Confessions and Guilt: Complicity Makes Us Laugh
“Complicity is the only understanding.”
Nadine Gordimer
Almost every time we laugh, there is some form of agreement, understanding, insight more importantly complicity. While we witness the story of a friend or a comedian, we understand and see it in our lives, it can happen to us. It may even have happened to some of us, or we may feel embarrassed or ashamed on behalf of the storyteller. When everyone else is laughing, laughing help us to regulate our emotions and feel less guilty. French philosopher Henry Bergson in his classic ‘Laughter: An Essay on the Meaning of the Comic’ writes: “However spontaneous it seems, laughter always implies a kind of secret freemasonry, or even complicity, with other laughers, real or imaginary.”
When we laugh together, it is a bonding experience because we understand and share the complicity, perhaps at times feel guilty for laughing as if we are approving it. Yet laughter comes as a welcome relief to ease the tension, caused by the guilt of the misdemeanours and faults.
Invariably in larger groups, the complicity becomes stronger, people almost laugh in a synchronised chorus. Bergson again points out:
“How often has it been said that the fuller the theatre, the more uncontrolled the laughter of the audience! On the other hand, how often has the remark been made that many comic effects are incapable of translation from one language to another, because they refer to the customs and ideas of a particular social group!”
One of the good ways to create laughter is to make them complicit to your misdemeanours, failings, mistakes, wrongdoings and embarrassments. There is no end to what one can confess to, from the most trivial to some more serious embarrassing situations. Comedians are master of this technique, invariably you will hear the most absurd and wonderful confessions. Not all confessions are necessarily true, nor truth should be an obstacle on the way of a great confession.
Keith Johnstone in his 'Impro for Storytellers’ lists a number of ways you can confess and accept guilt on stage. Some of the ideas below can also be used with friends and family, here is the list:
“Apologize. Confess, e.g. hit and run driver; you sat on a small pet; you were unjust; you stole something; left the bath dirty, etc. Avoid people’s eyes, hang head. Whatever you do, over-explain the reasons for it. Embarrass someone and feel terrible. You forgot to close fridge, gate, airlock, etc. Help people more than they need. Be over-concerned. Borrowed something and didn’t return it. Help people incompetently. Often say, 'Is it all right?’, 'Do you mind?’, etc. Set objects or people on fire. You lied about using contraception. You told someone’s secret. You broke a religious rule.”
When we laugh with complicity, we also recognise that others are as bad as we are in not keeping with the social rules. Complicity helps us to see the ourselves in others. Also we understand the guilt of the other person and feel some guilt ourselves too. Practising with some small confessions can also help in building courage toward sharing more important ones. Perhaps a guilt confessed may not make you feel as guilty or if that confession cause an uproar of laughter. This may also be a small step in being able to laugh at yourself. And this can only be a good thing.
Nat Tsolak
Please see www.theschooloflaughter.com for our next comedy course










