I am still sorting through so much but to offer my genuine, hopeful take: the headbonk of love scene (yes it is still that) is filled with so much genuine love and hope that to write it off as merely a breakup up is a disservice to the beauty of the scene.
The focus on love, unconditional, with no caveats, past and present is beautiful.
Their confessions to one another demonstrate a deep understanding of one another and it just feels like them so much that it made me cry in joy.
I know a lot of people are focused on the quotes from the People interview, but this quote from their interview with Variety sums up what I think is the most obvious writing choice here: Jonathan and Nancy need to separate themselves from their shared trauma to have any of hope of a relationship in the future.
To me, this makes it obvious that the plan is for them to chase their dreams after the final battle while loving and supporting each other in the way they can by doing what they need to on their own before coming back to one another, knowing what who they are and what they want without the pressure of shared trauma feeling like itâs forcing their hand, and then having a âI know what I want now, I want us, I choose us.â Moment.
Because that was the most in love, hopeful break up Iâve ever witnessed. And thatâs not for nothing.
Side note: having the duffer brothers confirm this so explicitly in the people article instead of letting it be this vague thing like it is in the show tells me they want us to see them as broken up for a reason. That they will have some narrative pay off for their clear separation here. And I think itâs for their inevitable reunion.


















