âťť Vantablack âťž
| Poindexter x ftm!reader
fluff / FBI!dex / Dex is shy and awkward / colleague!reader / transphobic statements at work / written with top!operated reader in mind / mention of : psychological issues, fights, blood, scars, agent Nadeem
summary: You’re the cool and skilled colleague Dex admires from afar, until one day you actually talk to him.
A/N: A little something to get your teeth into while I complete my two longer fics. I wish we had more civilian Dex in Daredevil, I loved every single time when he was interacting with others. Please do not see any sexual under-tone in this fic, it is meant to be fluffy and kind of written with asexual!Dex in mind.
wc : 3.9k
English isn’t my first language, sorry for the mistakes
Females DNI
The FBI had always been the best option, the most reasonable one. A stable job, a flawless structure, an opportunity to put his talents to use. It was the best option.
Dex liked his work. He liked the sense of pride blooming in his chest whenever people stared at the three yellow letters stitched onto his uniform with wide, almost dazzled eyes. A soothing warmth purred low in his stomach—the feeling of doing something good, something meaningful, something that mattered.
The hardest part had always been the coworkers, the interactions. It was like an athlete being forced to go through reporters and their intrusive stares just to earn his medal. Dex felt like that athlete. He only wanted to do his job, follow orders, act, then go home. But on the way there, he also had to greet the idiots swarming in the department, offer them coffee whenever he made one for himself, pretend to care while someone rambled about their kid’s first steps.
He had a list ready inside his head, similar to the one he used at Brooklyn Suicide Prevention Center—a neat little A4 sheet, organized into rows and columns highlighted with neutral colors. He forced connections to form across that imaginary page, stopping his lips from parting too quickly and saying something wrong.
It was exhausting, draining.
Sometimes he locked himself inside a maintenance closet, or the bathroom if it was clean. He took deep breaths, trying to steady the subtle tremors in his hands. In those moments, his eyes instinctively searched for a loose nail on a stall door—a sharply tipped brush, a toxic spray can. He let them search for a weapon, because for a brief second it soothed his mind. Then he walked back out, wiping the last beads of sweat from his forehead.
He liked his work. But sometimes it was hard, really hard.
However, within that fog, there was something stirring excitement inside him.
You had been introduced to the department exactly two months ago. Hattley had walked in, her tired eyes and permanently irritated expression accompanying her as always, and rested a hand on your shoulder to draw everyone’s attention toward you. She stated your full name, your CV—and what a CV it was, complete, impressive. That was the first thing that caught Dex’s attention, like a slimy tentacle finally wrapping around its prey before sending out the seven others. Hattley had looked almost proud presenting you, like some rare collector’s item—a knife, a card, a stamp. A smile, rare on her face, had brightened her features for a second, and it was enough to convince everyone of your capabilities.
Dex watched the scene from afar, leaning against the section of wall he often used as support. Arms crossed, he’d initially thought it’d be annoying—bothering. But then the days passed. You didn’t work directly with him, though you wandered the same floor. Agent Nadeem was supervising you while you got used to the agency’s endless offices. Ray was a coworker Dex frequently dealt with, so those were the circumstances in which he saw you—or during meetings, or coffee breaks. He’d also crossed paths with you once outside the building. You hadn’t noticed him.
Actually, you never really noticed him—that’s what he thought. He watched you, observed you perhaps far more than he should have allowed himself to. Yet your eyes rarely met his, and whenever they did, he almost fled from your line of sight.
The first few days, once he realized how he was behaving, he’d wanted to slap himself.
“Got a soft spot for the newbie, Dex?” Mark had asked while taking over his shift, bumping his shoulder in what was supposed to be a friendly gesture. Dex tried changing the subject but Mark was clingy, irritating, intrusive. “Since I’m such a good mate, I’ll tell you a secret,” he’d continued despite Dex’s obvious disinterest. “This guy is not a real one, if you know what I mean.”
Dex hadn’t reacted outwardly, making Mark sigh before wandering off to bother someone else instead. But once home, Dex searched your name online.
