RED IN THE GREY

My BIGGEST problem with the theories circulating is that Bethany is alive.

WILL SOMEONE please tell me how that’s possible AND who would be in the grave instead of her or Alison. IT DOESN’T MAKE SENSE. I feel like completely disregarding a dead body doesn’t make sense.

6x03 Charlotte listens as Kenneth tells Alison and Jason that Charles was there brother who commited suicide, not knowing that Jessica had lied to him about Charles death.  

6x04 Charlotte eats taffy as she looks at a screen that has a GPS location of all the liars. This reveals that “A” chipped the girls in the doll house, except Sara Harvey.

6x05 Charlotte or Uber ‘A' make an Aria doll with her class pink striped hair

6x06 Charlotte sends Kenneth a birthday card and he goes to the grave for Charles to bury it. Also to check if Charles was truly buried there like Jessica had told him.

6x07 Charlotte leaves a message for Jason on the projector that is playing Charles birthday party that Alison and Jason went too. Charlotte planned to meet Jason until the cops came and made Charlotte think Jason was lying

6x08 Charlotte receives a birthday gift from an anonymous person. The gift is a photo of Charles, Jason, and Ali at Charles birthday. Red coat is presumably the one who sent the gift

6x08 Charlotte puts a tuxedo in the back of a limo with electrical stuff, duct tape, and 6 syringes. Charlotte gets into the backseat and Sara Harvey dressed as Red Coat gives him two tickets to Rosewood High’s senior prom

6x09 Charlotte finally reveals herself to Alison

6x11 Uber 'A’ OR Dr. Rollins are seen watching the girls leave Charlottes funeral from the back of a car.

6x12 Someone leaves a romantic bouquet of flowers at Charlottes grave. Know we can guess this is Dr. Rollins. I don’t believe Uber 'A’ and Dr. Rollins are the same person though

6x13 Uber 'A’ is seen in a new lair with all of Charlottes old things. They are seen researching UNIFORMS online and then throw the old black hoodies into the trash.

6x14 Uber 'A’ is seen wearing a new disguise as a bell hop for the Radley Hotel. 

6x15 Uber 'A’ uses the disk that Caleb placed a virus on his entire computer is wiped clean.

6x17 Uber 'A’ is seen removing another disguise used in the Radley hotel. This seen is near the middle but still significant.

In the ending we see Uber 'A’ eating a piece of wedding cake from Byron and Ella’s wedding indicating they were there.

6x19 Hanna sends uber 'A' the text saying that she is Charlottes killer and we see Veronicas state senator picture on the desktop.

6x20 Uber 'A’ sends a text to the liars and initials it for the first time with A.D giving the audience insight into who Uber 'A’ could be

6x03 Charlotte listens as Kenneth tells Alison and Jason that Charles was there brother who commited suicide, not knowing that Jessica had lied to him about Charles death.  

6x04 Charlotte eats taffy as she looks at a screen that has a GPS location of all the liars. This reveals that “A” chipped the girls in the doll house, except Sara Harvey.

6x05 Charlotte or Uber ‘A' make an Aria doll with her class pink striped hair

6x06 Charlotte sends Kenneth a birthday card and he goes to the grave for Charles to bury it. Also to check if Charles was truly buried there like Jessica had told him.

6x07 Charlotte leaves a message for Jason on the projector that is playing Charles birthday party that Alison and Jason went too. Charlotte planned to meet Jason until the cops came and made Charlotte think Jason was lying

6x08 Charlotte receives a birthday gift from an anonymous person. The gift is a photo of Charles, Jason, and Ali at Charles birthday. Red coat is presumably the one who sent the gift

6x08 Charlotte puts a tuxedo in the back of a limo with electrical stuff, duct tape, and 6 syringes. Charlotte gets into the backseat and Sara Harvey dressed as Red Coat gives him two tickets to Rosewood High’s senior prom

6x09 Charlotte finally reveals herself to Alison

6x11 Uber 'A’ OR Dr. Rollins are seen watching the girls leave Charlottes funeral from the back of a car.

6x12 Someone leaves a romantic bouquet of flowers at Charlottes grave. Know we can guess this is Dr. Rollins. I don’t believe Uber 'A’ and Dr. Rollins are the same person though

6x13 Uber 'A’ is seen in a new lair with all of Charlottes old things. They are seen researching UNIFORMS online and then throw the old black hoodies into the trash.

6x14 Uber 'A’ is seen wearing a new disguise as a bell hop for the Radley Hotel. 

