@eliseofthelibrary and @drowninginmytbr here the second part of Scriptorium :D It starts right after the end of the first one.
@hollowholofernees I hope you like the culture parts (even the boring school ones) <3
⚠️ cw: racism, ethnocentrism/cultural supremacy. References and/or graphic descriptions of war violence, famine, cannibalism, human (elven) sacrifice, unconsensual transmutation of souls
Some clarifying introduction notes: Elladan doesn't actually believe that the Elves of Beleriand are inferior (though he was academically educated to think the culture the Noldor inherited from Aman is "superior"), but since he spends a lot of time in Noldor circles, he's nonetheless "absorbed" some of their prejudices. He's been duly reprimanded for this, but precisely because he knows they're wrong he uses them to get a reaction from Elrohir. Basically Elladan is a cazzone as they say here (an insult with the magical property of having multiple, always offensive, meanings, used in this case as "one who makes and/or acts like a fool, or makes inappropriate jokes") lol.
Also the twins are not homophobic, simply naive and particularly dense on matters of the heart (a legendary trait passed down in the family since the time of Finwë at Cuiviénen), especially queer ones because the only frame of reference they have is the elven equivalent of chivalric poems.
They continued poking around until they found a tome bound in leather so dark it looked black, and pages of paper as thin as hair, yet extremely durable. They had never seen anything resembling those materials.
“What kind of paper is this?” Elladan asked almost reflexively, feeling its peculiar roughness under his fingers. It had a strange smell, woody but with a hint of acidity. “It almost feels like horsetail, but it isn't.”
“And it's written in Cirth, not Tengwar…” added Elrohir, who in the meantime had begun to flip through it delicately, trying not to damage it. “Sennight... Behoof... Betwixt... Hoar... Cottier... who uses these terms? How old is this book?”
“Look at the strange drawings!” his brother noticed instead. “Why are the faces and legs in profile but not the torso? And why are the eyes so large?”
“Maybe they didn't know how to draw realistically yet?” Elrohir suggested. “Or rather, look: they all have rims around their eyes, so maybe they all wore makeup? And the men are all bare-chested…”
“So the Moriquendi were indeed effeminate and half-naked.”
“Elladan! You know Grandpa doesn't want those terms used!”
“Well, that's true. Look at the wide hips they all have. Do they look masculine to you?”
“Hmph.” Elrohir reluctantly conceded. “Look, they're all wearing trousers and are barefoot, but some of the soldiers have sashes across their chests. Maybe they're women? So women fought too?”
This surprised them because their grandmother often spoke of how hard she'd struggled as a young girl to be admitted to the Noldor martial arts competitions in Valinor ("of which she was champion!" she proudly emphasized), and how she'd had to beg her brothers to let her fight in the First Age like the men did. But then Elrohir remembered hearing that in Greenwood, where King Oropher was a Sindar traditionalist, women were part of the army and other less-than-feminine activities.
Elladan leafed through the pages delicately, curious. Despite the dismissive tone, something in those images fascinated him. A sixth sense, a calling. Something was different from all the other history books they'd seen.
“Do you see that all the elves in these drawings are Teleri?”
“Grandpa says they're called Lindar. But it's true. This book is very old, so perhaps it's from before the Noldor returned from Valinor? That might explain why everyone looks like…”
Elrohir seemed to be having trouble finding the right word, so Elladan did it for him. “Primitive savages?”
“Elladan! ”
“Okay okay, sorry, come on, now read aloud.”
“Me? Why me?” Elrohir protested, for now he was annoyed with his brother. “You do it!”
“I can't read Cirth!”
“You'd know if you'd listened to Daeron's lessons!”
Although, to be fair, Daeron wasn't exactly an easy teacher to follow. Not because his lessons were difficult or because he didn't pay attention to the children's needs, but because he seemed to harbor a visceral hatred for curriculum design, maintaining that learning was a spontaneous process. He held his classes outdoors, on the edge of the woods, and, despite having invented a script, he actually wrote surprisingly little. He didn't use a blackboard, but drew runes on the ground, and refused to use paper or a textbook, though he reluctantly allowed Elrohir to take notes in a notebook.
When asked why, Daeron explained that the Cirth had been created out of a need for Doriath, now bursting with population, to begin keeping track of supply quantities in the warehouses, the collection and management of taxes, and trade movements. It was therefore not a medium connected to the heart, to the soul, which was where the art of speech was supposed to come from.
(But apparently, it was fine for the Chronicles and Annals, because "History has been fixed in the threads of the Great Weaver, who seals the flows of time in the silk of the past, indelible, unchangeable, the firmest structure of Eä." Just the usual strange, meaningless mysticism from elder elves.)
(They hadn't told him this, though; they didn't want him to be upset.)
