unpopular opinion, sorta
all these TLJ novelization spoilers kind of got me riled up because
THE MOVIES SHOULDāVE INCLUDED SOME OF THIS SHIT instead of burying it under 100 layers of subtext
like u telling me itās canon leia and han were afraid of ben as a kid and didnt know how to handle him, and talked about him behind his back like he was a monster??? at age 10?? THIS IS IMPORTANT AF.Ā instead of dwelling on this in the movie, we only get it in the novelization. NOPE. this irks me because well, it makes TFA and TLJ look fucking flimsy. and it makes it look like they underwrote kylo renās character. it gives antis ammunition to say ānah, he was happy & loved, he just turned out bad when he was sent to lukeāsā. btw, this ALSO makes han and leia look like chumps because we never get to explore the conflict in-depth so itās either that a) kyloās perspective is selling us lies...which...no...why would he invent a conversation between his parents about him, or b) a force!strong person like leia shouldntāve had any kids cuz apparently no one can handle this shitĀ when the force is involved
this just points more and more to the force being a flawed concept in both philosophy and execution and again, MAYBE we shouldāve focused on this more in the movie. like where was grey jedi??? where was balance???
SECOND, the fact that rey can tap into his powers and borrow them via bond SHOULD HAVE BEEN MADE MORE EXPLICIT. because lots of anti reylo folks say sheās just naturally better than him and can whoop his ass no matter what. which man, i love rey but FALSE. sheās strong but she gets her technique from him! thatās not the death of feminism, jfc, theyāre working as a team! itās a breath of fresh air sheās not some mary sue who just inherited her powers via plot-convenience. and this makes her a better character because she manipulates the bond in a way that is useful to her, while still having genuine feelings for kylo. complexity!! nuance!!! what i am here for!!! instead, half the time both TFA and TLJ frame it like sheās just a goddamn messiah natural. when...we all know what happened to that other messiah, anakin....
again, iāve been in the trenches with this ship and i know what im talking about when i say we had to fight so much BS about how it was all in our heads. the fact that these pretty damn important details are only included in the book makes it easier for antis to tear down our arguments.Ā
iāve seen other spoilers with reylo moments (and while iām thrilled about them), some of them feel like a cop-out. like here, we couldnt commit to this dynamic entirely and go into some uncomfortable places, so u got a book instead
star wars isnāt art-house. itās supposed to have a clear enough narrative to follow. iām not saying i need everything spelled out, but wow, when the novelization is 80% more character-oriented than your movies, thatās a problem.
and i love TLJ, but they gotta do better in episode 9 if they wanna untangle this han/leia/ben/rey mess for meĀ
and if these novelizations are not supposed to be included in canon, then promote them differently, cuz it makes your movies look bad