6x15 Uber 'A’ uses the disk that Caleb placed a virus on his entire computer is wiped clean.

6x17 Uber 'A’ is seen removing another disguise used in the Radley hotel. This seen is near the middle but still significant.

In the ending we see Uber 'A’ eating a piece of wedding cake from Byron and Ella’s wedding indicating they were there.

6x19 Hanna sends uber 'A' the text saying that she is Charlottes killer and we see Veronicas state senator picture on the desktop.

6x20 Uber 'A’ sends a text to the liars and initials it for the first time with A.D giving the audience insight into who Uber 'A’ could be

TWIN THEORY: Jessica Dilaurentis

Jessica’s twin is Bethany’s mother.

Bethany resented/hated her mother and was drawing pictures of her mother, Jessica’s twin.

When Jessica took Bethany out of Radley it was secret from her twin, that's why she told Bethany to call her Aunt Jessi; but she is-fact her aunt.

After it was revealed that Bethany was in the grave instead of Alison Jessica sent flowers to her twin sister in the Black Veil disguise.

The twin found out Jessica had covered up what Charlotte had done the night she hit Alison over the head and since she didn’t know it was truly Mona who hit Bethany she thought it was Charlotte and Jessica covered it up. Causing her to want revenge on Jessica.

Jessica killed her twin and that’s who we saw get buried.

Jessica is still alive and has been in hiding. That’s why she visited Alison in her dreams in the Christmas special and in 6x19.

She is the one sending the ‘A’ text messages to try and figure out who killed her daughter.

UBER A: Wren (This is my guess but I don’t think this will be revealed in the finale)

He was most likely Charlotte and Bethany’s doctor and I’m thinking we will learn more about his involvement in everything as season progresses.

WHO KILLED CHARLOTTE: Dr. Rollins (This is my guess but I don’t think this will be revealed in the finale)

I believe he killed Charlotte because he wanted to finally have a life with Alison and he felt Charlotte was just holding her back.

SARA HARVEY

Did Aria just make sure and touch not only all of Ezra's golf clubs, but all of her fathers clubs as well. Yep, sure did. -_-

The writers are literally throwing in all the old tricks; using Byron, Lucas, Toby and Ezra all as 'A' suspects. 

I have not cleared Lucas yet.. but if he were 'A' there would be no motive. Except maybe that the liars ignored him or something. But c'mon, we know Marlene isn't that boring.

I have a feeling Ezra witnessed Bryon meeting with a new love interest? Possibly a new women but my guess is that its back with Ella.

I found it super odd how Yvonne told Caleb that Toby would never sit down to watch TV with her unless its FNL, then she told Spencer they're binge watching retro TV. Yvonne is plotting something, we just don't have the proof we need to figure out what it is.

The new 'A' "uniform" better change from week to week because this old mail man is terrible. As of right now it seems so irrelevant to the whole show. I mean the black hoodie/red coat is what made 'A' that much more fascinating and this disguise is basically just awkward to look at.

Every time I post an 'A' theory, I want to change It the next episode. But these are my thoughts so far

Mona has been completely stripped of all her happiness. Her relationship with the girls is terrible. No matter how much of an asset Mona is and has been to the liars, they've always treated her as an outsider after her 'A' reveal,  and now after the time jump nothing has changed for example in 6X13 with Veronica's campaign

Episode 6X11 "Of Late I Think Of Rosewood" Mona requested that she was able to speak about the dollhouse and being tortured in regards to Charlotte being released. She approached Spencer and made it clear that she was still affected by what Charlotte had done to them and expressed that she was in the public eye and couldn't have her secrets exposed. Mona did not want Charlotte to be released and all of a sudden changed her story at the last minute. My theory is she knew Charlotte was going to be released no matter what after hearing the others testimony's and wanted fly under the radar, unlike Aria who became the first suspect after her testimony. When Mona says, "That's what all of us want, is to have a home" convinces me further that Mona's story is completely unresolved. 

Episode 6X13 "The Gloves Are Off" Some of the artifacts that were recovered were from the dollhouse and some were from the room in Radley that Charlotte was holding her family. My theory is that Mona stuck around after the girls ran to the roof and she kept specific things. 1. The doll reminded me so much of Mona. 2. The mannequin was in Radley and I don't think anyone, other then cops would have had access to it but I think Mona stole it before they had a chance.

Side note: Sara Harvey claims she was saying goodbye to someone when Emily asked her why she was at the cemetery. Who else is buried in Rosewood that she would be saying goodbye too? Bethany Young. I guarantee Sara Harvey is her twin. If you haven't already, read my Sara Harvey theory to see my entire theory on that. 