It was a miracle that in fifty years they had learned anything beyond the basics of grammar. Rather, Daeron became kind of thir teacher of philosophy and, of course, music.
Now, the boys were already familiar with music: when they were children, their mother would sing to them every night before bed, and even now, as adults, they often find themselves humming those melodies to relax.
But they were also experts in technique. Lindir, their housekeeper and one of the palace minstrels, had already taught them to read sheet music at the age of twenty, because it was said that music was preparatory to mathematics and was therefore essential to the mental and spiritual development of young elves.
Every morning for as long as they could remember, Lindir directed the attendants and waited until the pages had finished preparing them, then led them to the gardens. There, the servants brought breakfast of gingerbread, pear tarts, and almond and blueberry jam in the summer months, almonds and carrots in the colder months, and their parents joined them whenever they could, when they weren't busy with politics and business travel.
Lindir had explained one day that almonds were native to Aman and did not exist in Old Beleriand, when fruit did not yet grow and the Moriquendi foraged for whatever berries they could find in the thick forest. They had been imported to Middle-earth after the end of the War of Wrath and were therefore both a sign of peace and better times to come, traditionally eaten during feasts, and a reminder of home for the Exiles who still wandered these lands (that's why Grandma loved them so much!).
After eating, Lindir would take up his harp and begin to tell of the great deeds of the Noldor, and the children listened raptly. Sometimes it was hard to believe that all those legendary heroes were their relatives. Elladan particularly admired Fingon the Valiant, who had risked everything to save someone dear to him, while Elrohir felt closer to his grandmother's brothers, crying every time he heard of the tragedy of Andreth and Aegnor.
But they found themselves thinking the stories were very incomplete: none of the Chronicles of Gondolin mentioned that Glorfindel loved apple tarts! And the twins saw him take them from their table every morning (despite Lindir's "you could at least deign to take a napkin!" protests). How could Pengolodh not seen him do so once in centuries at the court of the hidden city?
How could they feel close to their relatives if all they had were names on a page?
When they reached school age, Lindir had also taken on the role of tutor, chosen personally by Elrond, and their lessons had been supplemented by grammar, arithmetic, geometry, gymnastics and drawing. At one hundred they had begun working on rhetoric, and at one hundred and fifty on ethics, dialectics, and oratory.
Daeron, however, had never come to collect them. Instead, he waited for them, perched on the branch of the oak tree overlooking the circle of stones within which they would be teaching. He was also habitually barefoot, with his hair loose and disheveled, and his clothes wet with dew. Indeed, there were several rumors that he lived and slept in the woods, and the twins were quite willing to believe them. But there were also opposing rumors that he *didn't sleep at all*, and instead spent his nights wandering the gardens and corridors like a ghost, chanting dirges, his eyes glowing blue like will-o'-the-wisps to lure travelers astray and make them disappear forever without a trace. They were much more skeptical of the latter, however, because they were… well, utterly insane. And because these rumors were primarily human, and humans were known to accidentally distort things over time, adding and twisting details by word of mouth until the tale was unrecognizable from the original facts. It was far more likely that Daeron was simply a night owl, like Grandpa, and took walks to clear his mind of melancholy and dark thoughts.
But he did have something in common with Lindir. Sometimes, after lessons, he would sit in the center of the circle and begin to delicately pluck the strings of his lyre (or more rarely, the cithara or psaltery) and chant the ancient deeds of heroes from the darkest ages. And then the twins understood where Daeron drew his fame, for at his voice, time seemed to slow and the trees themselves strained to listen, and the birds and the moss and the blades of grass, and a longing arose in all who listened. Daeron sang of King Thingol and King Elmo, of tribes whose names were buried in the night, of warriors and hunts, of battles fought in the grip of winter and of beasts fierce and mighty, gigantic mountain lions with teeth like sabers and enormous birds with red plumage, of glowing mushrooms and immense trees taller than towers, of rivers that ran through entire kingdoms and of the stars that would always lead you home.
It was from Daeron that they learned a little more of Galadhon Wolfheart and all those other names their grandfather could only whisper, like Galathil Kindheart and Nimloth Pearlheart and Brethil Doubleblade.
The bard had never even eaten with them, or rather, the twins never took anything from him again after they saw him catch and swallow a live lizard, around their third lesson. They didn't want to risk accidentally eating squirrel skewers, sparrow stew, or any other poor little creature that had the misfortune to become Daeron's lunch.
