#first witches

ok first up we need to address, which witches are shown here?

From far far left to far far right,

First sprinkle

Unknown I believe (methinks first honey) (edit: after peer review it’s highly likely that’s first choco)

First milk RAGH

witch of light herself

First egg (I WAS RIGHT SHE IS HER RIGHT HAND [more on this later])

First berry

Unknown I believe (I think its first yeast or first vanilla tbh) (edit: peer review says this is most likely first grain)

Ok now time for actual analysis

The specific first witches shown are most intriguing to me. Why first sprinkle and first berry and all of them? There are 12 total possible witches that could’ve been chosen for this showing of the stained glass, so why those 6? 

First egg’s stained glass being right next to WoL is interesting to me as well. We know she was the one who fucked everyone over and fucked up the spell/ritual they were all doing. Why is she shown in such close proximity to the equivalent of the Queen of cookie gods?

This brings me to my other point. I strongly believe that first egg was the right hand or secondary leader of the first witches during their human times before they were turned into cookies. That helps explain why she’s right next to WoL, she had to have been held to an extremely high level of reverence compared to the other first witches that aren’t WoL (first milk being on the other side is a wholeeee different story).

First milk being on the other side as well… Why her? Why not first grain or first choco, who I assume to have been rescued/saved before first milk?

This is where the crazy psycho part comes into play.

What if this is a projection from Shadow Milk?

It might sound far-fetched, but why would this frame be shown RIGHT after Shmilk had his angels descend on his throne? This could be some kind of projection, and he subconsciously wanted to see first milk in a grander light.

-# that or I’m insane hahahahahahahahhahahahahahah

BUT WAIT, THERE'S MORE!!!!!! (smaller details)

Obviously the clothes the witches are in are significant here. Let’s look closer at first berry’s normal attire from her witch form and her cookie form and compare it to her fit in this shot:

You can see in the witch and cookie forms, both of them are very woodland forest type/not basic like this. All of the witches (-WoL) are wearing this exact same outfit.

It looks quite similar to the outfits the witches were in in the original first witches lore teaser over at the witches castle account:

This was the same ritual that resulted in the witches being turned into cookies iirc. Why was this moment etched in stained glass?

Another important thing to note is the design of the stained glass itself, specifically the little things above the witches heads:

It’s so obviously the light of knowledge/deceit/truth. This furthers my “this scene is a projection made by shmilk” because putting your soul jam on top of the witches, also seemingly shining light upon them as well, is absolutely something shadow milk would do, ESPECIALLY in this batshit insane form he has (tho that ✨ in the middle looks an AWFUL lot like pure vanilla’s little face thing amirite or amirite)