2 years ago you would have asked me about barre and I would have told you it was the best workout in the world and all you need to do 5 days a week for optimal fitness. It will help you lose weight, tone, build strength, gain flexibility, give you piece of mind, and change your life as it did mine. Well after 2 full years of being a client and 1 full year of teaching barreā¦I have decided to hang up the grip socks.
A month ago I had to stop teaching with the main reason being my other commitments were growing and my social life as well as my energy level were suffering. But another big reason was that I began questioning what I was saying and doing.
When I started taking barre 2 years ago, it was after 3 years of road running. Lots of half-marathons, 10Kās, 5Kās, etc under my belt. I was training for the NYC marathon when I injured my IT band and ankle. My sports doctor told me long distance running was not healthy for my joints in the long term (I was learning that from my own research just before my injuries) and that I was lacking the proper muscle strength to protect my joints from the constant impact. I began doing my own workouts but I knew I needed some professional guidance, and someone who wasnāt trying to have me compete in a world bodybuilding competition. I heard about barre workouts and decided to give it a go. After my first month I fell in love. I saw the tone it gave me, I loved the movement, the stretching, and it was different from anything else Iāve done. In that first few months I gave up running and focused solely on barre 5-7 days a week.
Beginning my teaching career propelled me into a serious fitness education journey. Yes I had ābarre certificationā, but it was a day of āanatomy lessonsā and other days of learning how to speak in ābarreā, remember names, correct form, etc. Initially, I drank the Kool-Aid barre was serving, but a number of things made me begin to question what I was doing and saying to clients:
1. Ā Ā My own neck and back spasms began. Something that has never happened to me before. Going to my doctor she was worried about my spine alignment and losing the natural curves causing more pressure and pain. I had been taking barre and barre alone for a yearā¦it was supposed to better my posture not worsen it.
2. Ā Ā I had clients developing injuries from barre work including foot injuries, lower back injuries, and hip flexor pain.
3. Ā Ā People who had been taking barre for years, longer than I have, were working extremely hard and not seeing much change. Not just in their body, but in their ability to withstand the exercise after years of doing basically the same thing 3-5 times a week.
4. Ā Ā Why was I reading all these scientific articles, taking these other fitness classes, working with personal trainers who said the complete opposite of what I was asking my clients todo.
To Tuck or Not To Tuck, That isā¦One Question
The tuck is the basis of barre workouts. Dropping your tailbone, rolling your hips forward and gripping your glutes. This creates resistance when lifting your chest and/or moving your thigh in opposition causing tension which in turn strengthens your core and lifts your butt. This posterior pelvic tilt can be great for good looking abs, but down the road, what it also does is cause future permanent curvature of the lumbar spine leading to back posture, lower back, hip, and leg pain. Many of the things myself and clients have been experiencing. In barre, you tuck and curve your back for almost an entire hour. And depending on your flexibility, this can be more or less painful while taking class.
So the other question is⦠āAre great abs now, worth back pain and a curved back later?ā Not for me. But you canāt take a class without an instructor telling you or physically tucking you deeper even though many barre workout founders tell you not to āover-tuckā. Ā I began skipping out on the last 15 minutes of class which focused heavily on ācurl workā. Something I actually learned years ago was bad for your spine.
I had to dig deeper. I began reading all these articles in the NY Times and other publications which delved into the science behind High-Intensity Interval Training (HIIT). Without going into a science lesson here, check out my previous post here. Effective and efficient workouts are what I wanted vs. moderate intensity, lengthy workouts which is essentially what barre is. I began introducing this into my workout routine about 6 months ago starting just once a week. I still loved my barre though because of the changes I saw it do for me. But I realized doing this new workout, their method was heavily based on science and research, touching on a lot of things I was reading. Not based on a dancers theory from 40 years ago. They focused on finding neutral spines in the warm-up, throughout the exercises, and in the stretch. Getting your heart-rate to its max and shorter intervals to burn fat in class and throughout the day. I began incorporating this process into the classes I taught, but it definitely went against my barre learnings. Then I saw myself increasing my HIIT training to 3 times a week, and lessening my barre days. Iāve seen my body change beyond what barre has been able to do and I deal with less to no back pain during the class.
The Doās and Mostly Donātās
I have begun working on getting certified in group fitness instruction through a nationally recognized fitness certification organization. In this process I continue to learn more and more about proper fitness, technique, form, etc. Since barre instructors come with dance backgrounds you expect them to know what is proper. But the tools theyāre given, which is generally a list of pre-made exercises from corporate, are faulty on their own. You might askā¦if theyāre faulty⦠why do so many dancers have amazing bodies and why do so many people see results.
Starting with the dancers questionā¦as a dancer, most have started dancing since they were in the single digits as their bones and muscles were still developing. They have developed flexibility, strength and control in areas needed for dance over decades. Many who take these barre workouts have been sitting at school desks and work desks for decades. Or doing different forms of exercise to where these barre exercises force strain in areas like lower back, hip flexors, toes, knees etc. The positions required are difficult to hold without proper core strength and the support ends up shifting into the wrong areas.
Even for non-dancers, people have different ranges of strength and flexibility. I tend to work the lowest in thigh work because I have strengthened my quads over the years, but many would feel knee pain at that range. Some can lift their thighs to almost vertical in round-back and flat-back work, but my hip-flexors keep me from reaching those heights due to the pull on my lower back. But thatās not something youāre explained when taking classes. Youāre pushed to get higher, work lower and tuck more when youāre already in these alignment-compromising positions. It fuels injury.
Shape had a great article on the Best & Worse Barre Exercises. I realized that I was doing all of the worse exercises in my classes I was taking and teaching. Thereās also this article on staying Injury Free in barre workouts. The feet thing freaks me out and I have definitely developed pain in my foot joint.
Anyway, Iāve spent so much time being pro-barre, but on my search to quench my thirst for proper fitness, strength, and movement, I have to leave barre behind.