He also taught them a verbal battle technique common in Beleriand, called the Strife. Two or more parties, composed of a group or rarely a single individual, would face each other, exchanging insults and taunts in the form of verse, with the aim of outdoing their opponent with wit and verbal mastery. There were different styles, but they all featured a syncopated rhythm and rapid, rhyming speech, usually accompanied by dancing and acrobatic dancing. For example, the challenged group chose the style, and if one of the two groups was significantly outnumbered, they were offered the option of asking the other side to choose only some of their members for the competition. Since it was a peaceful solution, weapons could not be used throughout the Strife, and the losing group was allowed to leave safely. Despite the technique's almost sacred status, it was rarely used, because the opportunities for its application were rare: a Strife could be launched only if one tribe accidentally crossed the border into another's territory, as could sometimes happen during a hunt, and only if an agreement could not be reached and the resulting division of prey and/or valuables could not be reached. If, however, the border cross was intentional, armed and hostile, then it was resolved like any war: with blood on the blades.
It was said that it was in Doriath that Finrod Felagund learned this technique, and that it was from the Strife that he drew inspiration for his heroic defiance of Sauron. (Daeron hadn't exactly called it "heroic," but the twins couldn't repeat such terms without getting grounded. Let's pretend he said "unlucky.")
Lindir nearly had a heart attack when he heard them insulting each other in rhyme, because "such foul language is unbecoming, especially of young princes!" But when they said Daeron had taught them, he paled and said nothing more.
Lindir was terrified of the bard, but the twins didn't understand why: Daeron was thin even by Teleri standards, and he'd never handled a blade in his life (except carving tools and kitchen knives, but those didn't count because they weren't weapons. The older Noldor had looked strange when they'd told them, but hadn't said anything).
Although, more accurately, Lindir was afraid of Teleri in general, for some reason. Even of Mom. Mom, Celebrían of the sweet voice! Let alone if we were talking about Grandpa.
However, precisely because these arts were so closely tied to technique, his assessments were even more severe than any Noldo teacher they had ever had, so much so that Elrohir had often found himself frantically leafing through his notes, dreading an oral test the next day.
The cause of this peculiar teaching situation could be traced to the fact that Daeron was actually more of an artist than a pedagogue, and when he had to teach, it was to adults and his interests included music, singing, and drama. If he had agreed to teach literature to a couple of disrespectful and half-atemptive children it was only because Elrond had essentially begged him on his knees. Although it's very likely that Grandpa himself had convinced him, because Daeron obeyed no one but Celeborn.
They knew they were long-time friends, and very close ones at that: Daeron was extremely loyal to Celeborn, and would follow him wherever he went on his travels. Both disliked sunlight, and were often seen snuggling together in the afternoons or walking together along the riverbank or along the paths (if you could call these barely-trodden dirt "paths") of the woods. The twins had often seen the bard combing and playing with their grandfather's hair, something they knew was reserved for relatives and lovers among elves of all Kindreds. But they were not blood-related (though it was said that Daeron, orphaned at a young age, had been adopted by Thingol), and their grandfather was married, and, well, they were both men. How strange are the Sindar!
“It's not that!” Elladan protested. “It's just that when I read, the letters all get mixed up weirdly! You do it!"
“All right, all right, let's take a random page…”
Elrohir began to flip through the pages quickly, until Elladan stopped him. “This!”
“Winter 12,417 since the Awakening of the Elves. Huh? Who records time like that?”
"Awakening of the Elves"...? Perhaps they mean the Years of the Stars? That's roughly the same period, isn't it?”
“I'd say it's likely, but the count is too high... Shouldn't they already be in the Years of the Trees?”
“Well, the Trees were in Aman, weren't they? Perhaps their light didn't reach Beleriand. So it doesn't make sense for those Elves to count the Years of the Trees.”
“You're right!” Elrohir almost bolted up in academic excitement. “Wait, that means that in Beleriand they went directly from the Years of the Stars to the First Age. That must have been quite traumatic for the environment. Do you think-
“Boring, boring, boring! I don't care. Just read it!”
Elrohir rolled his eyes, but resumed reading in a slow, measured voice. “...I was saying, Winter 12,417 since the Awakening of the Elves. Rain on snow. Animals have not taken their usual migration routes. Great shortage of meat, famine throughout Beleriand. One of the Southern Orc Clans has attacked the northern borders of Doriath... blah blah useless data, lots of place names and people I've never heard of before… invasion of the borders… King Elu Thingol… Prince Celeborn Galadhonion-"
“Hey, he's talking about Grandpa!” It was Elladan's turn to interrupt excitedly. “It's true that he was born in the Years of the Stars! It talks about when he was young? What does it say?”
In fact, the twins knew very little about their grandfather's past. Every time he tried, Grandma Galadriel would get angry, and in the end, nothing was said. They knew they'd argued about it, because one day they'd hidden outside the thick mahogany door of their bedroom. Their words were indistinguishable, but they could hear Grandma raising her voice more and more, something that never happened, because she always insisted that if you raised your voice you were already in the wrong. Grandpa hadn't said anything, but the twins had heard some sounds that sounded like growls, so deep they vibrated in their bones. Then the sound of a glass vase crashing against a wall, and several minutes of tense silence. It seemed the whole house was holding its breath. Then Grandma said something in a low cold voice, Grandpa didn't respond, and the twins fled before they could open the door and punish them for eavesdropping. Grandma said it was wrong and shouldn't be done, and Grandpa said that who did not want to be punished would not have been cought.
