I saw your genius summary-review-warning-ode about The Witcher, Betts, and now I wonderâŚhave you watched The Mandalorian? What would you say about that? Should one watch? I want to. For the babby. But I haven't yet because the first 3 minutes had a lot of boring killing and Boringly Seen That. So? *chin hands*
so i wrote a somewhat scathing review of it already, but that was only halfway through the season. after watching all of it, iâve softened a bit. there are plenty of people who enjoyed the mandalorian, and i can see why. it does some things really well. but ultimately, yeah, i found the whole thing pretty boring, and no, it doesnât really get better.Â
i canât tell you whether or not you should watch it, because if you have like a cold and just want something really soothing and easy to watch with a high production value and a sickeningly sweet heart, itâs a great show. but itâs also not one that makes you want to slam the next episode button at 2 in the morning because you canât wait to see what happens next. the latter is not inherently better than the former, but the things i personally value in tv shows were completely absent in the mandalorian.
i feel about the mandalorian the exact opposite of the way i feel about the witcher. the witcher should not have worked on any level, yet watching it is like being lovingly kicked in the teeth. you go into it kind of bored and apprehensive, and for me anyway, i had to be convinced to like it. (and i was!)
the mandalorian, however, should have worked for me but didnât. i went into it totally jazzed but was deeply disappointed. i kept looking for things to appreciate in it, but all i could muster was a vague enjoyment, like watching a particularly witty commercial, but for like, 8 hours. what i really got out of it was a craft lesson -- how, if this show has done everything Right, what feels like a story tailored exactly to my interests, has it failed so hard for me?
by the last episode (directed by taika waititi) i had warmed to it a bit, and realized that it definitely achieved its purpose. it got me to subscribe to disney+. i watched it diligently every week because i am easily manipulated by FOMO and have a personal investment in the star wars universe. it had tenderness and heart and all those things i normally latch onto in a show, but it still missed its mark in getting me to really feel anything other than an ambivalent satisfaction that i had seen something everyone else had also seen.Â