hey love!! i hope your doing well :) i LOVE your fanfics and i would like to request a peter pevensie x fem!reader series(specifically taking place in the second movie but has of backstory where reader was the professors distant, shy, quiet and smart granddaughter(but lived with her mother and just went there bcs of the war) in the first movie. She quickly became a good friend of theirs, catching Peters attention especially. Reader was part of the prophecy of narnia, and aslan had a very special connection with her(kind of like lucys but way more than that, like she was his daughter) and made her immortal(but not aging like a vampire or something) and high queen of the narnians specifically(if that makes sense). Then in the golden age me and peter got married but then Peter accidentally went back to his world.) Since she was immortal and the high queen of the narnian, she led a war with the telmarines but quickly lost and was forced into hiding for thousands of years since cair paravel was destroyed and she believed all her fellow narnians went extict. But then from the cave where I was hiding I saw prince caspian and like teamed up with him and the remaining narnians left to fight against the telmarines. Then back with Peter, he misses her more than anything and yearns for her back in london. Then they come back to narnia and meet in the forest scene where Peter fights with Caspian but reader points a bow and arrow at him making him stop and recognize her. But then during the rest of the movie, peter tries to talk with her but she believes the Pevensie siblings abandoned her, especially peter and please add in a bit of jealousy with caspian. Please make it very angsty and end where reader finally dies in the final battle with the telmarines. Im sorry this is SOOO long and its okay if you don't do it but pls dođđźđđźđĽš
The Charming and the Charmed
Peter Pevensie x immortal!reader
Summary: He left. He left, and you couldnât accept it. How dare he leave and come back. You should have never met him.
a/n: Huhu, thank you for requesting! I did take some creative liberties. Like I didn't want reader to die because it's so gut-wrenching knowing your love was on the other side loving you. and so much, still, I hoped you enjoy!
At least, that was what Peter thought.Â
Itâs mathematically impossible that youâre aliveâand Peter hates Math.Â
But looking at the woman he knew. The woman he once ruled alongside. The woman he once loved.
Youâve aged. Not as old as he once left at the ripe age of 28. No, you lookedâ
He irked at this. Boy? He is the High King of Narnia. He ruled the lands when he was 16 years old. He has loved you before then.
Did he even notice you were pointing an arrow at him?Â
Have you aged or was he rejuvenated?
He scoffed at this, âI have you know, Iâm still the High King.â His voice cracked.
Ah, puberty, oh, how he did not miss it.
You raised your eyebrows. Surprised didnât even measure how much youâre feeling. You lowered your bow.Â
You were as encapsulating as you ever were.
He was about to speak when another beat him to it,
âCaptain, I do apologize for not informing you earlierâI blew on a horn and it summoned the long-lost Kings and Queens.â
You turned towards Prince Caspian and smiled. You put a hand on his shoulder and patted, Peter, bless his soul, tries so hard not to look, âItâs alright, I do have to wonder, though,âÂ
âWill they be able to help us with how they are?â
With how they are? What were you implyingâ
And then it dawned on Peter. You didnât trust them because they were children.
He walked closer to you, even at his current age, he was taller than you, âYou canât be serious. Iâll have you remember that we fought for Narnia just a year agoââ
You raised your eyebrows at this.
He looked back at his siblings then at you, âwhat I meant, 1300 years ago! We were younger back then. We fought a war. Won it. And ruledââ
âWith the help of Aslan.â
âAnd where is he now?â
Peter jerked his head back. Thatâs what he was worried about. Was it really a coincidence they came back or was Aslan asking of them?
He looked at his youngest sibling.Â
âLucy, youâve seen Aslan, havenât you?â
Lucy looked surprised and furrowed her eyebrows, âbut you didnât believe meâŚâ
You barked out a laugh, âyou didnât even believe in Aslan, how would he believe in you?â
Peter, outraged, grabbed you by the wrist.
Heâd always step into your personal space if youâre too stubborn to hear him out. He was about to give a piece of his mindâ
He heard a sigh beside him.
