Unravel: Part 9
Tell Me Lies, Alex x Reader
Summary: Y/N meets Alex — the opposite of safe. Might be the beginning of something dangerous.
Warnings: Abusive toxic relationship, Domestic violence, Jealousy
A few days passed.
And somehow, without either of us saying anything about it, a routine formed.
It wasn’t romantic. It wasn’t even something we talked about. There were no “good morning” texts, no plans days in advance, no conversations about what this was supposed to mean.
But five more times that week I ended up at Alex’s place.
It always happened the same way. A short message. Usually from him. Sometimes from me when I was pretending I was bored enough to justify it.
Come over.
You busy.
Door’s open.
Just that quiet pull toward the same place and every time it ended the same way too.
Alex had this way of holding control over a moment without saying much. His hands were always firm, sometimes too firm, and by the time I left his apartment there were always marks somewhere on my skin. Faint bruises along my ribs, fingerprints on my hips, once a darker mark on my shoulder that lasted two days.
None of it felt accidental. He noticed everything. Which meant he definitely noticed the bruises. But neither of us talked about them.
It existed in that strange space between us where things happened but were never labeled.
And the weirdest part?
I kept going back.
⸻
By Thursday night Lucy decided we all needed a break from campus.
Which meant drinks.
The bar was small and dimly lit, the kind of place students packed into because the music was good and nobody cared if you stayed for hours with the same drink.
We were sitting at a corner booth—Lucy, Bree, Pippa, and me—half laughing over something stupid Lucy had just said.
“That bartender is my ex,” Lucy announced casually, pointing her glass toward the bar.
We all turned.
He was behind the counter pouring drinks, tall, blond, the type who probably knew exactly how charming he looked when he smiled at customers.
Pippa blinked.
“That’s your ex?”
Lucy nodded.
Bree leaned forward slightly. “Wait, you dated him?”
Lucy shrugged. “For like… two-ish weeks.”
“That’s barely dating,” I said.
Lucy gave me a look. “It counts if he ghosted me.”
Pippa burst out laughing.
“You got ghosted by him?”
“Shut up.”
We all laughed, and Lucy rolled her eyes but couldn’t stop smiling either.
“Anyway,” she continued, waving it off, “I think I traumatized him..”
“Of course you did,” Bree said laughing.
We stayed there talking for a while, jumping between random topics the way people do after a couple drinks. Classes, gossip, Pippa complaining about one of her professors.
At some point Lucy checked her phone.
“Stephen’s asking where we are.”
Pippa groaned immediately. “Why does he always show up?”
Lucy typed something quickly. “Because I told him where we are.”
“Lucy.”
“What?”
“Now he’s going to bring Wrigley and Evan with him.”
She smiled innocently. “Relax.”
Ten minutes later the door of the bar opened.
And there they were.
Stephen walked in first, scanning the room like he owned the place. Behind him was Wrigley, already grinning at something on his phone, and Evan just a step behind them.
Lucy waved them over.
The booth suddenly got crowded as they joined us, chairs scraping and people shifting around to make space.
Evan sat across from me.
“Hey,” he said with that familiar soft smile.
“Hey.”
Wrigley dropped into the chair beside Bree, immediately leaning closer to say something to her that made her laugh quietly. I noticed the way their shoulders brushed.
Interesting.
Stephen slid into the booth beside Lucy, resting his arm behind her like he always did.
“You guys started without us,” he said.
“You took too long,” Lucy replied.
Drinks appeared, conversation picked up again, the group growing louder and more chaotic the longer we sat there.
For a while it actually felt normal. Until the door opened again.
And Alex walked in.
I noticed immediately. I always did.
He paused near the entrance for a second, scanning the room the same way Stephen had earlier.
Then his eyes landed on our table.
Bree suddenly sat up straight. “Oh,” she said. “Alex.”
Everyone looked at her.
“I totally forgot,” she added quickly. “I texted him earlier.”
Lucy blinked. “You invited him?”
“I didn’t think he’d actually come,” Bree said.
Too late. Alex was already walking toward us. The energy at the table shifted before he even reached it.
Wrigley leaned back slightly in his chair. Stephen’s expression went neutral. Evan glanced between Alex and me for half a second before looking away again.
Alex stopped at the edge of the table.
“Busy night,” he said.
Bree smiled. “Sit.”
He grabbed an empty chair and pulled it over, sliding into the spot at the end of the booth.
Our eyes met for a brief moment. No smile.
Just that familiar, quiet recognition. Lucy looked between us, clearly sensing something interesting.
“So,” she said slowly. “Alex.”
“Lucy.”
She grinned. “Long time.”
“Not really.”
Wrigley snorted into his drink. The conversation picked up again after that, but it felt… different.
Like there was a current running under the table that only a few of us were aware of.
Alex didn’t say much. He mostly listened, occasionally adding a short comment that made people laugh before leaning back again.
But every once in a while I felt his eyes on me. Just quick glances.
At one point Evan asked me something about a class we shared, leaning slightly closer so he could hear me over the music.
I answered normally. But when I looked up again, Alex was watching. His expression hadn’t changed.
Lucy suddenly stood up. “Shots,” she announced.
Everyone groaned but followed her toward the bar anyway. The group scattered for a moment, chairs scraping as people moved.
By the time the drinks were ordered, I realized I’d been left at the table.
Not alone. Alex was still there. Leaning back in his chair, watching me.
“You’ve been busy,” he said quietly.
My stomach tightened slightly. “What does that mean?”
He tilted his head a little. “You haven’t texted today.”
I crossed my arms. “You didn’t text either.”
“That’s true.”
Silence stretched for a moment. The music was louder here. Then his eyes dropped briefly to my arm where my sleeve had shifted slightly. Just enough to reveal the faint edge of a bruise near my wrist.
His gaze lingered there and he looked back at me. Something darker flickered across his expression. “Careful,” he murmured.
“About what?”
His voice stayed low. “People might start asking questions.”
My pulse jumped. “About what?”
But before he could answer, the others came back with the drinks.
Lucy slammed the tray onto the table dramatically. “Okay, everyone,” she said. “Bad decisions time.”
The glasses were passed around, Laughter filled the table again.
But as everyone grabbed their shots, I could still feel Alex’s eyes on me. The room suddenly felt a lot warmer.











