A hill I will forever die on is that maven never hated Cal and Elara was not able to fully take Maven’s love away from Cal.
Maven said that what truly took his bond away from Cal was mare not his mother. Sure his mother physically alternated his mind when it came to Cal and fed him wrong and toxic stuff about him, probably telling him that Cal stole all the things that should’ve rightfully been his, including his father’s love. I think deep down maven knew that this isn’t true. And that strong believe finally broke down the minute he saw Cal kissing Mare.
You see that situation wasn’t about Mare, but about Cal. In that moment, Cal proved to him what his mother always said and believed was true, that Cal will always steal everything from him. That Cal doesn’t care about him and would hurt him this way. Maven felt betrayed. He didn’t even fully believe in his own mother’s words, but believed that his brother would never. But now he understands that his mother was correct.
I feel that’s why Elara showed him that footage in the first place. She knew that her abilities weren’t fully taking away that love and so she later tried with basic manipulation, but that didn’t fully take that love away either. Elara probably feared that since maven, to a degree, felt love towards Cal, that he wouldn’t go with the plan because he doesn’t wanna hurt his brother.
After Maven saw that footage and realized that his mother was right and that he was “tricked” by Cal, he didn’t just wanna betray him, he wanted to hurt him just like Cal hurt and betrayed him. (The fact that Cal was the only alive person that hurted/made maven bleed as much as Thomas did says a lot).
But even after all that betrayal, Maven still didn’t fully hate cal. He felt hurt and betrayed by his brother and felt like a fool for believing in him and not in his own mother. But still, he still somehow felt love. And that’s shown in Broken Throne. Maven could’ve did something that forever wounded Cal, it would’ve been the ultimate revenge, better than stealing Mare and branding her; it was showing Cal that the brother he loved was somehow, somewhere, still in there, unwilling to come out. He would’ve gave Cal hope and consequently killing him would’ve been killing that hope and therefore killing the Maven Cal always knew, that would’ve completely destroyed Cal. But he didn’t do that, he didn’t want to hurt him that much for eternity…














