Buddie + âwhy didnât you tell me?â
"Why didn't you tell me?"
It's not an accusation - Eddie knows it's not an accusation. Buck genuinely wants to know the answer - only, Eddie's not so sure that he has one. At least not one that makes complete sense, even as a thought in his mind - and everything always tends to make even less sense once he tries to formulate it out loud.
"I don't know, Buck," he settles for. The porch railing is cool against his temple as he lets it support the weight of his head, his eyes wandering across the dark, silent street. One of the streetlights flicker slightly, and he sees a moth dance its way through the dim light, just for a second - a moment in time. Then it's gone.
"You - you could have, you know," Buck says. "You can - you can tell me anything. I could have... I don't know. I don't know..." Buck trails off, clearly not sure what he actually wants to say. Eddie can't blame him.
"Technically I did tell you," Eddie points out; he hears the monotonous way his voice sounds - although Buck's isn't much better. In between Eddie having spent a week in El Paso, and Buck having been alone with Chris for that same amount of time, they're both exhausted - and should absolutely be asleep. But Eddie had suggested a beer on the front porch, and Buck had accepted - far too aware of how many thoughts Eddie likely had spinning around in his brain after the visit.
And there are a lot - too many - but the one that Eddie had heard spill from his own lips as soon as they had sat down was 'I came out to them. Told them I'm gay.'
Of course, Buck had hugged him, congratulated him - all of that. But then they fell into a comfortable silence, and now they're here, and Buck wants to know - rightfully so - why Eddie hadn't come out to Buck first. They tell each other everything - more or less, at least.
"Well - I - you know what I mean, though - not that you don't have the right to do this how you want, I just - I guess - I just..." Eddie turns his head to look at him, waiting patiently for him to make his way through the stuttering and get to the point. Finally, he sighs and seems to collect his thoughts, looking at Eddie through the dim porch light. "I don't want you to think that it would have changed anything."
âI know that,â Eddie assures him. âTruth is I hadnât planned on telling them, I - thatâs not why I went.â Itâs a half truth at best. Eddie hadnât planned on coming out to them, but he had gone with the intention of⊠coming out to himself. Accepting himself. âWell, I - I went to accept myself, and I thought I might do it, but I wasnât sure,â he gets out before he has enough time to stop himself.Â
Telling Buck lies or half truths has never been Eddieâs strong suit - it never feels good. Maybe thatâs why he hadnât come out to Buck first - because telling Buck âIâm gayâ without following it up with âand Iâm in love with youâ would feel like just that - a half truth.Â
Once again, Eddie lets his head drop to the railing, but now his head is turned so that his eyes are on Buck - dancing across the view of his profile, the orange porch light pouring across his features. His birthmark. The slight bump in his nose. His lips. Everything that made Buck Buck.Â
âSo itâs not âcause of me?â Buck asks, dipping his head, a slight, nervous smile on his face as he picks it back up and looks at Eddie. Itâs on the tip of Eddieâs tongue to assure him that no - itâs not because of Buck. But once again - that would be a lie. And Eddie canât lie to Buck.Â
âBuck,â Eddie says his name on a heavy exhale as he pushes himself to sit back up, the half-empty bottle of beer hanging in between his fingers as he copies Buckâs previous movement of dropping his head. He canât look at Buck when he says what heâs about to say, though - so instead he stares back out into the street. Pointedly trying to ignore the way he can feel Buckâs eyes on the side of his face. âI didnât tell you Iâm gay because... I wasnât ready to find out how you would react to the next part of that confession.âÂ
Finally, he turns to look at Buck. Buck - whose face goes through about three different emotions in the span of ten seconds. Eddie hears the crickets sing, but he doesnât mind them - the silence isnât uncomfortable. Especially not when Buckâs face settles into something... soft. Something like an âohâ.Â
âOh,â Buck indeed voices. âEddie, I...â
âItâs okay - like you said. Doesnât have to change anything.âÂ
âNo, I-â Buck immediately objects. âI want it to - change, I just... itâs not that I donât feel the same way, I do.âÂ
âI - you do?â Eddie questions. Buck gives him a nod.Â
âI just think I need some time.â Eddie thinks he can feel his entire soul relax. Let go.Â
âYeah,â he promises. âYeah, Buck. We got time.âÂ













