the stones wept
also known as papers AU #1! this is the first thing i ever wrote for the hadestown fandom and it will always be very near and dear to my heart. if youâre new here, my papers AUs are several different scenarios that i imagine could happen after the workers leave in âpapers,â before âif itâs true.â enjoy!
-----
persephone liked to take walks on earth. she enjoyed seeing all of the fruits of the mortalsâ labor, all in reverence to her. the bright colors, the swirling green, it was therapeutic.
in hadestown, however, walks were less pleasant. everywhere persephone went, she saw dead-eyed workers toiling over one of hadesâ new projects. it was definitely unnerving, but couldnât bar her from walking. it was one of the only things tying her to the surface world.
persephone took her flask out of her dress and sipped from it, letting the sensation lull her into makeshift tranquility before going on her way. she usually avoided looking around her while walking, but something in the corner of her eye caught her attention. a crumpled mass lay on the ground, and upon further inspection, it differed from the other crumpled masses she usually saw. those were usually rocks, or bricks, or oddly-placed piles of pickaxes. but this one appeared to be shaking. persephone stashed her flask back in her dress and stumbled over. this was a young man, thin and pale, and hurt badly. blood marred his face and stained his white shirt. despite her better judgement, persephone touched his face to brush back his hair. it was impulsive, but she couldnât remember the last time she touched someone with the intent to care. her hand met his forehead and upon contact, his eyes fluttered open. persephone gasped. âthe poet.â she murmured. he attempted to speak, but all that would come out was a harsh hissing noise.
âhey, shh.â persephone shushed him. she felt the urge to protect this boyâgoodness knew how long sheâd been deprived of any opportunity to care for someone, and it was in her blood. she cultivated the earth, she trained the flowers to grow. she felt compelled to help this poet that had always said such kind words about her with his cup raised high. âcan you walk, honey?â the term of endearment spilled out of her before she could stop it. she hadnât called anyone something that tender inâŚforever. the poet nodded feebly, allowing persephone to pull him to his feet. he held his right side with his left arm and cringed, but allowed persephone to lead him to her bar. âthatâs it, yeah.â persephone whispered. âstep into my office.â she sat him on a chair and stepped back to find supplies. âi remember you.â she told him. âyouâre the poet.â once she had bandages and alcohol in tow, persephone pulled up a chair in front of her patient and started to tend to his wounds. âorpheus.â the boy whispered. the words had no sooner left his mouth when he sat up abruptly. âiâm orpheus.â he said this like it was a revelation and locked eyes with persephone. âi need to find eurydice.â orpheusâs eyes widened. âiâŚi have to go and find eurydice, excuse me, pleaseââ he tried to stand, but only fell back into the chair with a sharp cry and wrapped an arm around his ribcage again. persephone placed a pacifying hand on his chest. âwhoa.â she said. âslow down, sweetheart. youâre not in any condition to go find anyone.â the poetâs eyes were desperate. persephone hadnât seen desperation down here in a while, save for in the mirror.
wait. she kept her hand against orpheusâs chest, spreading her fingers wide. to her shock, a fast beating met her fingertips. âyouâre alive.â orpheus blinked. âi am.â it was too tentative to be a statement, but not curious enough to be a question. âi, i am.â persephone peered at the poet in disbelief. she took in his thin, trembling frame and the cuts and bruises on his face. had she not felt his heart, she wouldnât have known he was alive at all. âyou canât be here.â she murmured. âhow can you be here?â âthereâs another way, a-around the back.â âthereâs another way?â she exclaimed, perhaps too loudly. orpheus flinched, and persephone quickly stopped herself from shouting anything else. he couldnât take any sudden movements right now, not like this. âsorryâŚwhat other way?â she had searched everywhere for another way out. never before had she found a back way. orpheus shook his head. âi canât, iâŚâ he coughed and grimaced at the consequent sharp pain in his cracked ribs. âi canât tell you. i donât know, i didnât look up, i couldnât, i justâjust couldnâtâŚâ he concentrated on regulating his breathing, focusing on keeping his heart rate down. it was clear to persephone that he was unused to feeling like thisâŚwhatever âthisâ was. âcalm down, honey. itâs okay. iâm here. iâm here.â persephone murmured with a hand still on orpheusâs chest. sharing escape tips would have to come later. âslow down, hush.â
âitâs my fault sheâs down here, itâs my fault, i need to tell her that iâm sorry.â orpheus was shivering, but it was far from cold. persephone took her hand off of his chest to get the faux fur coat she always brought down with her. orpheus didnât turn to look and cast his eyes downward, his arm tightening around his body. persephone draped the coat around the boy with a tutting noise of sympathy. poor kid. he really did look like he was falling apart at the seams.