Edmund removed Peterâs hand off of yours, âPeteâs right. We have fought this kind of war when we were younger.â
Edmund looked at you, and you stared down at him, "Yes, youâre right. We havenât seen Aslanâyet. But we ended up here, didnât we? He must have led us here.â
You scoffed, âUncertainty wonât get you anywhere here.â
Edmund's mind started to turn, âwell, if not for Aslan, weâre still here. More man power would still lead to a high probability of victory, wouldnât it?â
You keep staring at Edmund, longer than necessary until your shoulders slump.
Then you slowly walk off and leave the small room of Aslanâs How.
Susan and Peter were patrolling the night. Itâs the least they can do to gain back the trust of the Narniansâparticularly a certain someone.
Susan sighed, âWell, this isnât how I expected to be back. Or be back at all.â
Peter looked at Susan, then back at the sky.
âNarnia changed. So much. A year, and everything turns into shamblesâŚWe shouldnât have left.â
Susan shook her head at what Peter said.
âYou didnât know you would have left.â
âWe choose to leave. I choose to leave. We could have looked back.â
Susan shuts her eyes and leaned back, âAslan would have not liked it if we looked back.â
Peter puffed out his cheeks, âitâs justâitâs notââ
Susan waited, as gentle as she is.
âIt must have been lonely.â
Susan thought: lonely where? Lonely who?
And Susan realized who he was talking about, âwho would have realized she would live for 1300 years?â
âEven if we or she realized it, it doesnât matter. Because it happened.â
âI donât even know what happened to her. I donât know how long she ruled; how long she hid; how long sheââ
Encapsulating. That is what Peter Pevensie thought when he first laid eyes on you.
And he didnât even realize that he ran into a tree.
Peter looks back at his siblings running to get to his side.
Susan was inspecting Peter if he had any injuries, Lucyâpoor soul, she could barely keep up with her tiny legs. And Edmund, who happened to be by Peterâs side, looked at you.
Peter smacked his shoulder.
âDonât be rude, Ed!â
âPeter! What is wrong with you?â
Susan finally reached them.
âI was trying to teach Ed here some mannersââ
âYou smacked me in front of a stranger, I donât think thatâs very politeââ
âIâll show you what being politeââ
You giggled. And oh, did you cast a spell on Peter the very moment you met?
You ran up to the older man, and hugged (squeezed) the life out of him.
You slowly let go of your dear old pops.
âCareful now, Pops, Iâm starting to think you donât miss when I do that.â
His eyes shined at this, âcouldnât have missed it for anything else.â
âPops? You have a granddaughter?â Edmund raised his eyebrows.Â
âAh, thatâs right,â the professor looked up from your shoulder and looked at the Pevensies.
âThis is my favorite grandchildââ
âIâm your only grandchildââ
âTo have ever existed. Please treat her with love and respect, as Iâve shown you.â He eyes Edmund specifically.Â
Lucy and Susan were staring at the professor like this was sort of riddle they already have the answer to.
All he could see was you.
Peter never got to experience what having a crush felt like. He was, after all, in the prime of adolescent years. But that got cut short with the war. Curse bloody wars for ruining a lover boyâs dream.
Now this. This could have been the love he read about in the books of the library.
Edmund looked at Peter, seemingly to get help getting away from the Professor, but what he saw was much more amusing.
He leaned in close, âoooh, Peter has a crush! When are you gonna propose?â
Peter shoved Edmund to the ground.
âEd! Are you alright?â
You were the first to move. you lent a hand out for him to grab on, and he took it. Looking at Peter with a grin on his face.
He stuck his tongue out.Â
You giggled at the action.
If Edmund didnât already taste wrath, he would certainly see it.
Peter smiled at the memory.
And now, heâs looking at you and Prince Caspian discussing a strategy to dethrone the current Telmarine King.Â
Not only is he leading the Narnians (not even from his own land), but heâs gotten your attention.Â
The only man that has ever grabbed your attention was him.
