it is sort of weird that after a decade or more of environmentalism (both professional and lumpen) focusing the vast majority of messaging on carbon dioxide reduction (with anti-nuclear sitting way in the back seat), carbon dioxide is just out
like I can't believe that the green opposition to, say, building a new 9GW natural gas plant to feed a 9GW data center in Utah is primarily focused on how much water the data center might use for cooling chips, with NIMBYish land use fears and heat island catastrophism playing second fiddle. If the Utah guys had proposed exactly the same data center with exclusively wind+solar+battery power the green backlash would look almost exactly the same!
what happened here? Uncharitable guess is that the highest-viz climate groups (e.g. sunrise, extinction rebellion, greenpeace, Sierra club) got hollowed out by 5 years of scope creep (e.g. Gaza, BLM), leaving the field open for off-message influencers on tiktok or whatever.
also nobody in this crowd seems to have noticed that gas plants (like all thermal generation, including nuclear) also generate concentrated low-grade heat and require cooling, traditionally done by evaporating water. Not trying to summon any demons here but like that is exactly what those big towers with big white steam clouds billowing out are doing.
it's all very strange I tell you
also rapid self reblog to add that the "we're all gonna die in the next 20 years" messaging we all remember from the climate change era is completely unchanged, but instead of the cause being runaway greenhouse effect, it's water scarcity because the AI is drinking it all (and sometimes fear that the data center heat islands are going to literally fry us alive)
doomers gonna doom ofc but man I wish the death of climate change anxiety had lowered the temperature (har har) a bit
I'm really bewildered by this.
I tend to assume that Trumpism suddenly replacing climate change as the Doom is a bigger factor. It's all weird.
I haven't heard concern about doom from AI environmental effects. I've been under the impression that AI concerns are largely an realm of local politics.
Yeah maybe this is a bubble thing: both of us are now (alas) Olds who are no longer With It, so our windows on the zeitgeist are increasingly dim.
But my impression is that the anti-AI leftist youth movement you see on this hellsite has merged with nonpartisan local-politics NIMBYism and conservative-coded farm defenders to form a growing big-tent consensus that new data center construction should be banned or restricted. AOC & Bernie sponsored bills on this last month, but Josh Hawley and Nancy Mace are also in the news as being on this train.
Anyway, the left/green corner of this tent looks to me like what I described above. Agreed though that Trump-based doomerism is also popular with that audience.

















