All new to this, but I need to get all this off of my chest somewhere.
So I started One Piece a month ago, and I’m currently on episode 630. So SPOILERZ AHEAD for up to Punk Hazard arc.
This isn’t a hate post, but I must confess I hated Tashigi at first. She totally misunderstood Zoro upon their first meeting, and was extremely judgemental about his inability to harm her when she didn’t even see the bigger picture. She refused admit her own incompetence and was convinced that the perceived insult was all misogyny on Zoro’s part, when in fact, 1. he wouldn’t harm her because of his Kuina trauma, and 2. he just dislikes getting serious with weak opponents. And particularly in contrast to Sanji, I have pointedly noted how indifferent and non-discriminatory Zoro is with regards to serious combat.
That’s why it pissed me off to have this weak ass, patronizing marine criticizing him for his non-existent prejudice.
She felt to me like one of those people who had so thoroughly convinced themselves that they were always the victim, the underdog, and the object of derision, that they couldn’t even tell when it was real or not. Like in her mission to rid the world of such close-mindedness, she herself had succumbed to the exact same kind of close-mindedness of seeing everyone through the same lens. Railing against prejudice so insistently like that felt counterproductive and hypocritical, like she was screaming for attention to the fact that she was a woman and almost inviting the different treatment. And it seemed like she felt so justified in it, too, caught up in lofty ideals of righteous justice that blinded her to the grey, grey morality of basically everything around her.
Then Tashigi changed my mind in Alabasta when she actually acknowledged her lack of ability and aided our mugiwara bebies. I was impressed with her for setting aside her pride as a marine, as a fighter, and for recognizing the need for compromise. I was genuinely looking forward to her character development.
Punk Hazard had me excited at her post time skip debut, and she didn’t disappoint. Her hair was more mature, fashion sense was still endearingly shitty, coat was cooler, and she reigned over those G5 scoundrels like a boss, what’s not to like?
Uhhhh, yeah, then I got to the Monet fight. And everything just seemed the same as before. She still misunderstood Zoro in the most frustrating way, and righteously (patronizingly) lashed out at him for NOT KILLING A WOMAN. Seriously, I thought she stood on the side of absolute justice?? Is sparing your opponent’s life something so shameful and wrong?? No wonder Zoro literally admits to looking down on her. He’s right to deem her weaker than him, but Tashigi yet again is in denial or actually cannot tell the disparity between them.
She also didn’t get that Zoro didn’t refrain because she was a woman, he refrained because that’s not his thing.
He’s not killed a single opponent so far: not Hachi, not Daz Bones, not T Bone, not Kaku, not Hyouzou. Monet is no exception, her gender has nothing to do with it. Maybe because it’s a shounen, but also, I think, because Zoro just doesn’t kill. He wants strong opponents, and maybe he’s aware killing might prevent them from growing stronger and challenging him again.
The point was defeat, which Zoro did the moment he broke Monet’s spirit, and Tashigi totally missed it, and I’m pretty sure she felt real proud inside for her petty “win” from cutting Monet up “first.” Yeah, I was disappointed, because I was expecting so much better from her. Two years should’ve been enough for her views to mature, but. Oh well.
Of course she redeems herself with the children thing, and I start liking her again, because dammit Oda you make EVERYONE so goddamn likeable at one point or another.
So I guess I just hate her interactions with Zoro. Once he’s out of the equation, she’s just another loveable, quirky, badass One Piece character.
And thus concludes this Tashigi love/hate post that probably no one will ever read. But if anyone does, I hope you could sort of relate to my internal conflict with this gurl.