You used to laugh at his unfunny jokes. Get angry when he has done something relatively stupid (which is to get your attention). And look at him, like the weight of the crown didnât matter because he matters to you.
Now, youâre doing that with someone younger than he was.
Well, he and Prince Caspian were the same age, but still. He was 1300 years old.Â
Why did you treat Prince Caspian differently when they were basically the same age?Â
Why did you trust him more when he knew you for far too long?
You then looked at his direction. Your eyes stayed long but turned cold quickly. Then you bowed your head to Prince Caspian and left the vicinity.Â
The banquet was far too much. After the Pevensies were crowned as Kings and Queens, the Narnians hosted a beautiful dinner. It was just, you had a lot on your mind.Â
You went out on the balcony. Not to get fresh air, in Narnia, thereâs always fresh air, but to think. You leaned against the cement and stared out in the lush forest.Â
âWell, if it isnât the Brilliant, what are you doing out here?â
You turned your head and looked at the boy before you.Â
âWhy, hello there, the Magnificent. Shouldnât you be charming to your people?âÂ
He laughed and walked towards you, âI canât be charming if one of them left the banquet to go here.â
You tilted your head, âhm, then you should go work on that then.â
He finally reached you. Although, the proximity was too close but far at the same time. You donât dare move to close the distance.Â
âAre you worried? That Aslan has knighted you as the Protector of Narnia?â
âAre you? Being the High King of Narnia is no easy job.â
Peter chuckled at this, âthatâs why Aslan crowned all my siblings as royalty. So the burden isnât mine alone.âÂ
He reached out but stopped himself. His hand was just floating in the air.Â
You giggled at the action, âWhat were you gonna do?â
âSomething Iâve been trying to stop myself from doing.â
You hummed, âI can see that.â
You face Peter and let one hand lay on his chest, close to his heart. Beating. One second. And then another.Â
âMy, has the High King been charmed?â
Peter puffs his cheek and leans forward, he whispers, âI canât help but notice that youâre falling for me.â
You grinned, and whispered back, âyouâve been falling for me.â
âAlright, alright. Just, donât tell my siblings.â
âI think theyâve known it before you did.â
âThen donât confirm it.â
You donât know who leans in, but both of you felt content afterwards.
âPeter likes older women.â
âNow is not the time to joke, Ed.â
âBut itâs true! You do believe me, donât you, Lu?â
âIt does make senseââ
Edmund and Lucy snickered as Susan rolled her eyes. Peter stood there just daydreaming of what had happened.Â
Peter knew what Edmund was doing. He was trying to lighten up the mood after the raid that happened a few days agoâmore specifically, what happened between Peter and Prince Caspian.Â
âThink about it,â Edmund pointed at Peter, âIt looks like he fell harder when she got older.â
Peter furrowed his eyebrows, but Susan spoke for him, âtheyâre literally the same age!â
Lucy chimed in, âThat was a year ago. Now, sheâs way older than him! You need to catch up, Peteââ
âYou two barely have experience with love!â
âAnd you do with Prince Caspian? Oh pleaseââ
Peter goes back into his mind and replays what Lucy said, Now, sheâs way older than you! You need to catch up, Pete.
You barely left Aslanâs How. Which is so unlike you because youâve always tended to be the first one to leave.Â
You feel eyes staring at you, âcome to apologize to Prince Caspian? Heâs out right now.â
He scoffed at this and muttered, âif anything, he should be apologizing to me.â
You sighed and finally looked back at him, âthen why are you here?â
He made a step towards you, âI came here to talk. To you.â
âDo I need a conversation topic to talk to you?â
âWell, thatâs how conversations work.â
He now stood in front of you. He sees your face much more clearly. You were by no means an old woman. You still look like an adult, but now with a few smile lines. Little gray hairs peaking out of your healthy hair. And that was the thing, you looked older than Peter. And he didnât like that at all. He thoughtâ
Youâd see him just as old too.Â
Now it will be a long time till you see that.
âHow long have you ruled?â
It felt like you stopped breathing. You fisted your hands,Â
You were in the training grounds, teaching some of the new recruits about swordsmanship. Then you turned to the sound of the voice.