No one ever spoke about it again, and the twins never asked.
“ If you don't interrupt me, maybe we'll find out! I was saying, Prince Celeborn Galadhonion, of 470 winters, surrounded by 9 orcs, ripp- huh? I think... I think there's a translation error.”
“Translation from what? It's in Sindarin, just a bit archaic. You're just a little sensitive, like always when blood is involved.”
Elrohir didn't protest as he usually would. Instead, he stared at the pages, his face pale.
“...Elrohir?”
“Sorry, sorry, I was saying..." Elrohir took a breath and then read it all in one go, as if trying to get it finished as quickly as possible. “-ripped out the heart of one of his opponents with his bare hands and used it as a hand flail, striking two other orcs hard enough to crack their skulls, single-handedly slaughtered the other five, and, his war axe breaking on their armor, felled the last one with his fangs. It's also said he then cursed their spirits, transforming them into crows and keeping them as his familiars for several centuries."
There was a silence that could have lasted for an hour or a minute, as the boys tried to process what they had just read.
“...Do you think it's true?” Elladan finally asked, hesitantly.
“I don't know. The document is authentic, but it's Grandpa. He couldn't... He couldn't, could he?”
“Hey, maybe-”
But whatever he was about to say was interrupted by the sound of the library door opening and the approaching footsteps. Celeborn appeared from behind the shelves, looking worried. Then he finally saw them, and immediately relaxed. “Ah, there you are. I've been looking everywhere for you! How many times have I told you to go away without saying anything? Come on, there's hibiscus tea and almond biscuits, the orange ones you like so much.”
Seeing his grandchildren unusually quiet, Celeborn became worried. “Boys...?”
Elladan gathered the courage to ask. “...Is that true? Did you really do it, Grandpa?”
“No! It's not true! Legends are always exaggerated, so it didn't happen that way! I'm right, right, Grandpa?” Elrohir protested, his eyes imploring his grandfather to reassure him.
Celeborn frowned, as if searching through a mental archive. “...You should be a little more specific than that, little squirrels.”
“You really ripped out a heart with your bare hands and used it to kill your enemies?” Elladan urged.
“...Oooh, that.” Celeborn visibly relaxed, looking almost amused, as if he couldn't believe his grandchildren could fall victim to such a rooky mistake. “Of course it's exaggerated: organs aren't blunt weapons, they can't be used to kill. I used the staff part to crack skulls. The tied heart was just for effect.”
There was another moment of silence for the twins to process. Then Elladan asked, "And then what did you do with it, Grandpa?"
"With the flail or with the enemies?"
"Both."
"Well, first I ate the heart-"
Elladan couldn't stop a hysterical laugh. "You're kidding, right?"
"No." was the only flat response he got.
His ears lowered. "Ah. So... ummm... And then?"
"Then," his grandfather looked at him sternly, a silent scold for interrupting him, "we sent a falcon to Menegroth to say we had temporarily stopped the raids in that March, and other falcons to the small villages near the Girdle to ask them to lend us wagons in exchange for some of the bodies. Then we cast a spell on the bodies to make the flesh last longer. When the wagons arrived, we filled them with a layer of snow at the base, then loaded them with the bodies, and then again layered the snow on top and between the bodies to preserve the meat. Then, back in Menegroth, I placed the staff in the firewood, burned along with the heads. That small victory was a great grace, and the gods deserved great thanks." His ears flopped slightly and his eyes glazed over for a moment, lost in distant, painful memories. "That was a very harsh winter, among the worst I can remember, and the famine was no less. Devastating, so much so that it was remembered as the Third Great Famine. So many died." Then he blinked, shaking his head as if to chase away the sadness. "It was also the battle that gave me my Warname."
"Really?" Elrohir asked, his voice shaking slightly. "And what was it?"
"Heart-Devourer. The Diarchs chose it together." He said, puffing his chest, his ears raising and his eyes beaming with ancient pride.
"Ah." Whatever strength remained in Elrohir's voice had faded to a faint sob. "Appropriate.”
"You seem particularly troubled. It's because you young people these days are too soft. I often tell your grandmother this, but she tells me you're too young. Too young! Bah, humbug talk! At your age, I had already concluded the Passage conquering even more bands than was required, and I was following the older Warriors of Doriath on my first hunts outside the Girdle, and I grew up perfectly fine!"
"It's just that the Noldor don't eat people, Grandpa."
"But they burn them alive," his grandfather retorted harshly, "pursuing the survivors to destroy their new home and kidnapping their children by snatching them from their parents' arms, as your father well knows.”












