i saw an ask about how shiro has a lot of anger in him and that he's not the "soft space dad" that everyone makes him out to be. do you think shiro shows any signs of repressed anger or something along those lines?
Alright so, I think the best way to look at this is to cover it the same way I did for Keith–which is to say, where does Shiro’s anger come from? We know Shiro’s changed dramatically since Kerberos. Joaquim has described Keith as someone whose “experienced loss in his life, in his childhood.” Keith’s been shaped by that loss since a young age. But it seems that Shiro’s been in fairly good mental health prior to Kerberos. He was the garrison golden boy, someone cadets looked up to as their hero. The pioneer of a new era in space exploration. He was held in high esteem by his colleagues–until mission failure was scrolling across every TV screen.
And while there is the notable absence of any parents or siblings–I personally believe he must be estranged from his family–I don’t think it had the same impact on Shiro that being orphaned had on Keith. Shiro was able to reach out to others and still make connections. Others saw him as approachable and amicable. He doesn’t live in constant fear of abandonment. While I do believe he’s a private person who maintains his own walls, he doesn’t shut people out entirely for fear of rejection the way Keith does. He’s more like someone who will put on a facade that everything’s fine and he’s got his life together. But yeah, I certainly don’t think there’s anything that points to him being anything but sweet, friendly, honest and compassionate.
These fits of “anger” don’t start until after Kerberos, so let’s take a look at why. The two common themes for Takashi’s outbursts are due to either 1) lashing out because people he cares about are in danger
or 2) frustration about what the galra have done to him and all consuming fear that he’s turning into the monster they tried to make him. It’s this loss of autonomy that makes him break down
And because Shiro identifies so closely with the Black lion, seeing Zarkon try to control her as well makes him furious. It’s not just a matter of fighting Zarkon because he’s the Bad Guy–this is very much a personal fight. “You’re no paladin.” Shiro’s not going to let her be made into a weapon against her will the way he was. “No one commands the Black Lion.” I’d also like to point out in season 3 Keith says “Shiro’s the Black Lion,” and there’s so much truth to that. It might be his lion Shiro’s defending, but the lesson here also boils down to No one commands me. He’s defying Zarkon and breaking free in this scene just like Black
It’s also important to remember that, just like Keith has his high intensity emotions and abandonment issues, Shiro has PTSD. He was a prisoner of war for a year, and that leaves more scars than just the one on his face. He’s been through a lot, and healing isn’t always going to be soft smiles and perfect temperament. It’s not being able to drag yourself out of bed and constantly berating yourself for being useless. It’s believing you’re your symptoms and you’re just a horrible person. It’s having nervous breakdowns and screaming or crying or punching something in a sudden rage. It’s acting on impulse and doing something you immediately regret. It’s ugly and it’s hard and I’m glad with Shiro’s character arc we still get to see that. It’s not something you should just gloss over.
So again, I don’t think it’s that Shiro has a lot of anger in him or anything. He’s not someone who goes looking for a fight. I think he’s just someone dealing with his trauma and struggling with low self-worth. He’s also fiercely over protective, and that’s where a lot of his “rage” comes from. He’s an incredibly good person, but he’s wiling to act up a bit if it means protecting the people he loves–attacking Matt to save him, throwing away the alliance to rescue Keith, ect.
He’s someone who will get his hands a bit dirty if it ensures his team’s survival. It’s a kind of instinct that was honed in the arena I think, this knowledge that you have to be willing to compromise some of your beliefs for a cause. Though not to the extent that you’re doing anything that makes you worse than the enemy. It’s a fine line to walk, but Shiro isn’t some infallible, perfect paladin. He’s human and he’s just trying to get by and lead his team as well as he can. The real tragedy is that he was always a good person–and he could’ve lived a relatively happy, long life if not for Kerberos. But even though he’s battle-worn and suffering from trauma now, he’s still so kind and gentle. The fact that anyone can still be so warm and caring after so much was taken from them–the universe really doesn’t deserve him