âThe Kings and Queens are missing!â
You dropped your sword, âWhat? Werenât they on a horse ride a few hours ago?â
âYes, but they havenât come back. No one saw them in the borders of Cair Paravel.â
You turned to the new, âAlter the army, search every inch of Narnia. If theyâre in danger, they would certainly leave clues.â
They saluted and ran off.Â
Itâs been days. No sign of the Kings and Queens.Â
Cair Paravel was in the dark of their rulers being missing. Only the ones in the castle knew what actually was going on.Â
Someone barges in the library and you look up, âMr. Tumnus?â
âHello, sweetie, how are you feeling?â someone spoke from below and you looked down.Â
âMrs. Beaver, what are you doing here?â
âWeâre worried too, kid,â Mr. Beaver replied.
âAnd we have a proposition,â Mr. Tumnus chimed in.Â
They all looked at each other before speaking, âYou have to go find for themââ
âWeâre already doing that.â
âNo, alone. Not in Narnia, but the places outside of it.â
You stopped at this, and looked towards them.Â
âAnd leave Narnia even more defenseless? Not a chance.â
âKid, thereâs no other optionââ
âAnd this is the best option? Leaving the crown to go find people who we donât even know if theyâre alive?â You bit your tongue.Â
âDear,â Mrs. Beaver started, âwe are not asking as Narnians, but as your friends. We know you could find them, however long it takes. But you will find them. We trust you and they trust you to do so.â
You shut your eyes. But nodded.Â
âMaybe youâre right. I wouldnât have been fit to rule anyway.â
You should have never listened to them.Â
After your leave, Narnia was attacked. And you couldnât get back in time because you were on the other side of the world.Â
After the news broke, you got to Narnia as fast as you could, but it was too late. Everything. Everything was in shambles.Â
You gathered survivors and led them to somewhere that was safe.Â
The next day, when everything was already torn, you went back.Â
It was an awful sight. Corpses are treated as mountains. The once beautiful buildings turned into awful bricks.Â
You stopped at the center. The throne that was once the highlight of Narnia.Â
You stared at the four broken seats.Â
You unleashed your sword, and screamed, cutting each one of them. Especially the one in the center. That seems to be the one least broken.
You crumpled down on the ground. Gasping for air. Your body achesânot because you stayed up all night, but the stress that has never left your body when they left.
Every single one of them.
You told Peter this and it was silent for a long moment.Â
âYou left Narnia? To adventure all over the world?â
âI did not adventureââ
âWell, it was quite idiotic to leave Narnia all aloneââ
âIâve told you why I had to go!â
âThen why did you listen to them?! You knew the risk, yet, yet you still went!â
He shouted this as if he wanted the whole world to hear.
âYou didnât give any possible certainty that it would have been something reasonable!â
You pointed at his chest and walked forward, he stepped back, âWhat could I have thought? âMaybe the Pevensies needed a break and didnât say anything?â âMaybe they had an alliance and had to fight an impossible battle?â Maybe, maybe, maybe! I didnât know where in the bloody hell you were!â
âI was back in London!â
âAnd I was supposed to know that?! Iâm not a mind reader, Pevensie.â
You said his name as if you were scolding a child.Â
âCould have fooled me, youâve lived long enough to know who I am. And youâre still living.â
You both heard a gasp and people shushing, but you both ignored it.Â
âYouâve left our people and look what happened to Narnia! It was unreasonable to think that we would have been anywhere elseââ
âOh, I get it now. Youâre blaming me. For all this.â
He stopped stepping back. You continued.Â
âEver since you came here, I wonder why you needed to take control. Yes, you were King, but do you really think people trusted you? That you could take back whatâs yours? No one here trusts you. Theyâd rather trust Prince Caspian over you, because they didnât screw up to prove to them you were better.â
That struck Peter. He was never jealous of Prince Caspian, but what he has done. And Peter has done nothing.
Peter grabbed your wrist harshly.
