SCA 5- Another blow to Asian Americans
SCA 5- Another blow to Asian Americans
SCA 5 – I hear about it everywhere now. The news, Facebook, friends. There’s much opposition towards it, especially stemming from the Asian American community. Why, in an effort to create a more “diverse” public education system, would you discriminate against the color of someone’s skin? By clumping the different ethnicities of “Asian” into one category, we are oppressing the minority groups, the different nuances and shades of “Asian” peoples. SCA 5- affirmative action- an effort to make the education system more “fair” and “equal.” I’m sorry, but I don’t see any justice coming from this. We are mistakenly labeled as taking over the public education system. A common complaint that I hear from many people, no matter where I go, is “THERE’S TOO MANY ASIANS. TOO MANY CHINESE PEOPLE.” Yeah, it’s true there’s Asians everywhere, but do you recognize the different types of ethnicities that make up the Asian population? Do you realize that within the Asian American community are individuals with unique characteristics and minds and perspectives? Do you realize that there are individuals, regardless of race, who actually want to work hard and succeed and do well in education in life? And it just so happens that much of the Asian American community consists of hard-working, determined individuals? It’s not like whites and black and browns, Latinos and Caucasians and Africans, are inferior and less hard-working than Asians. But I truly believe that it is a coincidence that there are more Asians in the higher education system. And what is this thing about “diversity?” Some statistic that treats everyone as a number? A bar graph, a pie chart, that one falls under a category? From what I see, this only limits a perfectly suitable person’s ability to have a chance at higher education. College admissions are hella competitive enough, as many Cal and UC students know, and adding a whole layer of discrimination on top of it makes matters worse. A student not only has to worry about grades, extracurricular activities, their GPA and class rank, SATs, and overall academic integrity, but they also have to worry about the color of their skin. How can you reject someone for ethnicity, a characteristic that one is born with? One doesn’t have the choice to be born an Asian or French. Do we seriously think that having a proportionate number race in our education system is going to make things better? If so, then why not standardize the system everywhere? Why is it that here, in America, the land of freedom and equality, we are judging people based on where they come from? Higher education is a privilege that is earned and should be offered to everyone who is WILLING to work and can contribute to the community.
I’m extremely frustrated and disappointed in the direction that SCA 5 and public education is heading. I was talking to my young friend who is in high school now, and hearing her stress over college only deepened my frustration with public education. AP classes, sports, clubs, grades, and even when you seem like the perfect, qualified student, you STILL aren’t guaranteed a spot in college because guess what? Now you are competing against all the other Asians, Africans, Caucasians, etc. Suddenly, it becomes a battle of the hues instead of looking at what a person can bring to the community. I always thought college admissions would be fair and choose students based on their potential and dedication. Ha.
SCA 5, I believe, will deepen the cracks in our already broken, underfunded education system.
Taken from: http://www.economist.com/news/united-states/21599369-asians-object-affirmative-action-not-black-and-white
Below are a few of my favorite comments from other people taken from the website:
------------------------------------------------------------------
guest-swminjsMar 27th, 03:13
When you call Asian students, they are group of each individuals, but not a big can corn beef. They are one boy by one boy, one girl by one girl, as same as black students, as same as Latino students. Each of them has different smile, each of them has different figure print, each of them has his/her dream for his/her future.
Now, just because skin color, when he starts his first step out of his family to pursue his future, he is refused from his dream campus, not because he is not excellent, just because his skin filling holes are full.
You call this is diversity. [?]
---------------------------------------------------
q9j3hWoS2vMar 20th, 22:16
In the late 1800s California and by Extension the whole U.S. passed a series of laws against Chinese and other Asians. Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882, Asian Exclusion Act of 1975, Chinese Police Tax, Foreign Miners' Tax. These were aimed at Asians who seemingly worked harder, willing to take undesireable jobs (like launder clothes) for less pay, thus competing unfairly with Americans.
Now, Asians are under attack again for willing to study harder, take more advance level classwork, thus gaining an advantage when it comes to university admission. Thus competing "unfairly" with others seeking university admission.
Seen through this lens, SCA 5 is really the Asian Exclusion Act of 2014.