painfulguess!

but then I realised that same challenge would be infinitely more funny with folks who have atypical or horror OCs

Back in my early days,I had made this Au where during chapter 7-8 of Beast Yeast, Fortune Teller Cookie is unable to save them in time and they fall in the yoghurt river. The flow of the river eventually takes them all the way to the garden of delights where they are found by Sugar Fly.

Due to reasons (recovering from almost drowning, losing their weapons in the river, plus some convincing from ESC) they decide to stay in the garden to recover and make a plan to save PV. And during that time they start bonding with ESC and Warming up to her. Who on her part, quickly starts getting attached to them since no cookie has ever shown such sincere back kindness to her. Which leads both parties opening up to the other.

(ESC taking GingerBrave flying and exploring the garden. Strawberry finally having a chance to breathe and talking naps with ESC in the clouds. ESC learning to listen to Wizard’s rambles and indulging him. Allowing them to breathe and be children.) Basically she adopts them, which becomes a problem when the idea of saving PV rears its head. This causes ESC to panic and fabricate excuses and problems that makes them prolong their stay.

It all comes to a head when HBC arrives. And now they must try to convince ESC to let them leave and even help them since they saw the good in her and think she could change and be a better cookie.

(and while all of this is happening, PV is losing his mind as he thinks the kids have died)

This one went longer than expected. I’m a sucker for the found family trope and I love to give the Brave trio Parent Figures/ Found Familes. Speaking of which:

This one is a bit simpler but basically After the DE war. The Dough Trio look for refuge and come across the trio. ( Who have decided (Wc&SBc) to take it easy and rest for a while in the Cookie Kingdom) Who invite them to their home and with no other options accept this. This one is basically just a fluff Au where both trios bond over witch trauma and become a wierd family in the process.

(Also the ancient are unaware of this, and in fear of what they might do since they are former CoD members the doughs must stay hidden)

I hope these ideas aren’t too weird 😅. I’m writing this with personal interpretation and with what I remember. (plus I haven’t checked out the newest update yet) so if anything seems off or OOC that probably why.

(I also just remembered this other Au I made with Light Cream cookie but it’s the middle of the night and I should probably go to bed, but let me now if you wanna hear it)

HOLY SHIT THOSE ARE SO AWESOME WHAT THANKS ANON 🥹🥹

In the cookie Odyssey, specifically Chapter 2, Day 3, Elder Mille-Feuille Cookie asks Gingerbrave to accompany her to Choco Mud Town. He agrees, and while he is following her, they encounter a Cookie asking for money.

Now, Gingerbrave very obviously sees the encounter between the background cookie and EMF. He sees a cookie in need of help, and he knows that EMF has the Coins to spare- they were going to the market, after all.

But Gingerbrave turns the other cheek. He chose to follow a trusted person instead of his desire to help.

EMF, to him, is trustworthy! She is a figure of power in the Creme Republic, she greets him kindly, she asks him for help- just about everything every other friend in his life did. Hell, half of the ancients didn't do that and they're still his friends!

And, what makes it clear to me that he didn't feel good about this choice, he stutters. Not once, before or after that interaction, did he hesitate to act. He was not nervous around her at all, did not suspect anything wrong with her.

He listened simply because she is a friend - and he trusts his friends more than anything.

...which leads to your post about Soli/ the Radiant Cookie taking white lily's form as a sympathetic jab. Gingerbrave is already willing to run back to the "really scary" witch if it means he's helping someone. He almost JOINED the Ultimate Cookie to help his friends, like, 2 seconds ago in lore!!!!

I think Soli knows and recognizes this in Gingerbrave's behavior as he, too, is a representation of solidarity as a whole. (Look at how many Cookies he rallied together for the cause, how his whole goal is to live, how he doesn't tell anyone about his feelings of insignificance/powerlessness)

and I think Soli is using it for their own reasons. I don't think they're,,,, evil, but they are likely self-serving and uncaring about the Cookies they were made to help.

aaah all tired now bye

YES YES YES! THEY ARE NOT EVIL BUT MORALLY DISCONNECTED FROM COOKIEKIND!!!!

Like they have a very set path in mind and Soli knows GB is very vulnerable in trust. I love love love this point. I actually am NOT very caught up in Odyssey because I've just...forgotten about it tbh! I have started chapter 2 but im only on day 1-2.

Could lead to SMC also taking advantage and using the voice of a friend (Strawberry, Wizard, PVC, Soli/Lily (since they share a voice)...

sigh someone help this boy

My friend made a puzzle game and I wanted to help with advertising it! So, uhh. 3 hour long Ms Paint drawing GO!!!!!

Sort of an ad here.

If you like hand-drawn graphics, chess, and/or turn based strategy, please view the read more!