I had previously summarized Brendon's 3 NRWC makeup stages as:

So that works. But now I can add way more since tumblr changed their image limits. Btw I made up my own names for these general phases... like do not take it seriously lol.

Phase 1: Meerkat

Brendon began the tour with black shapes on his eyes that some people thought looked like a demonic clown, but I thought looked like an adorable meerkat. Exhibit A from the first night of tour on November 7th:

November 9th:

Basically, he wore the meerkat look from November 7th – 13th. Here are November 8th, 10th, 11th, and 13th (in order):

Phase 2: Demonic Puppet

Then on November 14th (the second night at Madison Square Garden), Brendon added a puppet aspect:

Kerrang was backstage and actually described the moment when Brendon tried it for the first time:

“Urie is putting on his stage make-up in preparation for the evening’s show. He’s decided that he’ll go a bit crazier than usual and sets about drawing big, red circles on his cheeks to match the black patches masking his eyelids. Walker strolls in and stops cold. ‘Oh wow,’ he shouts. ‘That’s awesome!’ Ross and Smith rush in to see what the fuss is about. The four of them crowd in front of the mirror laughing and shrieking...”

Here's Kerrang's picture of Brendon backstage doing that makeup:

So that Demonic Puppet look was kind of like a bridge between his two main looks.

November 16th & 17th were still heavy on the black eyeshadow, so they're included in this in-between phase:

Phase 3: Full Puppet

From November 18th onward he stuck with this puppet look for the rest of the tour. Here are examples from some different shows in the order that they happened: