The bodycount is getting pretty high in season three Boardwalk Empire, higher than I think makes sense for the era or situation.
Organized crime in real life was always violent, but even at the height of Prohibition there weren’t double-digit massacres and gun-battles on a regular basis. The St. Valentine’s Day Massacre, which is one of the most infamous events of the Chicago gang wars and is popularly viewed as being what turned public sentiment against Al Capone (Although that’s not quite accurate), had seven victims. The biggest gunfight in the entire six-season run of The Sopranos was the failed poker game robbery in season three, which had a total of three deaths (And one wounding). In the first season of Boardwalk Empire, the death of four men in a hijacking was front-page news and was part of a monumental shift in the structure of organized crime in New Jersey, New York, and Chicago.
In "Blue Bell Boy" in season three, Gyp Rosetti and his gang gun down sixteen members of Nucky’s operation when they hijack a shipment of booze. Rosetti and his gang have functionally conquered a New Jersey town (the fictional “Tabor Heights”), after they murdered the Sheriff and then bribed the next Sheriff to join up and participate in the aforementioned hijacking/gunfight.
I don’t see how they can cover this up. That’s not something that can be covered up. Not and still retain any level of realism in the series. This kind of bloodshed will get competent government agents in the area, with proper resources and funding, instead of the overworked, understaffed, and underpaid Prohibition Agents whose universal incompetence and corruption allows the bootleggers to operate with near impunity. Heck, this might get the Army involved, to put down an armed rebellion.
It’s a scale that doesn’t align with the rest of the show, and is more in line with a a completely fictional drama or action story instead of the “Inspired by a true story” concept they’ve been working with so far.









