so ! I rewatched 2x17 Heart last night and im making it your 🫵 problem !
because i like to think theres absolutely no way sam went into that room with Madison at the end and just shot her. absolutely no way. so here's what they should've done instead;
they don't need any dialogue. they just need sam walking in all teary and sad, looking at madison. they need to show her guiding his hand and consequently the gun (because his hands are shaking too much to move himself) to right over her heart. then, they need to show madison maybe tracing the cuts on his face from earlier. then they need to show sam and madison getting one last kiss in, before cutting the screen to black with the gunshot
what we dont see; sam only breaking the kiss after the gunshot, then just dropping the gun (bcs his hands are shaking, remember !!) and sinking to his knees, hugging madison to him and crying. eventually, bcs the cops are going to show up (gunshots for Christ's sake), dean has to pull sam off of her, walk him outside and into the impala.
bonus points if sam never wears that shirt he lent her again; because he shot her while she was wearing it, and she should be buried in it. bonus points again if during 4x09 with ruby, sam has a visible brief moment of panic, because ruby looks just a little too much like madison