He understood your trans identity almost immediately, and somehow it had only increased the admiration he felt toward you. Because he wanted to believe you both were similar—no matter how far your life experience must have been from his, you had suffered and he did too. You fought against yourself, your demons—he did too. And maybe that if he was similar to you in this case, he could be in others.
You were so sociable, so comfortable. His eyes couldn’t stop analyzing your movements, trying to understand them, absorb them.
But the thing that fascinated him most was your natural authority. You earned respect without raising your voice or resorting to threats. People gravitated toward you because they instinctively trusted whatever it was you radiated. You handled weapons, hand-to-hand combat, paperwork, and human beings with equal ease.
You were so talented, and it fascinated Dex.
During the monthly training sessions held in a privately rented gymnasium, you were impressive as always. You helped Margot climb the rope, every single one of your bullets hit the target during shooting practice, and you slammed Ray to the floor with admirable effortless strength. Usually Dex avoided those pointless sessions as much as possible, considering they were optional, but to everyone’s surprise he signed up—just to watch the spectacle.
And because of that, he didn’t even notice that his own shots landed within the exact same crater every time, nor that he’d been among the fastest to climb the rope, nor even that he’d nearly dislocated Mark’s shoulder during the mock arrests. No, all he saw was your hand gently patting someone’s back in encouragement, the sweat sliding down the exposed curve of your neck, the lines your muscles drew beneath your skin with every movement. That was all he saw, with an expression that was absolutely not subtle.
One day, you spoke to him. He remembered it vividly.
It had been late in the evening. The sun was particularly inspired that day, painting magnificent palettes of color across the sky. Only a few people remained in the break room. Dex was grabbing coffee to survive the field mission waiting for him in less than an hour. The overly strong-smelling liquid was pouring into his paper cup when you detached yourself from the group you’d been talking with for a while.
The second he saw you approaching, Dex tried to run away like he always did, but the coffee hadn’t finished pouring yet.
“Hey, heading to Red Hook?” you asked with a smile, leaning so naturally against the wall.
Dex made a superhuman effort not to let his eyes drift toward the curves your arms created when you crossed them over your chest. Yes, he was heading to Red Hook—for a narcotics arrest operation. He was wearing his SWAT uniform, a khaki set that attracted far too much attention for his liking.
“Yes,” he answered simply, already feeling panic rising inside him.
The coffee machine finally stopped pouring. Dex grabbed the cup with visibly trembling hands and quickly escaped the situation.
You had watched him leave, brows slightly furrowed, a faint amused smile on your lips. Poindexter was always like that around you. It was strange, but you didn’t take it personally.
The foam ball traveled at a steady speed between the wall and his hand. A barely audible sound marked the impact against the clean white surface before Dex caught the object again without even looking at it.
He was bored. He was on call, which meant sitting around the office waiting for a potential emergency in his sector. He wasn’t alone—the FBI offices were never completely empty—but throwing a ball wasn’t exactly disruptive.
Another sigh slipped past his lips. Dex stared at the ceiling, lazily rocking his rolling chair while never missing a single throw. That ball—that distraction—was always tucked away at the bottom of his work backpack. Not large or solid enough to concern security, but substantial enough to occupy his restless mind during moments like these. He only took it out when he was alone in a room. He didn’t want to attract attention in a potentially dangerous way. But maybe the exhaustion mixed with the complete absence of events for too long kept him from hearing your footsteps approaching the office he’d been assigned to.
He heard the handle. His eyes snapped toward the metallic object lowering just before the white neon light flooded the room. You appeared in the doorway precisely as the ball flew past your head before bouncing neatly back into Dex’s already outstretched hand.
“Oh wow—trying to kill me, Poindexter?” your voice smiled while you leaned casually against the open doorframe.
Irony always took longer for him to process when you were breathing the same air as him. Dex straightened up immediately, like a child caught doing something forbidden. The ball squeezed tightly in his palm, he tried regaining control over the panic rapidly building inside him.
You were here. He’d been caught throwing an object. You were here. Why were you here?
“Huh—no, no, of course not.” He awkwardly cleared his throat. “What are you—doing here? I mean, it’s late.”
