larinah replied to your photoset “13x17 “The Thing” To be Gabriel or not to be Gabriel that is the...”
I've only watched a couple of episodes this season so I don't really know what's going on, but this theory would go right along with what happened in the movie "The Thing". In that film we were left with two guys who were unsure if either of them was a 'thing' or was who they appeared to be. They just had to sit there looking at each other and freezing to death...or not, depending on the true identity.
Ohhhh, that is interesting. I don’t know the original movie *hides* But the theme ans the movie then, I guess mostly was meant to parallel the main story of the episode in which we had a Goddess appearing disguised in human form. Then again, it would also nicely mirror the storyline playing out with Aesmodeus and Gabriel. Super curious to watch the movie now. Sounds gruesome though. :)
michellethetvaddict replied to your photoset “13x17 “The Thing” To be Gabriel or not to be Gabriel that is the...”
I love everything about this theory and fully support it. I'd be super surprised, though, if Dabb & Co. came up with this. *fingers crossed*
Aww thank you dear! I don’t think this is actually in the cards to be the case, but it was fun thinking out of the box for a bit. :)
awed-frog replied to your photoset “13x17 “The Thing” To be Gabriel or not to be Gabriel that is the...”
I love this theory, and I'm sold on the Gabriel!Michael theory, but if that's what happened, I'd rather the guy in the Bunker was actually Michael, and also the only one who can defeat the other Michael. If so, Dean would have to talk our Michael into possessing him so that he (Dean) has enough juice to off AU!Michael. That scenario would mean Jack is out, of course, but then again, can he really stay around as an all-powerful character? That's always trick to write.
That is what I would like most as well, if Dean agreed to possession with Michael without any blackmail or such kind wold be involved. And I would like it if then Michael and Dean would defeat AU!Michael together. Who knows maybe then Jack will have to go against his father and kill him. It’s either Jack against AU!Michael or Michael!Dean against Lucifer. Or it’s is something thrown together or something COMPLETELY different lol.
trainedunprofessional replied to your photoset “13x17 “The Thing” To be Gabriel or not to be Gabriel that is the...”
This is complicated to me because I've only seen the Scooby ep lately, but I *think* I followed most of it. I'm wondering about vessel consent issues though...and how that would work with both Asmodeus & Michael in the same vessel. Or is Asmodeus still an angel, just fallen...? I can't remember...
I think I probably didn’t make it clear enough in that crazy ramble. :) Basically I don’t think Aesmodeus would be in the same vessel as Michael. We have seen him shapeshift and I think he would have simply disguised himself as Gabriel and Gabriel/Michael the other way around - as we know and with that any other archangel as well - could disguise himself as well. Or he wouldn’t have to, as he would have simply not been n the room any longer. But I have truly been writing out a ton of crazy here so you would likely find “plotholes” in the theor here and there. :)
stopmakingfaces replied to your photoset “13x17 “The Thing” To be Gabriel or not to be Gabriel that is the...”
Very interesting read, I like it. My only quibble is whether Asmodeus is the long con kind of player. I had thought the sewn mouth was to a) keep the angel trapped b) keep him silent since Gabriel is the Herald I always wondered if he had special (but undeclared) vocal spells.
Not sure about Aesmodeus either, but we have seen him basically play a long game since episode one lol, since not much has happened with him, aside from him wanting Jack, but I guess we’ll find out soon enough. Initally I had also thought the sewn mouth was simply to keep his grace on lockdown, interesting thought about vocal spells though. :)
