Lost in the Remaster: Star Trek, Vintage Special Effects, and the Charm of Old Media
by Ren Basel renbasel.com
Originally created by Gene Roddenberry, Star Trek is a franchise that spans decades. From the original series of 1966 to current shows such as Lower Decks, it stands as a titan of television and pop culture. The real world has undergone incredible change since Star Trekβs first appearance, yet nerds everywhere still find entertainment, inspiration, and hope in its classic episodes. Recently, along with my husband and best friend, I decided I wanted to attempt the gauntlet of watching the entire franchise from beginning to end, revisiting favorites and finally checking out the ones I missed. Media and fandom studies are my passion, after all, and Star Trek is a foundational part of modern American nerd culture.
Starting with the original series proved more difficult than expected. Living in a tiny apartment, we donβt have much space for DVDs, so Star Trek wasnβt in our existing collection. The local public library didnβt have copies, either, and putting in a purchase request doesnβt guarantee it will be made available. My family doesnβt have the funds to pay for every single streaming service on the market, and Star Trek isnβt available on any we do have access to. Piracy was starting to look like the only option, but even that fell flat when we couldnβt find a version with subtitles. Finally we dug it up officially and with subtitles, for free via PlutoTV, but there were still limitations: PlutoTV only streams season one, and season one is only available in the remastered edition that replaced the original special effects with new visuals.
It wasnβt ideal, but, hey, it was Star Trek.
Watching just one episode a week gave us enough time to scrape together savings to get what we really wanted for seasons two and three: the official BluRay release, which includes both remastered and original-release versions of each episode. The remasters are fine, but as a lover of media history and practical effects, Iβm always disappointed to lose a chance to appreciate the originals. It doesnβt matter how good it might look, remasters are never as much fun to me as matte paintings, camera tricks, and whatever the prop department could pull off with ten dollars and some glue.
Finally having the BluRays in hand for season two only affirmed my love of vintage practical effects. Seeing the Enterprise in her original glory, before she was ever rendered in digital form, felt like opening a time capsule. I love time capsules. My favorite pieces of media are always those which capture a moment in time, showcasing the aesthetics, concerns, and culture of the time and place they were created. Star Trek: the Original Series is rooted in the late sixties, when mainstream culture in the United States was experiencing immense upheaval and social change. That context is written all over the show. The vintage effects add to it, grounding it in a very specific time and place. Updating the showβs effects takes away some of that 60s aesthetic, and while some may see it as making the show more timeless, I donβt care for it. To me, seeing what they could pull off before modern technology is half the fun of watching old shows. The ingenuity and creativity of propmakers, makeup artists, and set designers working on shoestring budgets is unparalleled.
To be clear, digital effects are also done by skilled professionals who deserve much more respect and many more labor protections. There are some truly stunning works created with digital tools. That said, I hate when digital effects are used to cover up the practical effects that came before. It feels disrespectful to the original artists, as if telling them their work wasnβt good enough; as if their work was just a placeholder until something better could come along and fix it. Practical effects arenβt a placeholder, theyβre an art form in their own right, and that art form is one for which I have deep appreciation.
It frustrates me that the original, non-remastered episodes were such a pain for us to access, but Iβm very glad to have added them to my personal media collection. No matter what future tweaks Star Trekβs rights holders might make, I can always pop in our personal copies to enjoy the Enterprise and her crew in all their vintage, βoutdatedβ glory. If youβre also too young to remember the showβs original airing, and you have the opportunity to watch the unedited version, I highly suggest you do. Watching the version that aired in 1966 gives the show a charm that no amount of remastering can ever match.
_
Like this essay? Tip me on Ko-Fi, pledge to my Patreon,Β or commission an essay on the topic of your choice!
#the remastered enterprise is NOT my beautiful home or my beautiful wife
Holy shit, Captain Kirk has a tumblr.
Aside from all the issues of preservation and access this brings up, Iβm most reminded of an episode of Reading Rainbow. Levar Burton, who was both hosting that show and playing Geordi in Next Gen at the time, spent a whole episode showing kids how making Star Trek worked. The part I remember best is the special effects. Because the models shown for the ships were so cool and learning that the transporter effect was done with glitter in a tube of water was so fascinating. Anyway, yeah thereβs a real charm to those effects and the drive to make everything look like itβs properly modern for re-releases is so often poorly thought through.



















