"Idaho state officials told a federal judge they can test bathroom users to DNA if necessary to enforce a law segregating stalls by gender.
Idaho’s strict anti-trans law requires people to use public restrooms and changing facilities that correspond with the sex they were assigned at birth. When attorneys for plaintiffs challenging the law noted that many transgender people have state-issued IDs reflecting their gender identity, U.S. District Judge Amanda Brailsford questioned how exactly the state would enforce the statute, according to the Idaho Capital Sun.
Idaho Solicitor General Michael Zarian told the judge enforcement should be straightforward “because there is DNA testing.” But that suggestion raises significant questions about privacy rights and what level of suspicion would be required before Idaho authorities could demand that someone submit to genetic testing — a tool more commonly associated with investigating serious crimes such as rape and murder."
- https://www.advocate.com/politics/states/idaho-dna-trans-bathroom
Surely this won't have ANY unforseen repercussions.
This is transphobia, exorsexism, varsexism, and GNCphobia.
This will impact so many people. It will affect binary trans and nonbinary people, of course, but also, it will affect gender non-conforming folks, even if they're cisgender. It will force people to present in very specific ways if they wish to use public restrooms.
It will also impact intersex folks (specifically those with "mixed" or "null" characteristics) massively, whether they're cis, trans, cistrans, or neither.
DNA tests would not "prove" anything when it comes to a lot of different intersex variations. Some intersex people have bodies that "misalign" with their chromosomes, or they have chromosomes other than XX and XY.
Taking transness and enbyhood out of the picture, what bathroom is a an androgenized cis intersex woman meant to use? An estrogenized cis intersex man? Androestrogenized cis men and cis women?
This law forces TGD (trans & gender diverse) people to either detransition/conform or never use public bathrooms, and it forces "ambiguous" intersex people to either never use public bathrooms or to go through medical abuse (ie; forced hormone treatments, genital surgeries, etc) to "fix" their bodies enough to be allowed in.
Gendered bathrooms are incredibly bigoted as a concept already, leaving enben in the dust. The only way society can progress is if we rid of gender separatism and oppositional sexism. There are places around the world who have gender neutral bathrooms and have 0 problems with it. Why can't we just follow in their footsteps already, and make every bathroom neutral, with individualized disability-friendly stalls?