I think itâs really interesting how a personâs gut reaction to a trope can change with age and understanding, and with the way fandom shifts around them.
Like, Iâve talked about gender bending before, and I have a lot of really intense feelings on that trope in particular, but a trope thatâs been on my mind recently is mpreg, which is... related, in that itâs a gender-related trope thatâs often very transphobic and fetishizing, if in different ways.
I came into fandom relatively young, or at least on the younger side of average. I was twelve when I started reading fic, and fifteen when I started exploring things in relation to my sexuality.
This is when I first ran into mpreg. Half the time it was a kink thing, and half the time it was just a plot point. I was initially squicked, but eased myself into neutrality because that was what I did with most tropes back then; I had a squicky reaction to plenty of things, some banal and some that I could have done to avoid, in hindsight. I was initially squicked by same sex couples and while I know now that this isnât the same thing, 15yo me was... sheltered, and confused, andÂ
By the time I hit late high school/early college, I was invested in the queer community, and had read enough about how mpreg fetishized trans and intersex characters to have developed an aversion to it on the basis that, well, most of it was written with such a lens.
Now... itâs case by case. A lot of it still is a gross fetish thing thatâs deep in the transphobia well, but a lot of these fics are written like... okay.
I have a vague relationship with my own gender, but Iâm capable of pregnancy, if I ever were to want to go through it. I definitely never plan on getting pregnant, and find the idea of doing so deeply unsettling. I also never plan on having kids, and find that idea scary as well.
But I love other peopleâs kids. I love seeing parents, especially pregnant people, who want to be parents, who got pregnant with a plan, because they want nothing as much as they want to have and raise a child. I love seeing small, developing children who are loved and happy and growing up in a way that makes the world a wonder to explore and just... I love the idea of the people who raise kids being genuinely excited to have and love kids. I donât want to be pregnant or have kids but I will devour fic about people becoming parents and just loving their children more than anything else. Whether itâs biological, or adoption, or âolder sibling raises younger siblingâ or whatever... itâs just really, really comforting to read about someone raising a child they adore.
And fics where thatâs the main idea, where the mpreg isnât an accident so much as just a science fiction or fantasy process whereby an ostensibly cis male character goes through pregnancy because they want to, or even a character thatâs âAMAB dude, but not super concerned about the body, yâknow?â and so sees the possession of a uterus they didnât have before as just a neat thing that lets them have kids...
Like, isnât that just the penultimate expression of what Iâm talking about? Someone wanting kids or being so excited about kids that their body and expression is something theyâre willing to change, if only temporarily, to accommodate the desire for a family? A person whose ties to gender as a matter of the body being loose enough that theyâre okay with magical or scifi changes to their reproductive organs, thatâs good. I like a character with an unorthodox approach to gender. A person who, in the context of that relationship to their own gender, is then not only willing but excited to have a child?
I just. I have a lot of feelings on the nature of gender in fanfiction as a form of exploration and discovery and positivity, and on the nature of child-rearing fics as a matter of catharsis and hope and fluff, and mpreg isnât often done in a way that doesnât hit some kind of Weird Squick Button, but on the rare chances that itâs done well... I canât help but enjoy the idea, that someone is so happy and ready to be a parent that theyâre okay with being pregnant despite never having been in a position to expect it as a possibility.