What do we do with all this ache, vulnerability?
ā ļøWarning: Infinity Castle Arc/Manga Spoilers ahead...
(An Analysis of Inosuke/Kanao vs Douma)
Douma vs Shinobu has some significant lost potential, at least as far as the build-up of this fight is concerned, esp in terms of thematic gravity of their rivalry...This was an Upper Moon rivalry which had all flavors of becoming a dedicated sub-series, wherein the severity of motivation in clashing with each other is only rivaled by Akaza-Tanjiro fight, Kaigaku-Zenitsu fight (again an undercooked potential) and the ultimate face-off between Tanjiro and Muzan. Douma-Shinobu rivalry was among the very few rivalries where there was actually a past story to be told and an another story to unfold wrt Kanao and Inosuke.
And it is part of Kanao and Inosuke I want to focus upon. ...
Kanao is one of the characters who will undergo perhaps one of the most pivotal shifts in her character during this arc. In the beginning of the series, she is shown to be a quiet, timid yet skillful corps member who rose through the ranks pretty quickly and easily. So much so, that even Tanjiro comments upon how tough it has been to surpass her skill level for others. We remember how quickly she moved onto training with Sanemi when others only had just begun training with Uzui. Prudent or not, but Shinobu's trust in Kanao's abilities was certainly not misplaced...She had enrolled as a slayer despite Kanae and Shinobu stopping her but she proved herself enough to be trusted with such a risky plan.
On the other hand we have our beloved Inosuke (he is mine at least, not sure about others) who is ever ready to fight demons and ever ready to rip them apart... His ferocity and crudeness should not dislodge us from the fact that he invented his own breathing style and literally passed Final selection based on a whim... Very little is shown about his past though we get glimpses here and there. Kanao and Inosuke teaming together against Douma was an interesting choice, given Inouske is everything Kanao is not in terms of temperamentā loud, crude, ferocious...I mean here are these two charactersāone with extremely repressed emotions and one with an untamed ferocity getting teamed up against a powerful demon who wears emotions and vulnerability as a facade to lure in his victims and mask his depravity and inhumanity...
Kanao comes face to face against Douma in a moment of immense horror and pain, she witnesses Douma murdering Shinobu. She has lost family, her master and everything to himā again...Her grief and unbridled rage guides her against a formidable enemy and the first thing she notices and uses against him is his facade, and reminds him, tauntingly, of his own depravity....Her grief is immense, her loss monumental... She not only reminds Douma of the futility of his existence, she is also reminded of her own loss, grief and tragedy....She obviously did not want Shinobu to die, she had just begun to open up thanks to Tanjiro and had a whole family at Butterfly mansion...According to her, she had not grieved Kanae properly, now having to lose shinobu as well opened the flood gates of her own vulnerability...
But it was not only Kanao whose raw green grief finds an opening on that fateful night, someone else was to realise their own tragedy as well...
In this fight, one of the most painful realisations you can have regarding Inosuke is the fact how oblivious he was to the scale of his tragedy and how painfully aware he was about to become about this... Inosuke's clash with Douma and subsequent confrontation about his past life does something that tends to humanise his ferocity and aggression (something which has been done for Sanemi in the following arc)... For the first time in the series, we see Inosuke as a vulnerable child and not just an untamed wild boar/mountain god going on a rampage.... He is human like all his friends, he has also lost his loved ones and his life in itself is a gift of a mother's sacrifice....His grief is immeasurable and there is no escape from feeling all this pain and that too in such a sudden manner... His wound was always there but dormant, but now it throbs with an unforeseen severity..
I have seen many people tend to present Douma's dealing with Kotoha in a positive manner while it was a case of twisted mercy, one should not forget that we do not get an account of Kotoha's story from her perspective, we never know what set her off to discover his true identity.... Inouske realises with utmost horror just how much the vile being standing before him has robbed him of his life and how he has the audacity of painting it as something noble...
However, this is the moment where the key strength of this fight resides, both Kanao and Inosuke get to face pain like never before in this fight, their wounds ripped new and the realisation of scale of their loss hitting them hard... But despite the wretchedness of grief and depth of loss, they get to feel their tragedy...Their vulnerability, their fragility is a testament of their humanity ā unlike Douma...
One of the most significant subtexts of this fight is how far off Douma is from humanity and no matter how much he pretends, he will never belong with humans again... He has lost one of the basic tenets of being a human ā his ability to feel and unfortunately no matter what he does, he is never going to get it back...This makes Douma's facade even more vile and depraved, his pretense helps him feed on the vulnerability of his victims...He doesn't just kill people to keep himself satiated (unlike other demons), he makes a mockery out of them by pretending to save them...Douma is an outlier of sorts whose demonic self does not get posited in a sympathetic manner, he is a demon for the demon's sake....In fact, his humanity explains why he became a demon so readily.... He had begun to lose his human self way back in his childhood as a cult leader who became desensitised to others' suffering...There is a one thing Douma had lost even before becoming a demonā empathy.....
Kanao and Inosuke get to mourn their loss properly by the time Douma is defeated, they find a place deep within their heart to process and grieve...Douma never got to know where he should be keeping his own vulnerability and ache, he lost the ability to mourn, and by large, ability to feel way too soon and only managed to regain some of that at the precipice of hell....
While I stand by my criticism of the lack of proper build-up of Shinobu vs Douma fight, however, once the fight ensues, it falls into a completely opposite categoryā one of the rare fights in DS which actually had a common logic for everyone involved....Except for Muzan vs Tanjiro, no other upper moon fight has all those fighting bearing such an interconnected personal symbolism.. In this fight, all involved had been deeply violated by the given demon in a personal manner...
All three characters were essentially characters with borrowed identities, including their names, yet two get to know the feeling of kinship, pain, vulnerability and emotional bonding, while other one doesn'tā and that was perhaps his tragedy...
(This week on my TL has been all about Demon Slayer, Shinobu and Giyushino... And this has happened mainly impulsively, so I took this rhythm onto my weekend blog, I didn't want to come up with a long Demon Slayer post so quickly but this is kind of last few long thoughts I have on the series (I do have a post on Obamitsu and some 1 or 2 character analysis to be written esp of Sanemi), and obviously it involved something related to Shinobu (sorry I only see her as a character worth frequent analysis). I have a feeling that for some time this will be my last long post on Demon Slayer for a while (hopefully) and most probably I will stick to short Giyushino parallels/posts occasionally because there are some other series and TAD/Jinmao that have been becoming focus of my long thoughts....so let us see!!!)
