Benjamin Poindexter had always been somewhat of an enigma to you. He kept to himself, avoided social interactions like the plague, and yet he remained one of the agency’s best agents to date. Avoid forming attachments, never bring your private life to work—those were unavoidable rules drilled into all of you the hard way from day one. Working for the FBI demanded constant emotional and intellectual effort. Trust was one of its central pillars, yet everyone was taught to expect betrayal eventually.
Even served on the prettiest silver platter, beside the finest dishes imaginable, a knife remained a knife and a fork remained a fork. Useful, necessary—but their steel prongs stayed sharp. Ready to feed mouths in need, or stab a butler in the back.
Dex looked like he’d mastered that art of the table called “FBI”. He offered parts of himself whenever required, then bared his teeth the second someone tried to polish him smooth.
“Hattley wants some files on her desk by six in the morning, so here I am.” Your hands lazily gestured toward yourself before crossing over your chest again, unintentionally drawing even more attention to that area.Â
Your gaze wandered around the room opening before you. A space no larger than a small bedroom, suffocated by heavy filing cabinets storing old case reports. A desk organized down to the millimeter whenever Dex was on duty. A computer screen that was barely ever used. A cold coffee cup dreaming of its past warmth. And in the middle of that landscape stood Poindexter. He was looking at you again with that same intensity that had unsettled you since day one. You felt like you were watching a child stare at their favorite teacher. At first, you’d assumed maybe he was simply curious about the fact that you were trans—because yes, nothing truly remained secret inside the Federal Bureau of Investigation. That slightly too-wide stare whenever you entered a room had seemed like the kind of unhealthy curiosity you’d unfortunately grown used to. The kind that led to invasive questions or offers to “experiment.”
But eventually you realized it was different. Poindexter had never attempted any sort of approach. Quite the opposite—he physically avoided you while unconsciously seeking a connection he couldn’t control.
During conferences, whenever you spoke, his gaze burned through your entire body. Not like a fleeting warmth. His eyes scanned you with such intensity that you could almost feel spikes piercing through the deepest layers of your organism. Tiny injections of unknown substance.
“You?” you shattered the silence beginning to wrap its suffocating hands around the room. Dex visibly swallowed. You watched his Adam’s apple ride the tight elevator of his throat.
“On-call duty.”
You already knew that. You’d checked the on-call schedule earlier just to see who would be keeping you company during your late-night work. But conversation had to start somewhere.
The blue foam ball had absorbed the faint sweat coating Dex’s palm. He sat up straighter again, his back cracking pleasantly with the movement. You were looking at him, and he felt like he was being evaluated for an exam he hadn’t prepared for.
His office suddenly seemed even smaller. The walls had judgmental eyes. And something kept whispering in his ears. Pathetic, you can’t even hold a conversation, this is embarrassing. He wanted to slap himself hard enough to restart the machine inside his head—the one responsible for telling him how to behave in public. What to say. What to do. When to smile, when to speak, when to let others speak.
But the machine malfunctioned whenever you were nearby. It was as if Dex only had a flashlight for company, and you were some living Vantablack swallowing every trace of light from his pathetic little beam. It terrified him. He hated feeling those hands regain control the moment you turned off the light. Or rather—to be honest—the problem was that he adored it. And that was dangerous, because uncontrollable. He’d spent years keeping those hands restrained, those hooked nails tearing into his flesh and making him feel like he could finally breathe. The blood pouring from those wounds was his oxygen. But he kept it far away from himself, only allowing enough to surface that he could still maintain control over it.
Your footsteps echoed too close to him, dragging him violently out of the spiral of his thoughts.
“You’re pretty good with this.” Your hand rested naturally against the back of his chair, your warmth radiating enough to flush his skin. “Aim. Shooting.”
He was suffocating. He was certain he must’ve been visibly sweating by now, maybe even breathing too heavily. You were so close. Everything felt dark.
“You know, I read some of your files. Not to be weird, but you’re talented, Dex. Actually, I was… kinda impressed.” Your eyes lingered on the top of his head, perhaps a little too long on the different shades of blond threading through his hair.
