I know you don’t do much lyric analysis yourself Spade, and normally I don’t either, but I LOVE I Knew It, I Knew You so much, I hope you’ll indulge me!
I've been thinking a lot about the parallels between *cardigan* and *I Knew It, I Knew You*, and the more I listen, the more the second song feels like a response to the first. I’ve always felt Cardigan was about KK, and clearly this new song is as well, so here we go!
✨**Knowing someone deeply**
*cardigan* "But I knew you"
*I Knew It, I Knew You* "I knew it, I knew you"
Both songs are built around the conviction that the narrator truly understood this person. Not just their habits or their stories, but something essential about who they were. In *cardigan*, that certainty exists even after heartbreak. In *I Knew It, I Knew You*, it evolves into something even stronger: not only did I know you, I trusted what my heart knew about us all along.
✨**The return that was predicted**
*cardigan* “And I knew you'd come back to me"
*I Knew It, I Knew You* “I remembered I loved you Came back when it mattered"
One of the most striking connections between the songs is that *cardigan* ends with a prediction, while *I Knew It, I Knew You* seems to tell the story of that prediction coming true. The narrator in *cardigan* believes that the connection is too significant to disappear forever. Years later, in *I Knew It, I Knew You*, the feelings resurface and the relationship finds its way back into the light.
✨**Meeting again in the light**
*cardigan* "And you'd be standin' in my front porch light"
*I Knew It, I Knew You* “Standing there in the light of the window"
Both songs place the reunion in a moment of light. The imagery feels almost cinematic: after years of memories, questions, and distance, there they are. The use of light symbolizes recognition, clarity, and the sudden realization that some connections survive the passage of time. It's not just seeing someone again—it's seeing them and immediately remembering everything.
✨ **Memory as proof**
*cardigan* "Dancin' in your Levis"
*cardigan* "Your heartbeat on the High Line"
*I Knew It, I Knew You* "I memorized the sound of your bare footsteps"
Neither song relies on grand declarations of love. Instead, both narrators remember tiny details that most people would forget. A heartbeat. Footsteps. A familiar pair of jeans. These details become evidence of how closely they paid attention to each other. The memories feel intimate because they capture ordinary moments that became extraordinary simply because of who they shared them with.
✨**Wondering if it was real**
*cardigan* “Chasin' shadows in the grocery line"
*I Knew It, I Knew You* "The rivers I cried when we said goodbye Wondering if I'd made it up in my mind"
Both narrators spend years haunted by the relationship after it ends. They replay memories, question themselves, and wonder whether they imagined the depth of the connection. The pain isn't just losing someone—it is losing certainty. What makes the later reunion so meaningful is that it validates what they felt all along. They weren't imagining it.
✨**Looking back on youth**
*cardigan* "When you are young, they assume you know nothing"
*cardigan* "I knew everything when I was young"
*I Knew It, I Knew You* "Parachutes for the free fall of being younger"
Both songs challenge the idea that young relationships are somehow less meaningful because they happen early in life. Instead, they suggest that youth can bring a kind of emotional clarity. Looking back years later, the narrators realize that their younger selves understood the significance of the connection more accurately than anyone gave them credit for.
✨**Recognizing the same person years later**
*cardigan* "You'd come back to me"
*I Knew It, I Knew You* "Wearing that same smile"
What makes the reunion so powerful isn't that the person is unchanged—it's that something recognizable remains. In *I Knew It, I Knew You*, the smile becomes a symbol of continuity across time. Despite everything that has happened, the narrator instantly recognizes the person they once loved. The years disappear for a moment, replaced by familiarity and affection.
✨**Healing old wounds**
*cardigan* "You drew stars around my scars"
*I Knew It, I Knew You* "Love has ways of bringing things back to life"
Both songs acknowledge that the relationship caused pain. But while *cardigan* lives primarily inside the wound, *I Knew It, I Knew You* seems to exist on the other side of it. The later song suggests that time, distance, and reconnection can transform something that once hurt into something meaningful again.
💖**The strongest parallel**💖
*cardigan* "And I knew you'd come back to me"
*I Knew It, I Knew You* "I remembered I loved you Came back when it mattered"
If *cardigan* is the story of someone holding onto faith through heartbreak, *I Knew It, I Knew You* feels like the reward for that faith. One narrator says, "I know you'll come back." The other seems to answer years later, "You were right." Together, they tell a story about a connection that survives distance, doubt, grief, and time—and ultimately proves itself real.
This week feels a turning of the page towards a public Kaylor reunion. We’ve been here before, but this feel different and I have hope 🙏 Happy Pride Month! 🏳️🌈
