's fucking possible, but this is all on her. This is not a JJ vs. Shane debate it is a JJ and Shane vs. Reid debate and I am on team JJ and Shane.





