You were sincere. Truly sincere. Some considered it a bad habit, but you liked skimming through the files of the people you worked with. If someone was going to stab you with a fork, you might as well know who sharpened it.
There weren’t many attachments in Poindexter’s FBI file. Mission reports, handwritten notes from former military superiors, a few photographs of him in various uniforms—basic military gear, then higher-ranking attire, FBI SWAT equipment, civilian clothing. And buried beneath all the praise-filled reports, you’d also found two or three pages heavily blacked out. But you recognized the logo printed at the top of each one. The department responsible for government employees’ mental health and psychological evaluations. It didn't surprise you. Everyone had mandatory evaluations every three months—including you.
“Impressed?” he somehow managed to say.
“Yeah, impressed.” You stepped away from his chair, his warmth beginning to affect you too. Instead, you leaned against the corner of his desk and sat there absentmindedly.
Dex looked like he’d just walked into a wave of scorching wind. His hair was slightly disheveled—remarkable feature considering how meticulously arranged it usually was. His chest, hidden beneath a white shirt and sweater, rose and fell at an obviously uneven pace. You didn’t worry about it. He often reacted like this around you—maybe you’d simply grown used to it.
His trembling hand brushed against his forehead, trying to restore some illusion of control—or confidence. “Thanks, but I think you’re the one supposed to incite impressiveness.” Maybe he should stop talking. But exhaustion made words slip too easily past the filters he normally forced them through.
You chuckled softly, fatigue making you easier to approach—to hold in a hand like his. “Well, I’ll take the compliment, thank you. But I’m not the one with an FBI SWAT uniform in my wardrobe. And I definitely can’t throw a ball like you do.”
He wasn’t only talking about work, but you couldn’t know that.
Dex finally loosened his grip on the poor suffocating ball, staring at it for a moment. “I can—show you, if you want.”
A genuine smile spread across your lips. “I’d love to.”
In the whistling silence of the FBI offices, a faint echo began bouncing through the room, interrupted by quiet laughter and all those mute little things the human body created. A breath caught because of a perfectly controlled gesture. Sparks trembling deep within irises. The tightening of the vital organ called heart. Poorly organized paperwork waited peacefully for your return, abandoned on the desk that belonged to you. The surveillance camera kept performing its usual mechanical sweeps across the spacious main office where you were technically supposed to be working. It scanned the room robotically, imprinting the digital landscape into its artificial memory. If it had possessed intelligence—and a soul—it might’ve noticed your reflections in the glass. Standing close together. Maybe it would’ve appreciated the smile brightening your face with every flawlessly executed throw from your coworker. And if it had been truly attentive, perhaps it would’ve heard the child buried deep inside Dex laughing loudly and freely because you were there, and you were so kind to him, so attentive, so interested.
His flexible wrist moved with a precision that couldn’t help but captivate you. You wished you owned glasses capable of altering reality itself, just so they could show you the numbers activating beneath your eyes. The angles, distances, perfectly measured equations producing such precise results every single time. It was math. Purely math. Nothing supernatural or magical. And yet watching the ball strike the exact intended point again and again made mathematics suddenly feel like the closest thing to magic—when mastered that perfectly.
Dex struggled to swallow properly. His mouth had gone dry. You listened to his explanations with such genuine interest that it made him dizzy.
“Your fingers need to be aligned around the ball, like—imagine there’s two lines here.” His fingers fought to control the tremors shaking his entire body while tracing imaginary lines around the blue sphere. “And you just have to remain still while throwing it.”
Your brows furrowed in concentration, forming a fixed wave between them. Your fingers followed his instructions perfectly, settling along the invisible lines you tried to picture beneath the spongy texture. You glanced toward the man sitting in front of you, leaning too far forward in his chair. He was already watching you, though his eyes immediately darted back toward the ball once your gaze met his.
“And it makes it curve, doesn’t it?” Your question visibly surprised him. He hadn’t expected you to understand the movement’s physics so quickly.