This ties into Mona because Mona is Bethany's true killer. My initial thought is when I saw the new 'A' text is that it was Sara Harvey telling the girls that she knows Mona is responsible and is seeking revenge for her sister.

This is what will make Mona become Uber "A". To hide the secrets from the past and END the 'A' game once and for all.

The first significant episode regarding Sara Harvey is 3x24 "A dAngerous gAme". At the time we weren't able to fully understand the episode because it was not revealed that Sara Harvey is Red Coat/Black Widow. It is revealed in 6x10 "Game Over Charles" that Sara Harvey was hired by Charlotte Dilaurentis as Red Coat to do her dirty work. She is the red coat who flies to the Thornhill Lodge to distract Mona. After Shana set fire to the lodge Sara pulled Mona, Aria, Spencer and Emily out of the burning lodge but left Hanna inside, who was then saved by Alison. When Alison saves Hanna she unknowingly reveals that she is alive to Shana, Wilden and Charlotte. Knowing that Wilden wouldn't allow Alison to come back, because of lies he told regarding her death and Radley Charlotte kills Wilden.

In 4x1 we see Black Veil with a burned Alison mask indicating that it was in-fact Sara Harvey who pulled Mona, Aria, Spencer and Emily out of the fire. But why did she leave Hanna? (Theory at bottom of post)

In 4x9 a Red Coat is seen unscrewing a panel In the Dilaurentis home, we can now assume Sara Harvey was the person hiding underneath the Dilaurentis home. There is holes in the floor boards hinting that the Red Coat has been spying on the everything that's been going on in the house.

Sara is mentioned in 4x14 "Whose in the Box". It is uncovered by Hanna that Sara went missing around the same time as Alison which causes her and Emily to meet with Sara's friends to find out more information about her. One of Sara's friends, Claire says this about Sara "She was pretty, poised and perfect and everything she gave you, she took two things away. I mean she's gone but she's not "gone". And we can't get away from her and I'm so tired of being Sara's friend, it just sucks the life out of you." 

In 5x6 "Run, Ali, Run" Black Veil is seen sending flowers to the parents of Bethany Young. Charlotte reveals in 6x10 that she absolutely hates Bethany after Bethany blamed Marion's death on "the boy in the dress". If Charlotte hated Bethany so much we must assume that she would not want to send flowers to her parents either. Sara Harvey had other reasons for sending flowers to them.

THEORY:

Sara was found in the doll house wearing the iconic yellow top. It is implied that Charles was forcing her to be Alison. In the same episode Mona (trapped in the dollhouse) is wearing the yellow top, and Alison (trying to save the liars)  is forced to wear the yellow top as well. Point being, there is at least four of the same outfit. Jason saw someone talking to Melissa in a yellow top, and Charlotte promises it was not her, my theory is this was Sara Harvey. I believe Sara Harvey is the twin of Bethany Young. It has not been revealed who told Bethany about Mrs. Dilaurentis and her fathers affair, my guess is her twin, Sara Harvey informed Bethany of the affair. This is when Bethany realized why Mrs. Dilaurentis was spoiling her. Bethany then steals Charlottes clothing and escapes Radley to get her revenge. I believe Sara went to the Dilaurentis house to find her missing twin, Bethany but instead found Melissa. Melissa had already buried Bethany's body at this time. Sara was then left with no clues as to where her sister had gone. From that evening she devoted her life to figure out where her sister had gone, hence faking her kidnapping. At this time Charlotte believed Alison was gone as well and I think Sara Harvey agreed to be the new Ali doll in order to find out what really happened to her sister, Bethany. When 'A' (Charlotte) and Red Coat are seen standing over Alison's grave in 3x01 "It Happened 'That Night' I believe this is the first time Sara realizes her sister is truly dead. At this point Sara realizes her sister was killed instead of Alison, giving her a reason to go after Alison and the people keeping her hidden. The night of the lodge fire 3x24 "A dangerous gAme", Sara flew to the lodge pretending to be an accomplice in hopes to get revenge. This is the reason she leaves Hanna in the fire to burn, because she thought it was Alison. The real Alison in fact saves Hanna, revealing that Alison is still alive. Sara Harvey continues to work for 'A' in hopes she will find Bethany's real killer. While grieving she secretly sends flowers to her parents in 5x6. In 6x10 "Game Over Charles" Mona reveals that she hit Bethany with the shovel, thinking it was Alison. When Mona saw Alison walking later that night she assumed Alison didn't die from the shovel and tried to cover up what she had done by helping Alison fake her death, creating the first 'A'. She would not have any reason to believe anyone else was killed, until it is revealed that Bethany was in the grave. As of now, Five years later, I believe Sara Harvey knows exactly who killed her sister (Mona). I believe she blackmailed Mona into giving a fake testimony to make sure Charlotte was released and that's why Mona changed her story so last minute. It would explain her reaction when Sara Harvey comes to Charlottes funeral and why she bolted so quickly after the funeral ended.

