- Kissing Jessica Stein -
The 2001 sapphic romantic comedy Kissing Jessica Stein to me was in many ways ahead of it's time and in others very clearly a victim of it's time. My girlfriend actually introduced it to me as a movie she had seen and really enjoyed. She thought it was funny, though the ending felt a bit disappointing. So I watched it and I felt pretty much the same. Afterwards I went on Letterboxd to log it and was surprised to find how many people absolutely hate this movie.
I really liked it. And apparently that is a bit of a controversial take. Now, I understand that the ending of this movie can feel like a let down. It did to me too, at least a little bit. But I also think it is a very interesting look at sexuality. Not only the fluidity that is shown through both of the main characters, who have perviously only dated men, falling in love with each other and entering a lesbian relationship. But also Jessica's (to me) very apparent asexuality.
I saw people complaining about the movie setting the bisexual movement back or it making no sense for Jessica to be interested in a man at the end of the movie since she has shown very little interest and compatibility with men throughout the movie. And I do see that point. It surely is not the best bi rep we have and I'm very glad we have gotten better, more well rounded characters. But I think it's an interesting look at fluidity and Jessica potentially dating a man does not erase the very real relationship she had with Helen.
I think where a lot of us get felt irritation, at least that was the case for me, is that one sentence at the end of the movie where Jessica says that she wasn't "gay enough" for Helen and that is why they broke up. Now, I think this is exactly where the movie misunderstood it's own story and I blame the early 2000s for it. Helen and Jessica did not break up because Jessica isn't queer, they broke up because they wanted different things from a relationship. Mainly, Helen wanted sex and Jessica did not. Or at least not as much as Helen. The Problem wasn't not being "gay enough" it was not being allosexual.
We get very, very little asexual representation in media and I don't expect a 2001 movie to be part of that. But they portrayed it none the less. If intentional or not, they did. Jessicas behavior surrounding sex felt very real and relatable and close to many asexual experiences. She needs time to get accustomed to things, go step by step. She needs to feel comfortable first with Helen, try things out. But that does not mean that she doesn't fall in love with Helen. Because she clearly does. It is noticeable to everyone in the movie, even her mother (which leads to a sweet coming out scene). She grows to be happier and more confident. She finds someone who understands her and, as she says herself, they "click". They build a life and a partnership together and there are clearly romantic feelings involved. Jessica not liking sex or not wanting to have it as often as Helen, does not make her less gay. Sometimes relationships between asexual and allosexual people don't work, for this very reason. Even if they're both extremely gay!
But then again this is a movie from 2001. Jessica herself doesn't seem aware that there is such a thing as asexuality or that she might be on that spectrum. And maybe the whole movie isn't. Maybe it wasn't meant to be read as such (but oh boy it does!). Maybe they did want to frame it as Jessica just "not being that gay" at the end of the movie. But that's such wansted potential.
To me the problem was not that they broke up. Yes, it was sad and I wish they could have ended up together. But the breakup also felt painfully real. And possibly very relatable to a lot of ace people out there. At the end of the movie Helen is shown continuing to date women and Jessica maybe potentially getting back together with her ex (a man). That alone, to me, is not necessarily a problem. But it all falls with that one sentence. Jessica not being aware of her own asexuality (even though she states at one point not finding many things sexy sooo...) and not having the vocabulary for it, makes it seem like the movie is trying to erase her queerness. It can feel like the movie is trying to "correct" itself at the end by making the straight love story the one we should have been paying attention to all along.
BUT. IT'S NOT AND WE SHOULDN'T.
This is a love story between two women who are learning and exploring new things about themselves. Who fall in love and break up (very real of them to stay friends btw). If this movie hadn't been made at the time that it was it could have been a really nuanced and realistic prortrail of sexuality and the complications that a ace/allo partnership can bring. About the difference between romantic attraction and sexual attraction. And how, for many people, they are so closely intertwined they can't seperate them at all. And for others they are two completely different things. A careful portrail of a very real relationship between two queer women with different understandings and desires.
I don't know, it felt important to me and I was just surprised by how many people understood it so differently. "I guess I wasn't gay enough for her" did make my stomach drop though and I'm trying really hard to not let it ruin the whole movie for me.