New Post has been published on The Rakyat Post
New Post has been published on http://www.therakyatpost.com/news/2014/06/22/mca-gerakan-must-demand-retraction-non-secular-remarks/
'MCA, Gerakan must demand retraction of non-secular remarks'
DAP adviser and veteran lawmaker Lim Kit Siang today urged MCA and Gerakan to be more aggressive. He wanted them to demand a retraction of the statement made by a minister recently that Malaysia was not a secular state.
Lim said that they should not be satisfied that Minister in the Prime Ministerâs Department Datuk Seri Jamil Khir Baharomâs remarks were his personal views.
Instead, MCA and Gerakan, together with other Barisan Nasional component parties, must demand for a BN Supreme Council emergency meeting to clear the air over the matter once and for all.
âThe excuse that a minister is giving his âpersonal opinionâ might be used if the minister is speaking outside Parliament, but it is completely unacceptable when a minister makes a speech or a statement in Parliament.
âThere is no such thing as âpersonal viewsâ when a minister speaks in Parliament, whether in speeches or in replies to parliamentary questions.
âWhatever the minister speaks in Parliament is in his official capacity on behalf of the Barisan Nasional Cabinet, which binds all ministers under the doctrine of collective ministerial responsibility,â Lim posted on his blog today.
He trained his guns on MCA president Datuk Seri Liow Tiong Lai and Gerakan president Datuk Mah Siew Keong, citing the duoâs recent response to Jamil Khir as mere âpolitical evasionâ.
âIt is just not good enough for the MCA president to dismiss Jamil Khirâs parliamentary statement that Malaysia is not a secular state as âmerely his personal viewâ, arguing that Malaysiaâs position as a secular state was clearly defined in the Federal Constitution âdrafted to safeguard the rights of not only one race and religion, but of allâ.
âGerakanâs suggestion of a âspecial bipartisan committeeâ to resolve the âvarying views on the secular or Islamic state issueâ is another classic case of political evasion, which also puts the cart before the horse.
âThe first thing that must be done is to get back to the basics, to restore the original status of Malaysia as a secular state, as stipulated by the original constitutional provisions and the founding fathers of the nation.â
He was commenting on the âmeek responseâ by Liow and Mah over Jamil Khirâs parliamentary reply last week that Malaysia was not a secular country as the official religion of the state is Islam.
Jamil Khir added that this was also based on historical facts which showed that the formation of Malaysia adhered to the Islamic Malay Sultanate, with the Malay rulers being placed as the head of Islam in their respective states.
âThis is strengthened by Article 3 of the Federal Constitution, which clearly states that Islam is the official religion in the federal region, while other religions can be freely practised.
âTherefore, our position is different from that of secular countries which do not fix an official religion for their county, but their people are allowed to practise their respective faiths.
âTheir religion is a separate matter and is their personal practice,â he said in a written reply to Sibu Member of Parliament Oscar Ling Chai Yew.
Ling had asked Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak to state whether hudud laws were in breach of the Federal Constitution, whether the federal government planned to implement hudud and whether Malaysia was a secular or Islamic country.
He also asked Najib to define what he meant by secular if it was.
DAP later sought to refer Jamil Khir to the Parliamentary Rights and Privileges Committee, over his remarks, saying that he had misled the august house.
However, the motion against Jamil Khir was rejected by Dewan Rakyat Speaker Tan Sri Pandikar Amin Mulia.
âThe minister did not mislead the House and it was his own views, and thatâs why I am rejecting your motion,â Pandikar added.
âWhen I referred to the Oxford dictionary on the meaning of secular, this is what I found⌠that secular means ânot connected with religious or spiritual mattersâ, â Pandikar further elaborated.
He then said that Islam was the official religion of the country, thus not making Malaysia a secular state.