33 & 49, please Talk About My Boy
33. How Do You Feel About Lan Qiren
Okay so. As typical with...characters Cygna has opinions about...the question is, do you mean the Lan Qiren we're given in canon, or the Lan Qiren that happens when you fill in a person who - basically, who is the main character rather than a plot device with legs. And I don't mean that in a bad way! In writing, not everyone can be a main character. And some characters exist primarily to - well, MDZS is a romance, so all characters fundamentally exist either to make the leads kiss or prevent them from kissing.
I think Lan Qiren has thoroughly internalized the attitudes of the Lan Sect, even when they are shitty and even when they cause him suffering, and that's. Less than good, in many respects. But at least it's consistent! ...Honestly there are fundamentally two different Lan Qiren...s... depending on whether he's written as particularly strict and stern for a Lan Sect elder...or unusually open and reasonable. The latter is kind of terrifying but I don't think it's out of the question, and my favorite LQR fics tend to put him on that end.
I do always feel for him, that whatever life he'd thought he'd have when he was young got shelved indefinitely because his brother Could Not Be Bothered to lead the sect, or parent, or get a woman's consent before marrying her. (I do not feel for Qingheng-jun.) LQR did do some C- parenting, but At Least He Tried.
49. Is Nie Huaisang More Of A Goody Or A Baddy?
I don't really think that's a helpful question to ask about a character? He's sure a guy who does some stuff! And has some reasons! But, like, weighing them against each other morally is...I don't know, I don't particularly enjoy that.
He is the guy who brought his mob-violenced best friend back from the dead! That's pretty cool, especially if you like Wei Wuxian and think that him being alive is a net positive. And that did lead to finding out and punishing some really uncool crimes. We're into that, right? (mumble mumble inherent flaws in retributive justice mumble)
But he is very much also the guy who looked at a depressed and outcast teenager and, rather than helping him, instructed him on how to not only kill himself but destroy his own soul, to make that previous paragraph happen. That is...less cool. There's no indication that Mo Xuanyu was a Bad Person who Deserved To Be Driven To Suicide (uhhhh, if you think that that's a degree of bad that someone can be, which: no), or even that he had harmed NHS in any way. But he was convenient!
A lot of the MDZS characters have this duality to them - WWX most of all, but as other characters are meant to reflect him, they pick it up to. And I think that's cool! And like - the cultivation world in the book's greatest single flaw, probably, is sorting people into Always Good or Always Bad.
So: Nie Huaisang is a Hot Mess and I like him.