Their lips met and Grace froze, waiting. Waiting for it to stop feeling like wet flesh against his mouth. For a spark, heat, electricity, anything to change and morph and feel good instead of awkward. He had his eyes squeezed shut, both hands fisting the fabric of Simon's shirt. Was this how it should be like? Should he be holding his breath?
Simon thumbed a sliver of his skin where his hand rested on Grace's hip, sending subtle goosebumps up his spine. He was coaxing, patiently waiting for Grace and it stirred up an anxious coil in the pit of his stomach. This wasn't how it should feel like. He's read stories, seen movies, how they all portrayed this first kiss as something magical. Something special and cherished. Shouldn't it alight the part of his brain that craved this intimacy? He thought this would be it. Why did it feel so... strange?
Grace pressed a little closer, the humidity of Simon's exhale ghosting over his face. He could feel Simon's heart jackrabbiting under his fist, the radiating heat of his hand sinking into his side. Grace parted his mouth, licking his bottom lip, catching the hitch in Simon's breath as the other opened and reciprocated. He felt the tongue and warmth and saliva and his heart raced into knots for all the wrong reasons. Why wasn't it working? He didn't know how to turn the cold sweat beading at the back of his neck into something he should desire.
Grace pulled away, his face warm from the tears and the confusion and the guilt. He ducked his head, sleeve already wiping away at the mess, a choked noise swallowed down. Simon's hand fell away, coming up to his bicep, he can't face Simon. "I-I'm sorry, I don't, I don't get it. I like you- I swear, I do! I like you; I like you and- but. I. I don't understand how- why I can't- it doesn't-" He shakes his head, eyes burning. Grace asked for this, he asked to test it and he's hurting Simon all the same. "I tried! I really tried to- We- we can try again! Maybe-"
He's cut off by Simon's hand holding his jaw, gentle. Grace breathes carefully, trying to rein in the tears pricking his eyes. After a moment, he follows Simon's hand and lets his face be turned to look at him. The complicated worry he sees there makes him want to burst into tears all over again. It's cowardice that compels him to pull Simon into a hug, just so he doesn't have to look at that face. Simon's only arm rests on his back, hand between his shoulder blades and rubbing small circles there.
What is he doing? Grace should be the one comforting Simon.
"So. Not good?" Simon tests. Grace shakes his head minutely where he rested on Simon's shoulder. Grace feels the measured breath Simon takes, the swallow he does, and the slight tremble of his exhale. "Okay." He says simply, carefully neutral. The hand on his back doesn't stop. "It's fine. Well, uh, not fine, but. It's okay." His voice is thick with unidentified emotion, rumbling through his chest and into his head. "It's okay."
Simon drops his forehead onto Grace's shoulder, tightening his one-armed hold as he works through what that meant.