In Defense of Lukanette/Adrigami
I have recently completed watching the animated superhero television show Miraculous Ladybug for the first time, and I have some thoughts.
Now, before I start rambling, I just want to say that Iâm not trying to criticize anybody for their preferred ship in MLB. Iâm just trying to encourage employing critical thinking when it comes to the show, the characters, and the plot lines. Even if I donât convince you in this argumentative essay, it is my hope that you will at least perceive things a little more deeply regarding Miraculous Ladybug.
Okay, so for the most part, Miraculous was a decent enough show. Iâm not going to go shouting from the rooftops âF*CK YOU, THOMAS ASTRUC!!!â, as some people are apt to do. He is the showâs creator and is at the liberty to do whatever he likes with it.Â
However, that doesnât mean I have to agree with him on everything.
Despite its best parts, the show has a lot of flaws, and even though I could sit here all day complaining about whatâs wrong with it, Iâm choosing for focus on a single aspect of it (for now): the illusion of the OTP.
The Love Square - which involves Marinette liking Adrien and Chat Noir liking Ladybug, even though Marinette is Ladybug and Chat Noir is Adrien - never made much sense to me, even from the beginning. These are the problems Iâve found with it.
1. THATâS NOT EVEN HOW LOVE WORKS
Now, I could be wrong, but if you love someone - and I mean really love someone - that love wouldnât be jeopardized because of the love interest simply wearing a costume. And yes, I understand that Marinette and Adrienâs civilian identities act differently than their superhero ones, but still. THEYâRE THE SAME F*CKING PEOPLE!!! Iâve shouted myself hoarse about this loophole more times than I can count. If they were truly in love, wouldnât Marinette like Chat Noir as much as Adrien? And wouldnât Adrien like Marinette as much as Ladybug?
2. THEY DONâT LOVE EACH OTHER
Riding on the back of what I just said, the Love Square only proves that it isnât true love. If it were, they would love each other regardless of whether they were wearing their costumes or not! And there is simply nothing else I can add to this.
3. THE LOVE SQUARE FEELS SHOVED DOWN MY THROAT
The production team for the show has missed out on the chance of some excellent character-building scenes in favor of the Love Square. Theyâve been trying to sell it to us ever since the show began. Sure, the Love Square has had its moments, but it ultimately would not suffice as an actual romantic relationship. One of the worst things the show has done is scrap Lukanette and Adrigami. I think deep down all of us knew it was the move they were gonna make, but they dated for like TWO EPISODES. Even if they werenât gonna keep them, they shouldâve at least showed the relationship on more levels, at least to show Marinette and Adrien maturing emotionally.
4. THE REVEAL WOULDNâT CHANGE ANYTHING
Some people take the side of âOh, but once they find out their secret identities, theyâll love each other!â THATâS NOT WHAT WOULD HAPPEN AT ALL!!! Marinette would only love Chat Noir because he was Adrien, and Adrien would only love Marinette because she was Ladybug! Even people who support the Love Square agree on this!! They try to present a solution in which Ladybug falls in love with Chat Noir first and Adrien for Marinette, but that too is unrealistic. In the showâs timeline, Marinette and Adrien have been superheroes for three years. I mean, COME ON.Â
And 5. IT WOULD BE TOO DANGEROUS
We all saw what happened in Chat Blanc. Love Square = The End of Days. You can kid yourself all you like, but itâs the truth.
Maybe it wouldnât unfold quite like Chat Blanc, but Marinette and Adrien becoming romantically attached would provide a vital opportunity for Hawk Moth. Itâs not like heâs been the best at planning before, but this would be a hard one to miss.Â
Perhaps these five reasons arenât enough to sway you, but theyâre good enough for me. And now I turn my attention to the benefits of Lukanette and Adrigami.
1. THEY LOVE THEM FOR WHO THEY ARE
Marinette and Adrien have not always been superheroes, but theyâve always been themselves, and thatâs who they are at their core. Luka loves Marinette for who she is, and Kagami loves Adrien for who he is. Itâs that simple.
2. FAR LESS CONTRADICTIONS
The dilemma involving identities is nonexistent in a Lukanette/Adrigami scenario. If Marinette and Adrien revealed their identities to Luka and Kagami, well, that would just be the sprinkles on top of an ice cream sundae. The love of my life is a superhero too? Thatâs so like them. Also, this type of reveal wouldnât pose any threat Hawk Moth-wise.Â
3. THEY CAN HELP EACH OTHER GROW
If the Love Square were to happen, I think it would be a den of awkwardness. Adrien has had very little exposure to the outside world, and if he began a romantic relationship with Marinette, a lot of the time it would be Marinette showing stuff and teaching things to Adrien, which might be nice in some cases, but does not sound particularly fetching to me. With Lukanette and Adrigami on the other hand, it would be the two of either couple teaching things and showing stuff to each other. Luka could show Marinette to play guitar, Marinette could teach Luka how to bake (one of my dream Lukanette scenes is one of Marinette passing on her fashion skills to Luka).Â
I think this could work for Adrigami also. Both of them have been sheltered for all their lives, and I think it would be nice to see them discovering new things together. They could also teach each other the stuff they already know; Kagami could work on her art skills with Adrien, they could teach each other languages, maybe Adrien could show Kagami to play the piano (or whatever that video game was in Gamer), and so on and so forth. And obviously, at some point, one of them would say to the other, âItâs you and me against the world.â
For me, Lukanette and Adrigami are just more appealing, and I canât see why the show runners donât feel that way as well. If theyâre refusing it in favor of conflict to drive the show, they can provide that conflict through Lukanette and Adrigami. I mean, seriously - Luka and Kagami would be dating superheroes. That doesnât come without its side effects.
If their reasoning is âweâve been alluding to the Love Square ever since the show startedâ, then scrap the Love Square! I think Marinette and Adrien work better in a friend capacity anyway! Besides, changing love interests is a part of life, and doing this in the show would add a bit more realism to a rather unrealistic television program.
In conclusion, Lukanette and Adrigami could send MLB soaring to new heights, and provide a deviation from the same boring old formula.Â











