requested by anonymous:
RATING: RELIABLE
The above is from this article from The Guardian.Ā The images are from MYA Network.Ā The caption on their website reads:
Source:Ā āWhen a sperm and egg get together, the body creates tissue in order to support the developing pregnancy. Ā Here are photos of that tissue from 5-9 week pregnancies. Ā This is called the gestational sac, and itās like the āhouseā for the pregnancy. Inside this sac there are cells that have the potential to become a fetus but there is no visible embryo at this stage. We rinsed off the blood and menstrual lining (decidua) for these photographs.ā
The published images sparked a lot of debate, leading to the story being picked up by other news outlets. For example:
Source:Ā āLast week, the Guardian published images of pregnancy tissue after abortions in the first 10 weeks of pregnancy. The small size and appearance of the tissue were shocking to many. We have all absorbed, knowingly and unknowingly, the pervasive anti-abortion narrative that a pregnancy resembles a tiny baby starting in the earliest weeks. Though an early embryo can be seen under the magnification of ultrasound, it can take months for it to be perceptible to the naked eye.ā
Source:Ā āPeople have responded in disbelief, citing the (magnified) images theyāve seen on ultrasounds. [ā¦] āThink of the illustrations on pregnancy and medical websites. The Mayo Clinic, one of the preeminent medical organizations in the country, shows week-by-week illustrations of embryonic and fetal development without any context of scale, like the rulers in the MYA photos.ā
As stated in the article, whilst people talk about aĀ āheartbeatā at 6 weeks, there is no heart developed at this stage - only a group of cells that will become part of the heart.
Source:Ā āBut what exactly do we mean when we talk about a āfetal heartbeatā at six weeks of pregnancy? Although some people might picture a heart-shaped organ beating inside a fetus, this is not the case. Rather, at six weeks of pregnancy, an ultrasound can detect āa little flutter in the area that will become the future heart of the baby,ā said Dr. Saima Aftab, medical director of the Fetal Care Center at Nicklaus Childrenās Hospital in Miami. This flutter happens because the group of cells that will become the future āpacemakerā of the heart gain the capacity to fire electrical signals, she said.ā
It should also be noted that the images show an embryo, not a fetus, until the 9th week.
Source:Ā āIn human pregnancies, a baby-to-be isnāt considered a fetus until the 9th week after conception, or week 11 after your last menstrual period (LMP).ā
The co-founders of the MYA Network responded in a New York Times article.
Source:Ā āMany people, even those who support abortion rights, did not believe the photos were accurate. Some insisted we had deliberately removed the embryos before taking the photos. The images werenāt consistent with those often seen in embryological textbooks, magnified on ultrasounds or used in anti-abortion propaganda; these enlarged images are not what you see with the naked eye after an abortion. A Stanford gynecologic pathologist has validated our photos, but many people could not believe the pictures were presented unaltered.