âI could say the same thing for you, youâre a coward. You only left because you werenât confident to rule. Youâre selfish to think you could find people who could rule when you couldnât. Thatâs why you keep an eye on Prince Caspian, because he reminds you of me!â
And he left. Again. As simple as that.Â
He met his siblings and Prince Caspian behind the room. Lucy was crying and the other three looked down.Â
You woke up in the comfortable bed that you so loved, and cuddled by the comfortable man you so adored.
You groaned as you tried to get out of his hold.Â
You were free for just a second.
Till he pulls you back down and smashes his head on your shoulder.
He groaned and tightened his grip on your waist.
He chuckled at that and opened one of his eyes, he pretended to think, âhm, no.â
âYouâre keeping me as a hostage?â
âYouâd like that, wouldnât you?â
Your cheeks dusted pink, and put your palm to his face, pushing him away, âUgh, you pervert.â
âOnly for you, darling.â
âOh, get ready, stop with your dilly dally.â
He blinked and got up, changing into his royal attire. You roll and lay on your stomach, enjoying the view.Â
âYouâre going out with your siblings tomorrow, right?â
âMhm,â he stretched and popped a bone.Â
âWhat will you be doing?â
âYou mean âhorse racing.ââ
âOh, it wonât come to that.â
âIt always does, when it comes to you.â You glare at him.
He hummed and looked back at you, âAre you sure youâre not coming? What is it that youâre doing again?â
âTeaching the new recruits rules and swordsmanship.â You pouted, dreading tomorrow.Â
âAw, my darling is so hard working.âHe mocked.
âDonât patronize me.â
âAre you sure youâre not coming? I feel like tomorrow will be an interesting day.â
You squinted, âAre you finally proposing?â
âWould it kill you to be surprised?â
âNot unless you actually do it.â
He smiled, âThen be there tomorrow.â
You stand at the center of Aslanâs How. Your conversation with Peter replaying over and over again.Â
He doesnât understand, of course he doesnât.
When you first laid eyes on him after all these years, it hurt you more than anything. You got to see Peter when he was just the same age as you.Â
And now, he looks about half your age. Not even considering youâre 1300 years old.Â
You wanted to grow together, but now, you donât see it possible.Â
You havenât seen his 1 year of growth.Â
He hasnât seen 1300 years scourging for salvation. Â
He is the Peter you loved; hot-headed, action-oriented, selfless, charming boy.
But he wasnât the man you were with.Â
And you couldnât give back 1300 years of wandering around the world to have your Peter back.Â
Someone stood beside you. And held your hand, you looked down,
âIt isnât your fault.â
Lucy looked at the Lion statute.
âYou came back, and helped the last remaining Narnians. You would have always done that.â
âItâs not Peterâs fault either.â
You wanted to speak. That boy has done nothing but complainâ
âAfter we came back to London. He just stares at the wardrobe thinking heâs going back here.â
You blinked at that. Lucy continues,Â
âWhenever he sees a closet, he would just sit in it. Edmund and Susan thought he went insaneâwhich he did.â
âBut he just wanted to get back here. To you.â
You started shaking after this. You didnât cryâyou havenât cried for so long. You put your palm over your mouth.
You just tightened your hold on Lucyâs hand.
âI hope tomorrow goes well.â
The fight had been brutal. But it is over now.Â
You stood inside Aslanâs How and wandered around it. Until you bumped into someone.
He raised his eyebrows, âare you looking for someone?â
âIs it that obvious?â
âWell, thereâs one person who needs you at the moment.â
He told you the directions to a room and you followed.Â
You reached a door and pushed it open.
You find Peter trying to bandage his arm. The arm that he almost broke when he fought Miraz.Â
âWhy donât you ask for Lucyâs Cardinal?â
He looked startled for a moment, and looked back to you, âI wouldnât want to intrudeâmany Narnians are far more injured than me.â
You sighed, âstubborn as always,â you walked towards him.
âIs there somethingââ
âGive me the bandage. Youâre not very good at taking care of yourself.â
He was about to chuckle when he stopped himself. He handed you the bandage.
