im4egghead
replied to your post
āCurious about your opinion on Solas' feelings for the Inquisitor? He...ā
I didn't see what he said to her as "racism" personally. To me: All he meant by not like the other elves is she's more open minded. The dalish are more set in their ways and are more secluded. Kinda like how some people are set in their "religion." He said her clan was different for even having an interest in human affairs to send her to the council. Most dalish don't and could care less about shems and what they do and here she is helping the shems.
Hi there. Itās been a long time since Iāve posted or responded to anything on here, and itās taken me nearly a week of waffling to decided whether to respond or not but this is something too important to just brush aside.Ā
I specifically say in my character metas that my interpretations are not sacrosanct. Everyone is allowed to disagree and headcanon as they like, because fundamentally thatās what fandom is for. Itās a space for you to take a character we as a community know, and then show us the little details that you suss out. Everyone interprets a story differently because weāve all lead different lives.
But this reply is not an interpretation of character, or story.Ā
We donāt get to headcanon what racism is and what is not.Ā
Solasā dialogue is a more subtle form of racism than perhaps throwing out racial slurs, but itās still an insidious mindset that cannot be overlooked.Ā āYou are not like the rest of your kindā assumes that Solas knows how the rest of the Dalish are. Itās a racially based stereotype. Which...is racist.Ā
And look, I understand thereās a certain amount of knee jerk defensiveness to being told your fave is problematic, but this is just not up for debate. Racial stereotypes are getting black men killed by cops IRL. Theyāre a factor in why asian american women are something like six times more likely than average to be victims of domestic abuse.Ā
Have you heard this same dialogue between Solas and Adaar?
āQunari are savage creatures, their ferocity held in check only by the rigid teachings of the Qun. But you have shown a subtlety in your actions. A wisdom that goes against everything I know of your people.ā
DA:I has Bioware going out of their way to show that each and every one of your companions is, by some facet of their personality, unconventional by the rules of their own worldbuilding. Not all Qunari are savage, or need to be bound by the Qun. We know this, because we know Iron Bull. We know that not all mages wish to be free of the Circle through violent means, because we know Vivienne, who uses the Circles in order to improve the lives of mages from within the existing structures of power.
And in the context of this meta, where I am discussing whether or not Solas even ascribes PERSONHOOD to a modern Thedosian, his own words are a very strong argument that no, he does not. Or, perhaps, wishes not to.Ā
TL;DR: āRacismā doesnāt always look like supremacist rhetoric. You might want to keep that in mind. Making assumptions about someone due to their race is in fact racist. Thereās that pesky saying about those who assume, after all.Ā




