Spencer + Caleb (Spaleb) - Caleb admitted to Hanna that was with Spencer in Washington when she received the letter from Alison and that he is currently living in Spencer’s barn. Spencer was shocked to hear Toby say she saw Caleb; she was even more shocked when he says "We're the brotherhood of ex-boyfriends we have to stick together". Theory: Spencer and Caleb were grieving over they’re failed relationships and found comfort in each other. I think Hanna knows more than we think. 

Emily- Took a year longer to finish college. Her father passed away, she returned for the funeral but hasn’t been back to Rosewood since. Seen taking pills and hypodermic needles were seen falling from her purse. Theory: Need more information on this still but as of now I think Emily is collecting fluid opposed to injecting something. Perhaps blood? None the less she is on medication which we all know will pose a problem when mixed with alcohol, which she was drinking the night Charlotte was murdered.

Nicole Gordon- Went missing while working on her community project in South America. Ezra is devastated after she goes missing. Theory: I think she is dead. I think the writers killed her off to create a more complex story for Ezria

Sara Harvey- I think the two important questions we must focus on. 1) When did she become an alliance with Charlotte? 2) What happened to her the evening that Charlotte was revealed as ‘A’? We know that something happened the night Charlotte was arrested and that she blames on the liars. It caused her to be hospitalized for a short time but then was released from the hospital Labor Day weekend when the liars left for college. She wasn't permitted to testify in Charlotte’s case because of how her criminal charges were handled. Perhaps self-incrimination? A person is given the right to refuse testifying if the evidence presented will incriminate themselves. Theory: Sara wasn’t lying when she said she tried to save the liars. I think she is Bethany Young’s twin sister and wanted to figure out what happened to her sister, therefore she was working with Charlotte. This would also explain Mona’s reaction when Sara walked into Charlotte’s funeral, considering she is the one who killed Bethany. AS of now, after whatever happened to the night Charlotte was arrested and after the liars sided with Alison and Charlotte that night she has a grudge against them.

Mona- Approached Spencer and informed her that she has nightmares and asked if she still did too, she demanded to be heard at Charlottes hearing but then ended up changing her story after she heard the other girls confessions. Was seen at Charlotte’s funeral and left very promptly without talking to the liars.  Theory: Need more information before I can decide what I think the queen is up too now. As of now I think her plan all along was to change her story at the last minute to try and make sure Charlotte was released from the hospital.

IMPORTANT CLUES:

Charlotte’s body was found with purple roses that appeared to be on the table that Alison had made up for her tea party with Charlotte to celebrate her getting released from the hospital. Who-ever is responsible for her death had access into Alison's house. (Dr. Rollins?)

Lorenzo seems shady AF. It seems like he got the promotion Toby mentioned he didn’t get, considering Lorenzo was wearing a suit and badge opposed to Toby who was wearing a cop uniform.

PLL FANDOM..

I re-watched 6x10 Game Over Charles and there are few details I think are important going into 6B 

WILDEN- Was paid off twice, once to cover up that Charlotte hit Ali over the head with the rock, and to hide the truth about what happened to Toby's mother. Charlotte killed Wilden because he found out Ali was actually alive and if she came back it would come out that he was paid off by Mrs. D to hide Ali's (fake) death.   

Wilden had the most information out of the characters who are now dead. Whoever uber 'A' is, used Wilden to find out about Charlotte and Mrs. D's secrets; that resulted in her death.

SARA HARVEY- Was Red Coat at the lodge to distract Mona, also to reveal to Charlotte if Ali was truly alive. Was also Black Widow. If you remember Black Widow sends flowers to Bethany Young's parents.  

My theory is that Sara Harvey is a twin or sister to Bethany Young. She never admits to actually helping Charlotte, in-fact she tells the girls she was trying to keep them safe.

In the scene where we see Red Coat mess with the explosives it could almost seem as if she was trying to dis-able them or ignite them to kill Charlotte and Ali in order to keep the liars safe.