You started to wrap the bandage gently on his shoulder.Â
This is what usually happened back then. Although you were the knight, Peter got more injured and you always took care of him. Always berating him for not asking for Lucyâs help.Â
But when this usually happened, the both of you were quiet.
Because you hate seeing him injured, and he hates that you see him injured.Â
âI didnât want to leave.â
You stopped and continued your movement, he continues talking,
âI hoped that everyday Iâd go back here. Hope that everything doesn't change. Hope that you don't change.â
You tied the bandage and retreated your hands, he grabs both of your wrist,
âBut none of those things end up happening.â
âYou didnât knowââ
âAnd I should have been more convincing for you to come with me that day.â
You breathed out, âYou wouldnât have known Iâd come with you back to London. Sometimes Aslan is unpredictable as ever.â You laughed quietly to yourself.Â
âTrue, but you would have known where I was.â
In rare moments, you find yourself talking to the Peter you once had. The wise and cheeky man. But you remember he wasnât.
It was quiet again. But it isnât so bad anymore. It was the quiet you grew to love when you were with Peter.Â
The tree opened up a portal to another world.Â
âHow do we know he is not leading us to our deaths?!â
Reepicheep looked at Aslan, âSire, if my example can be of any service, I will take eleven mice though with no delay.â
Peter steps forward, âWe'll go.â
Edmund tilted his head, âWe will?â
âCome on. Our timeâs up.â
Peter walks over to Caspian and offers his sword.
âAfter all, weâre not really needed here anymore.â
âI will look after it until your return.â
Susan looks at him, âIâm afraid thatâs just itâŚWeâre not coming back.â
Lucy looks surprised, âWeâre not?â
Peter chimed in, not before he looked at you, âYou two are.â
You look down and you donât listen in the conversation.Â
Heâs no longer coming back. For good this time.
At least, now you know where heâll be.
âIâm glad I came back.â
âI wish we had more time together.â
âIt would never have worked anyway.â
I am 1300 years older than you.Â
Susan walks away, and then turns back. She kisses Caspian, and then they embrace.Â
âIâm sure when Iâm older Iâll understand.â
âIâm older and donât think I want to understand.â
You chuckled at the interaction, âOh, young love.â
âYouâve been in love once before.â
You looked at Aslan and he smiled. You nodded, âonce.âÂ
You look at Peter and wave. See you later. At least, thatâs what you hoped that came across.
Heâd want to grab you and youâd all go back to London. He would see your youth and youâd look the same age again. Maybe youâd be in love in London. Maybe youâd finally get married there.Â
But as his siblings started walking towards the tree, the possibility started to get less probable.
Youâd never see him again.
And heâll never see you.
But at least he knows you're alive.
And at least you know where he is.Â
And as Lucy finally disappears.
You know you wouldnât see him again.
The night in Cair Paravel is peaceful.
After the Pevensies left, and Prince Caspian took over the crown, nothing has looked peaceful since.Â
But you found yourself at the center of the throne.
They were rebuilt after you destroyed them.
The middle one, the largest and most formidable looks hunted.Â
You started inspecting it, going around in circles. Then you stopped in front of it and touched the armrest.Â
It would have fit him if he were still High King.Â
You fell to your knees and your body shook. You didnât cryâyou couldnât cry for someone that wasnât yours.
It was a faith worse than death. Knowing that you were both alive but could never see each other.Â
If only youâd be in the same timeline.Â
Maybe living for thousands of years would be bearable.
You felt a hand touch your shoulder, and you immediately hugged him.
âI know how you feelâŚI know I wouldnât be able to see her ever again. And you wouldnât see him either.â
You looked at Prince Caspian and he looked down at you.Â
Two people, who would be alive for quite some time, have to think about people whoâd never come back.
âWe will be able to see them,â you started.
âWe will be able to see themâŚif we choose to remember.â
a/n: huhu, sorry again if this isn't what you requested. I just loved your ideas and added on to them!