âwhen was the last time you ate?â she asked. she wasnât a mother in the biological sense, but every bone in her body was screaming at her to tend to this poor, lost boy.
orpheus shook his head, dazed. âi, i dunno. i donât remember.â persephone felt a pang of guilt strike her heart. she knew it wasnât really her fault, but she did feel guilty for everyone on earth that had to deal with the dead harvests and unforgiving weather while she was in hadestown, fighting with her husband. âhere, i can get you someâŚâ she slipped behind the bar and kneeled down. âi have some breadâitâs not old, i just smuggled it in.â persephone took it, unwrapped it, and spread a generous pat of butter on two slices. âhere.â orpheusâs hunger was nearly palpable; she could feel it in the air.
he hesitated, looking at persephone cautiously. sympathy filled her heart, mixing with the guilt. âgo on, honey, eat. i wonât do anythingâyou can eat.â orpheus lifted the bread to his mouth and took a bite. his eyes widened, and in a few seconds, the bread was gone. he devoured it practically whole. persephone chuckled despite herself, sat, and began to clean orpheusâs wounds with alcoholâŚnot the fun kind. he winced, but didnât have enough strength to really pull back. âis everyone as hungry as you up there?â orpheus nodded and met her question with a tentative one of his own. âdoes everyone getâŚget food like that down here?â
persephone thought for a moment. âi suppose so, yes.â then again, no one working down at the factory necessarily needed foodâthe nonstop labor sapped them of any hunger. nonetheless, the poet deflated before her very eyes, breathing a quiet sigh of relief. âso sheâs being fed.â he whispered, half to himself. persephone tilted her head. she knew who he was talking about. the look on his face said it all. âyou really love her, donât you.â orpheus touched his right hand to his chest. âwith all my heart.â persephone nodded, a ghost of a smile on her lips. she remembered feeling like that about hadesâlike there was no one else, nothing else that could make her feel the way he did. she missed it. âhow did you get in here? other than the back way.â she looked around the bar as a precaution before continuing. âthe fates are not known for their forgiving nature. atropos, especially.â orpheus blinked. âthe fates?â persephone nodded. âthree ladies, all dressed the same.â she set a gentle hand on his knee in her attempt to jog his memory. ânever liked them, myself.â âi sang a song.â orpheus said, sounding far away. âi sang a song so beautiful, the stones wept.â he directed his intense gaze at the bewildered persephone. âand they let me in.â âmust have been one hell of a song.â just like that, he stared at the floor again, avoiding any possible confrontation. âi wrote it so spring would come back.â before she could stop herself, persephone laughed. âto make spring come back?â âitâs a foolish idea, iââ âno! no. itâs not.â persephone regretted laughing immediately. she had never seen someone so unabashedly filled with hope, she didnât know what else to do. âhow long did it take to write?â what started as trying to keep the boy distracted from his wounds has blossomed into real curiosity. she was touched that he cared so much, and not just about the weather. âitâs not finished, i still canâtâŚâ orpheus swallowed and shook his head. ââŚi canât get it quite right.â something in his eyes told persephone that he wasnât disclosing a very important part of the story. sheâd seen that look glinting in hadesâ eyes every time winter ended. something like regret. âand the girl? eurydice?â she fought to keep an edge of disdain out of her voice. it wasnât orpheusâs fault that he was starting to remind her so much of her husband.
orpheus understood the question immediatelyâmuch to persephoneâs dismay. âi thought i could bring spring back, i really did. i couldnât think about anything else. i didnât eat, or, or sleep, but neither did she.â he raised his head weakly and made a fist just to do something with the hand that wasnât pressed to his side. evidently, this wasnât his favorite thing to talk about. âi couldnât provide for her. i was blind, i couldnâtâŚi was so caught up inâŚâ his dull eyes suddenly shone in a moment of temporary clarity. â in the world that could beââ ââthat you couldnât see the world that is.â persephone finished sharply. âthe world that was right in front of you.â orpheus blinked.
âyou remind me of my husband.â persephone took her hand off of his knee. âof hades?â the poetâs voice broke on the god of the underworldâs name.
