#I was shocked to find that some dislike the soundtrack. I love the soundtrack!!
It's because it's genuine. It's an 80s art rock soundtrack that takes itself seriously. And so people (especially men, who are often the first to laugh at or say they hate Ladyhawke's soundtrack) find that cringe.
There's nothing at all wrong with Ladyhawke's soundtrack. It's rock music. It's theme music. And speaking as someone with a degree in medievalism, I'm quite comfortable telling you Ladyhawke's soundtrack is more historically accurate than any contemporary orchestra doomfest could ever be for precisely that reason. Rock music is proletariat music. Dancing is for the people. Storytelling is for the people. Ladyhawke is all of that.
And cringe is why countless contemporary film soundtracks are Hans Zimmer-fied. And why countless films are drained of all color and enthusiasm and anything feminine, characterful, bodied, or sincere. The hyper-masculine is frightened of those things, so it protects itself by narrowing all enjoyment down to one note, one color, one idea so it can pretend it doesn't care and isn't bothered.
Ladyhawke—namely, Alan Parsons and Andrew Powell—did care.
Here's a song from The Alan Parsons Project's 1980 album Turn of a Friendly Card, a concept album themed around fortune and gambling that makes a pile of pop culture references (from Sergio Leone to Edgar Allan Poe).
You can hear an early Ladyhawke soundtrack in this:
No one will argue Alan Parsons wasn't a gifted, passionate musician who created awesome albums. He practically invented art rock.
But we've been conditioned to think "medieval" is miserable and bleak, the darkest and most savage of times, when it definitely was not. And we've been conditioned to think all period dramas are supposed to sound like Gladiator. Elenor Janega wrote a great article about distorted western/American ideas of medievalism in her blog last April.
What people forget about movies and music is the same thing they forget about medieval history, which is that it's experienced by people, who are complex, sincere, and messy. And the fear of that mess is why Film Bros or Soundtrack Bros or whoever else react by calling it cringe.
The thing about Ladyhawke's soundtrack that makes folks cringe is precisely the thing we NEED in our art today—reminders that we are human beings, and we love the shit out of stuff.