Comments On Last Exile: Ginyoku no Fam
I just recently go done watching Last Exile and while I thought overall it was a good show and what I am about to say is not particular to this show and more with shows that follow the same basic theme that was presented in Last Exile.
My problem concerns with how Premier Luscinia or Lukia as he was called in the one episode tried to attain his goal of true world peace. Even though it happened at the end I still contend that it was the wrong way to go about. The massive war and destruction that put upon the world in Last Exile is inexcusable in my opinion. I can understand that he wanted to usher in world peace for future generation I believe it did not give him the right to violate the rights and lives of those currently living. This was the same thing that happened in Code Geass. Even in that show I found the theme inexcusable.
Both Luscinia and Lelouch could have carried out making a better world without the need to kill people or oppress them. Both of them could have lived in the world they would have helped create, but instead they chose the cowards way out and involved more people in their meaningless slaughter. They willingly killed people who had families that would miss them. They destroyed land that could have better used to grow more food for people. They also wasted countless other resources of the planet by the machines of war they made.
All the war, suffering, and strife could have been avoided if they would have taken the harder route and held diplomatic negotiations. While not making for an interesting show because most people have an interest in explosions and betrayal. It would have shown a much better model to emulate for the people watching. War is always the easy way, but it is also the most crude way. It is the most crude because then you get people that look evil to other people because of the actions they have committed. This is what happened to Premier Luscinia and Liliana in Last Exile.
Luscinia thought he was doing the right thing and convinced Liliana of the same thing. Luscinia then proceeded to tear apart nations and sacrifice there people upon the altar of war. Last Exile even showed a repetition of event between the killing of the former Augusta Frahnaz and the killing of Liliana by Dian. Not everyone will perceive the noble intentions of the person even if that is what they have. When people have seen their friends and family die because of a conflict they can't understand it breeds hatred. Even though Luscinia eventually made the world peaceful it was at a great cost. No one knows how many children were killed/orphaned because of the conflict.
The one thing that Last Exile and Code Geass never showed were the people traumatized by the war. The people that witnessed the people being killed or the people doing the killing. This is what happened with General Orang when he decided to join the Joint Forces. He started have misgivings about the need for the killing after the Exile was used on Glacies. Just wish the misgivings and doubts would have came before all the meaningless slaughter.
The people traumatized by the war are most likely the ones who will go on to cause the next conflict. This why I believe the theme presented was the wrong one. Sure diplomacy may always take longer and everyone may not get what they want, but to me it shows that an understanding was made and that at anytime future generations can revisit the issue and workout something else that suits them. Peace is not made by killing people and tearing the world apart. It is made by taking the time to get to know other people and actually hear them out. Peace is mutually beneficial agreement between the people involved.
This is idea that I think Fam held onto was the much more hard way to peace. She never once killed anyone when hunting for the Federation's ships for Captain Tatiana of the Silvius. Even until the end she held onto the belief that people could talk out their problems and come to an understanding. And on that note is where I end this rant.