Handsome City Men
Hi. I actually wrote this fic in secret for my Tickle Diary over a year ago! @k-is-twordish-2 said that he wanted a tickle fic with the Schuyler sisters, so I thought this one would be perfect (:
Fandom: Hamilton
Summary: Just sisters being sisters
Every weekday, the three Schuyler sisters would venture to the city. They would spend their time there chatting, relaxing, but mainly checking out the guys. They didnât see people work often, as their father was too rich to bother; but golly-gosh, hard working men were handsome!Â
That was something that Angelica and Eliza would always mention on their walk back home, but their youngest sister, Peggy, always claimed to be having none of it. The key word is âclaimedâ, which brings us here.
The three sisters were stumbling out of the city in their fancy heels and tight dresses, hoping to be home by sundown. The sisters were all wearing their signature dresses that day: Orange, cyan, and classic Peggy yellow. Peggy had been awfully quiet for that walk, and Angelica and Eliza were sure they knew why. Eliza trotted closer to Peggy innocently, âSo, what did you think of that Lafayette guy?âÂ
Peggy blushed. âNothing!â, she blurted.
âOh really? He was rather attractive though, wasnât he?â, Eliza stirred.
âShut upâ, Peggy whined.
Eliza just laughed, âCome on Pegs!â. She tickled Peggyâs side gently.
Peggy squealed:Â âHey!â
She leaned back into Angelica, who wasnât as naturally playful as Eliza. But as soon as Peggy saw Angelicaâs smirk, she knew it was one of those days. Angelica continued walking, wrapping Peggy in a tight embrace, while tickling her with her free hand. Giggles peeled freely from Peggyâs lips as she struggled to escape.Â
Passers by smiled at the girls fondly, but if they were men, Angelica gave them a death glare, causing them to shudder away. Angelica was just walking normally, giving off the illusion that she was unaware of the laughing and begging mess beside her. But her hands didnât slow down one bit.
âEli-hiza, he-help me-he!â, Peggy managed to squeak.Â
Eliza smiled at her sisters fondly. âNah, you've been so stubborn on these city excursions. You could use some lightening up!â, she teased.
Suddenly, Angelica hit a particularly sensitive spot below Peggyâs ribs, and she full on lost it.Â
âNahaha stohohohp AHAHAHANGELICAHAHA NOHOHOHO!â
Still, Angelica acted oblivious, or at least tried to. It was impossible to hide the cheeky grin emerging on her face.Â
âNAHAHA PLEHEHEASE!â, Peggy begged, not sure of how more of this she could take. Angelica slowed her fingers, before jolting them to a stop. Giggles still poured from Peggyâs mouth as she caught her breath.Â
She glared up at her sisters, âI will get you back for this!â But she didnât sound to menacing, as a smile consumed her face.
But she would get them back. Somehow. It would be hard though, as she was the most ticklish sister. But still, she would get her revenge. In fact, she was already plotting it as they stumbled home.
The next day, Eliza was lost in a book, only ever leaving the couch to eat breakfast. Sheâd been obsessively reading for about three hours when Angelica entered the room.  âYour potatoes are getting coldâ.
âM-hmâ, Eliza nodded in reply, still clearly fully in the world of her book. Angelica rolled her eyes and walked towards the couch that her sister was laid across.Â
âEliza?â, she said. Eliza still didnât look up. âEliza!â she repeated.
âOh!â, Eliza said, dropping her book on her chest and looking up bashfully, âSorryâ.
âEliza, your lunch is getting coldâ.
âCan I just finish this chapter?â, she asked, letting her head sink back into the cushion as she reopened her book.Â
Angelica sighed, âHow many more pages?â
But it was too late, Eliza was already lost in her book again.
Meanwhile, Peggy was sitting at the dining room table, eating her potato pasta, thinking about her cheeky plans for the afternoon. That was when she heard a squeal coming from this living room, followed by the unmistakable sound of Elizaâs frantic laughter. Peggy smirked to herself, walking into the room.
Eliza was lying on the couch, face red, as Angelica wiggled her fingers under her arms mercilessly. Angelica had the same expression she had when tickling Peggy the day before: pretending to not know what she was doing.Â
âPeggy, hehelp!â, Eliza cried, noticing her sisterâs presence.Â
âNah, you could use some lightening upâ, Peggy teased, mimicking Elizaâs words from the day before. She just laughed and laughed helplessly. Sure, Peggyâs plan was to be the tickler, but I guess being a teasy witness was the same thing. And that was when an idea struck her.
She paced up to Angelica, who was clearly focused on Eliza, not noticing her. Eliza did notice Peggy however, and made a positive gesture to her through her hysterical laughter that Angelica luckily did not pick up on.Â
Angelica was hardly ticklish, but she did have one spot. Peggy crouched down to squeeze her sisterâs knee.Â
Angelica shrieked instantly, dropping Eliza, jumping high in the air. She turned around to glare at Peggy, who was laughing in delight of her sisterâs reaction. Eliza was laughing too.
âOk you twoâ, Angelica said, trying to hold back her smile and failing, âYou've both had your fun. Now I suggest you finish your lunch, wouldnât be walking into the city on an empty stomachâ.
Eliza smiled at Peggy, âAn empty stomach would be bad, but a ticklish stomach is worse!â Eliza reached out to poke Peggy but she had very fast reflexes and jumped away.Â
The three girls headed to the kitchen, eating, and than heading to the city for A Winters Ball. Which was where Eliza caught sight of a young looking man, hair in a ponytail, freckles around his nose...
One thing was certain, Eliza would be the subject of Peggyâs teasing on the way back.