“Yes. Like crazy.” The smile on his lips made his voice vibrate softly. “Have a try.”
You turned away from Dex, pushing yourself off the desk to face the wall he’d been throwing toward. The wheels of his chair squeaked quietly as he rolled backward for a better view of you. His trained eyes scanned your entire body—not to admire it, but as a security scanner analyzing data to ensure everything aligned correctly.
Your shoulder sat too far back. Your elbow wasn’t raised enough. The distance between your face and the ball was wrong. Dex’s mouth parted instinctively, wanting to correct your entire posture so everything would be perfect, so you’d succeed, so you’d realize he was a good teacher.
But you spoke before he could.
“Whatcha think? Am I doing good or bad?”
His eyes returned to your face, truly looking at you this time rather than the calculations clouding his vision. “Don’t arch your back. Lift your elbow a little more and bring the ball closer to your face.”
You adjusted your stance, trying to follow the new instructions. But judging from the restrained expression on Poindexter’s face, you understood it still wasn’t right. “Maybe you should adjust it for me?” Dex’s strangely colored eyes widened before he could stop himself, making you chuckle softly. “If it’s okay for you, of course.”
“Yeah—yeah, it’s okay,” he corrected himself quickly, nearly tangling his own tongue.
Once again the chair squeaked as his weight left it, almost like an incomprehensible complaint. He took advantage of the moment you looked elsewhere to wipe his sweaty palms against his thighs. His tangible silhouette moved behind you, casting an additional shadow beside your own against the wall. You heard the air scrape painfully through his throat when he breathed, the moisture in his mouth, even his faint heartbeat.
His right hand wrapped around your wrist with barely restrained weakness, adjusting it so slowly you briefly wondered whether Poindexter had the ability to turn you into porcelain and feared you’d shatter beneath the slightest pressure. It was unsettling in a way you couldn’t properly describe. To be touched without sexuality being the reason. Without it existing anywhere inside the gesture.
“You must be able to see the ball in your peripheral vision, if that helps,” his voice murmured above your shoulder. The position was now perfect. Dex stepped back to admire the structured line your arm created.
You understood the silent permission and refocused. If you really concentrated, you could almost see the faint crater formed where that ball had struck the wall countless times before. That was your target. A deep breath filled your lungs before you held it to eliminate any unwanted movement. Then you threw.
The ball nearly hit the exact spot, grazing it. You let out a quiet groan of fleeting disappointment. But for a first attempt, it was already impressive. You knew that.
You stepped forward to retrieve the small object rolling across the floor, attempting a pathetic little escape. Behind you, Dex stared at the precise point where the ball had struck the wall. You’d miscalculated the shift of impact caused by your arm movement. But you’d still nearly hit the target—good thing.
“Seems pretty fair for a first try,” you said while straightening up. “If I beat you in a single throw, it wouldn’t be funny, would it?” Your outstretched hand captured his softened gaze, an expression you’d never seen on his face before. He looked comfortable. Less tense.
“I guess.” His fingers brushed against the sensitive skin of your palm to get back the ball.
A comforting silence attempted settling between you both—bringing along its oversized pillows and heavy blanket. You let it happen, while Dex no longer seemed capable of noticing it. Something told you comfortable silence was a recurring concept for the awkward man standing before you. A familiar subject he’d stopped recognizing long ago because it had followed him everywhere.
But suddenly, the artificial sound of a notification echoed through the room, making both of you turn toward its source. An email had appeared on your coworker’s computer. One he had to answer.Â
And suddenly reality caught up with you like a slap softened by a cotton glove.Â
You had work too. A lot of it.
As if your thoughts had tangled together, your gazes met again, the same expression carved into marshmallow-textured marble. Disappointment. Melancholy. Peace. The moment was over. But at least it had existed somewhere within those cold walls.
“Maybe we could do this again one day?” you asked.
“Yes, I’d love to,” he answered, unconsciously regurgitating your own words without you noticing.
marvel masterlist
images : Pinterest
dividers : @uzmacchiato , @/cafekitsune , @/kthice and @/solitary-serendipity













