Ok, I feel like Iām going crazy. This is Tales of Arcadia centered btw. For the past 5 years (omg itās been that long since wizards-) I have always stood by my understanding of time travel in the trollhunters/tales of Arcadia universe. To preface, Iām an analyst, thats part of the reason I love Wizards, since they had to crunch down what they had planned into like half the amount of episodes, they had to squeeze in character psychologies and relationships into subtlety (specifically with like Merlin and his kids lol). I see no one else talk about this, but like time travel (pre rott) is cyclical. Like you canāt go back in time to change things, you only solidify what already happened.
My main point of evidence is Morganaās arm. In Trollhunters, we see she has this emerald/green crystal arm, and itās never explained as to why in Trollhunters, but in wizards⦠well, letās work backwards. Morgana gets her green arm from Nari when she is resurrected by the Arcane Order, why did she need to be resurrected and get a new arm? Arthur cut off her arm and she fell to her death; why did this fight happen? Well, she defended a troll while Arthur forced her to join him in hunting them, (letās put a pin in the fact that this troll is Jim), but why were they out chasing trolls in the first place? They broke out of the dungeons; well, how did they get out? Douxie, Claire and Steve FROM THE FUTURE needed to free Jim. So if a=c, Morgana has the green arm we see in Trollhunters because of the time-travelers in Wizards.
Additionally, in Claireās vision in Season 3 of Trollhunters, we see the amulet being made, we get references/allusions to this scene in Wizards when the amulet is, well obviously, being made. A small detail (which was likely an early early tease for Wizards) in that vision, we see someone hand Merlin the crystal within the Amulet
And if you notice (my red circle kinda makes in obvious) this is clearly implied to be Douxie. Now this isnāt exactly how his arm jewelry is exactly styled during wizards, but itās likely they hadnāt solidified that design yet. But you know what the first thing we ever saw of Douxie was?
THIS HAND. Itās the same bracelets. Now, what does this have to do with time travel? That canāt be past āMoppetā Douxie, beacause, 1, these are more modern bracelets, and 2, we are told in Wizards that to forge the amulet, you need TWO MASTER Wizards. It canāt be Moppet Douxie because he is no where near skilled enough to be considered a āmaster wizard.ā So therefore, for the entire franchise to even be possible, the time travel has to have ALWAYS happened. Now, why are Merlinās visions in Trollhunters (Morgana vs Merlin) different than what we see in Wizards (Morgana vs Douxie)? Well there are a few different reasons this could be, one, itās been a long time maybe Merlin is misremembering, he was asleep for Douxieās fight anyway, or, more likely, heās lying about himself facing Morgana as to keep the timeline in tact. Speaking of the timeline, isnāt the whole plot of Wizards them trying and failing to not screw up the timeline?? Hereās the thing. To understand all this, we had to have this deep analysis/meta discussion, this is dramatic irony; THE AUDIENCE knows that everything that is happening is what is supposed to happen for the timeline to continue, but THE CHARACTERS donāt know that. Merlin says to mess with time travel is foolish, therefore itās likely he doesnāt fully understand it either; itās better to not mess with it and never fully understand it than to mess with it and screw up the universe. However, he knows Douxie, Claire, Jim and Steve eventually go back in time, which is likely why Merlin comes up with that plan in the first place despite his past self being flabbergasted with such an idea. Well, you may ask, Douxie was there, why doesnāt he remember? āYou do realize repeated sleep spells can cause memory loss..permanently.ā āHuh, funny, don't remember thatā THIS this throw away joke feels like doubling down on the cyclical time theory. Like they knew what they were doing, they didnāt somehow walk backwards into this distinct type of time travel. It just feels so meticulously crafted for this to be the caseā¦and then I saw no one else saying thisā¦and then RotT happened..and ignored it all. UHGGHGWAHH
Well, if you read all of this, remember thats just a Theory! a Filā is that copyrighted? Idk.
