youâve scared him, persephone. heâs already scared enough, he doesnât need more. she shook her head, taking his hand and stroking the back of it with her thumb. âi didnât mean it badly, sweetheart.â persephone backtracked. âi promise.â orpheus shuddered, but didnât take his hand back. persephone didnât blame him for being scared. hades didnât used to be so hell-bent on his factories. there was something new in his eyes that she had never recognized before. something without any reservations. something dark that didnât used to be there. it was all about the machinery, all about the wall. what hades didnât understand was that it wasnât going to help anyone on the surface. making the underworld into a sauna wasnât going to make summer come back. building a wall wasnât going to fix the barrier between him and persephone, either. persephone pushed that out of her mind. only room for one hades-related breakdown a day, remember? think of the mortals. besides, this is about orpheus. âand eurydiceâŚis sheâŚ?â now orpheus took back his hand and pressed it to his mouth. persephone watched as tears pooled in the corners of his eyes. he was so sensitive, this boy. when he felt things, he felt them with his whole heart, his whole chest. she could see it in the way he spoke about the girl he loved. she could see it in the way he physically ached for eurydice but barely flinched when persephone tended to the cuts on his face and his bloody nose.
a tear slowly rolled down orpheusâs cheek, seeping into the gash on his cheekbone. persephone swallowed the urge to cry with him. i was wrong. he isnât like hades at all, she thought. hades would never feel remorse like this for me.
she pulled the fur coat tighter around his shoulders. âhey. hey, hey. honey, listenâŚâ her hand found orpheusâs knee again. âorpheus, itâs going to be okay.â a sob escaped his lips, shaking his whole body with its force. the poet shook his head and pressed his hand tighter against his mouth. persephone could do nothing but watch as he broke down in front of her. she knew that there was nothing she could say or do that would calm him. after a minute or two, he gathered himself. orpheus risked a glance at persephone with red-rimmed eyes. upon seeing her concerned expression, he let go of the tension in his shoulders and exhaled. âit was gonna be the two of us.â he murmured. âif i had finished the song sooner, i could haveâŚshe wouldnât have left.â âcan you sing it for me?â orpheusâs expression changed from one of sorrow to one of confusion. âsing it for you?â persephone offered him a sad little smile. âyou donât have to, but i havenât heard anything good in a while.â she shrugged. âand iâd like to hear it straight from the poet himself.â after a moment. orpheus tightened his grip on the side of his body and took a careful breath. with that, he started to sing. it was a gorgeous melody. it truly was. there werenât any words as far as persephone was aware. it didnât matter. he didnât need them. every few seconds, orpheus took a pause and changed a note or two. it was a broken melody, and definitely more of a work in progress than persephone first thought. but it was breathtaking.
every time he paused, she could see his brain working. she saw the poet writing and rewriting, crossing out and composing in his mind. she had never seen anything like it. orpheus held his next note out, long and glimmering with a gentle vibrato unique to him and him only. he repeated his previous unsuccessful melodies again after the first long note, decreasing in volume. there was a few seconds of this, and suddenly persephone watched something click in his head. something had just come together in a spectacular way. she listened closely. this tune was different. still gorgeousâŚbut different. persephone felt it in her chest, each beat of her heart echoing every note. it was familiar, and sad, and filled with what sounded like buried affection. orpheus trailed off, eyes wide with the shock of this new development in his song. âi think that was it.â he mumbled. âthat was the rest of it. that was it.â a spell that persephone didnât realize orpheusâs voice had cast over the room broke. âorpheus, where did you get that melody?â she asked quietly.
he stared at persephone with a mixture of fear and wonder on his face. âi, i donât know. i donât know, iâŚâ orpheus blinked. âitâs not mine, i know that, but itâs something iâve felt for a long time. itâs in my heart.â persephone considered the boy, taking in his tear-streaked face and awe-filled stare. âitâs in mine, too.â the silence that fell following her words was almost comfortable. before they had really met, persephone had liked orpheus. she had liked his music. but seeing him up close, observing the way he felt so deeply for thingsâŚit made her love him. she cared about him. she wanted to see him succeed. and she didnât want him to lose eurydice. if anyone in this world deserved pure love, it was orpheus. he had made mistakes, but his intentions were crystal clear. persephone saw this.Â
âi need to find her. i need to tell her i finished the song, iâŚâ he trailed off. âiâll lose her forever if i donât.â persephone made a soft, comforting noise. âyou just made a mistake.â orpheus unwrapped his left arm from his side and gave a soft hiss of pain. âsheâll never forgive me.â he whispered and made to put his head in his hands, but persephone reached out and lifted his chin. his hands fell to his lap.
âorpheus, if you love her, and she loves you, thenâŚâ persephone sighed. âit would be a bigger mistake to let her go.â she fiddled with the hem of her dress. âyou have to keep trying.â
âhow?â orpheus asked, his voice more breath than anything else. âhow can i keep trying when haâyour husbandâŚhe wonât let me.â he couldnât bring himself to say the god of the underworldâs name. persephone didnât blame him.
âyou would be surprised.â she spoke in a stage whisper. âpeople will hear you through that crack you made in the wall, orpheus.â persephone raised her head to look him in the eye. âeverybody knows the walls have ears.â














