This is post is therapeutic because Iâve been trying to argue these same points for a long time - particularly the âdark futureâ the Herald and Dorian visit In Hushed Whispers. Itâs a future thatâs apocalyptic to them because their own people have been imprisoned, enslaved, tortured, and harvested by their enemies. The âbad futureâ is good to the people who personally benefit from it (Corypheus and his people), but sucks for those whoâre being tortured and exploited for it (former Inquisition advisers and companions).
And, yes, the game makes it clear that while you and Dorian donât consider the future âreal,â the others do. As Leliana herself tells Dorian, âTo you, this is not real. Just some hypothetical future you hope does not come to pass. But I suffered. The whole world suffered.â By going back to the past, you are effectively erasing them; their lives, their memories, their existence.
But what I find really disingenuous (and a cop-out) on the part of the BioWare writers is, conveniently, everyone is fine with you going back and changing the past. The future to which you have no personal part of is so terrible that everyone in it knows theyâll be wiped out of existence, and are fine with it.Â
But imagine if the Inquisitor and Dorian jumped forward to the same dark future, only a hundred years into the future rather than one year. Everyone who knew the old world is dead and gone, and only people whoâve been born into the new world are left. They might have heard stories of the old world from their parents and grandparents and great-grandparents, but they just seem like fairy stories that have no basis in their day-to-day lives. They may know this dark future filled with demons and magisters and red lyrium harvesters is terrible, but since they have no basis of comparison itâs all they know, and thus something they feel they can live with.
Then you, some spectre of the past shows up, claims to know how this happened, and explains that you need to find the Elder Oneâs glowing green necklace so you can go back in time and fix it so this horrible post-apocalyptic world filled with demons and blood mages and red lyrium harvesting and mass torture and possessions and general hell-on-earth  never happened.
Can you imagine how theyâre react? Probably not well. âBut if you go back that means that I (and my family, friends, memories, world) never existed. I canât let you do that!â You, the viewer, the Herald, know what the old world was like and can see how horrid and post-apocalyptic this new dying world is compared to the old one⌠but they donât know, so they donât care.
Can you imagine how outraged palyers would be if the writers threw all that bullshit in our faces? The story starts off as an idealistic âclose the hole in the sky, stop the bad guys, and save the worldâ plot, then we suddenly get thrown forward in time to a dark future thatâs so obviously horrible and post-apocalyptic, and the answer seems simple: go back in time, fix the past so this horrible present never happens, then save the world as originally planned.â But then you get thwarted by the locals everywhere you turn because theyâve never seen this idyllic past youâre from, and theyâre not keen to throw away the world they know, nor their very existence, on a past theyâve never seen and have no connection to. They expect you to âjust get over the past already; your world is gone; stop being such a sore loser of history whoâs unwilling to accept that your world is gone, and just appreciate the good in the present already.â (Even if itâs just a warm fire and a hot meal in a little rat hole in the dirt while demons and slavers look for new victims outside, which seems paltry to you but heavenly to them.)
So, what do you do in that situation? A) Just abandon your quest and get used to a short, difficult, painful life in the dirt until taint exposure drives you into an early grave (compared to the lifespan youâre used to) if demons or slavers donât kill you first? Or do you B) Keep trying to fix the past (Veil, Chantry, Inquisition, your companions, etc.) with a heavy heart knowing that these people are people, but you feel this future is just too horrible to be allowed to stand anyway?
I suspect, personally, that most players would opt for B.
So, why do we expect Solas to go with option A?Â
Iâm not saying Iâm okay with Solasâ plan and actions, but I can understand his feelings. Because from where heâs standing, he is the Herald and Dorian who just woke up in the world of In Hushed Whispers, and is desperate to find a way back to the past to prevent this post-apocalyptic nightmare from ever happening. And weâre all products of this post-apocalyptic future saying, âItâs not that bad. Just get over the past and learn to like this new world.â