You Can Kiss a Hundred Boys in Bars
------------
gavin mckenna/jackson smith
story summary: Gavin McKenna and Jackson Smith agreed to take a break while they established themselves in hockey. Turns out pretending not to care about each other is a lot harder than either of them expected.
check it out on ao3
------------
Everything was complicated.
They had agreed to be on a break while they both settled into their hockey careers, but that didnât make it hurt any less leaving Penn State and, therefore, Jackson behind. A break that meant they were allowed, and were expected, to go out with other people.
Everyone who had met him knew Gavin was loyal to a fault. He tried to forget about the agreement, let Jackson breathe, settle into Toronto. They were at two different points in their careers; they needed everything to settle, to both get established in the league before they continued with whatever they were.
They never put words to it, just fleeting feelings and moments that they both knew meant more but were too scared to label. Quick glances, sitting overly close to each other on the bench, among other actions that could be brushed off as âboys being boys.â They were too scared of what the realities meant for themselves and their futures. Moments can be denied, pushed to the back. Boyfriends are much harder to deal with, so they didnât, and now Gavin was in a fucking different country, pretending he didnât care.
Soon enough he would have hockey to burry himself in. The first few weeks were manageable as he quickly met everyone and got to learning the systems. Hockey filled any gaps during the day. At night, though, the apartment went quiet and his phone that once constantly lit up stayed dark.
He told himself he just needed a distraction, so he went out. There was nothing stopping him anymore, he was legal in Canada, no more sneaking around or bribes needed to get his hands on alcohol.
The first couple of times were innocent enough as he was surrounded by his teammates that subconsciously kept him in check. He had to be on edge around them, especially with alcohol involved, scared he would slip up if he was any looser.
It was Auston Matthews who first really pushed him past that careful line he kept trying to draw for himself. Polite laughs, smiles, and nods could only get him so far when everyone else was hellbent on pushing.
It wasnât malicious. He was just trying to get the rookies to settle in. A hand on his shoulder in a crowded bar, a lazy grin as he looked around the room and decided Gavin needed to loosen up more than he was willing to admit.
âCome on,â Auston said one night, nodding toward a group of girls across the bar, âYouâre overthinking it. Just go have some fun, no strings attached.â
Gavin shouldâve said no and excused himself to go home all to avoid the unwanted interaction but he also didnât want to get chirped to the end of the Earth for âbeing a chickenâ. Refusing didnât always feel like an option especially when he was still finding his place in a league that valued conformity above all.
Auston took the lead as his âwingmanâ ordering drinks for everyone, introducing Gavin, he only left as the blonde girl separated from her group and took Gavin to the dancefloor. She was pretty, confident, clearly expecting the night to go in a predictable direction. He assumed Auston saw his duties as fulfilled as he sat back and watched the girl grind all over him from the table.
Gavin could feel the expectations settling over him, they were just showing a rookie the ropes. The story had a predictable ending, one that everyone was expecting from him. So he played along.
He got his teammates laughing and clapping him on the back as he left with the girl, Liv, he vaguely recalled.
The walk outside was colder than he expected, the kind of cold that nipped at fingers. She stayed close to him on the way out, arm brushing his, laughing softly like they already knew each other better than they did.
Everything really shouldâve ended there, no one would have known the difference. He could just lie when the guys asked later, but Gavin was an awful liar.
By the time they got to his place, the performance had already started to feel like second nature. Keys in hand, door open, lights too bright in the hallway. He let her inside like this was his normal routine.
------------
He didnât drink any more than usual the night before but he felt as if he had been hit by a truck. Liv was gone in the morning, a hastily written note in her place. In a way he was glad, he was able to avoid any awkward conversations that would have come his way.
Once again his apartment was quiet in an unnatural way, one that left him feeling uneasy. Last year, he always had Jackson crashing in his room, refusing to leave him alone no matter how much he wanted to be. They would be casually laying on top of each other as they argued while playing chel. He would pepper Jackson with kisses to distract him while he scored on the other boy.
Gavin stared at the ceiling, one arm thrown over his eyes, wishing he could shut his brain off for five minutes. If he really tried, he could bet he could find a hoodie that Jackson left over that had made it all the way to Toronto.
They had never been boyfriends. They had never made promises. But why did Gavin feel so guilty? This was the point of the deal, for them to have relationships outside of each other as their locations and schedules didnât line up.
His phone buzzed on the nightstand.
Auston: Did you have fun?
Auston: Just tell me you didnât scare her off.
Gavinâs fingers hovered above the keys before he decided on what to say.
Gavin: she survived
He left a lot up to interpretation, perfect for the overactive imagination of his teammate. A string of laughing emojis followed his message.
His thumb drifted automatically to Jacksonâs contact. The chat hadn't disappeared. It was still there, just buried beneath newer conversations. Weeks of messages had slowed into days between responses. The time between strings of messages seemed to keep getting longer. Now that they werenât together 24/7 due to proximity, everything was slower. Was their thing only possible due to location? Was it only a fling?
He tossed the phone onto the mattress and screamed into the nearest pillow. He hoped his walls were thick.
Everything became easier after the first. He only picked up girls when his teammates were around, but when he found himself alone it was always other boys. It became habit, baked into his routine. On his days off, he was always at the bar chatting up anyone he could.
No longer was he the quiet rookie that needed help settling in, for the most part his teammates left him along as long as it wasnât for âteammate bonding.â He was fitting in. That was what everyone wanted, wasn't it?
Gavin quickly learned that if people think they know what's going on, they stop asking questions.
Nobody looked twice when he disappeared after games anymore. Nobody questioned him when he declined invitations because he "already had plans." Nobody seemed concerned when he stumbled into practice looking exhausted.
The narrative had already been written for him: a rookie in Toronto, young, hot, single, and having fun. Exactly what everyone expected. They didnât know the details and they didnât need to, it would only make them more disappointed in him.
He spent every moment he could away from his apartment where the silence was suffocating. If that meant finding someone willing to take him home then so be it. Anywhere but home. Home was where he found himself opening old conversations and rereading messages like a complete loser.
He still texted Jackson but every text felt like a dagger to his heart. The one boy he couldnât have, the one kept at armâs length. They each would share tidbits about their day- stupid errors made, travel complaints, and even the occasional selfie but now Gavin found himself staring at his phone wondering if he'd already texted Jackson too much that day. They used to text constantly, now everything felt like too much.
He couldnât be the one starting the chain every time. One random notification could completely change his mood which was probably a sign that he was completely screwed.
------------
As the season wore on, he got sloppy. Not on the ice, never on the ice. He used to be meticulous in how he picked up in bars. He would check around, make sure no teammates were near, keep his head down, and make sure no one recognized him.
Too many times not getting caught got him to slip. It didnât all happen at once which probably made it even worse.
He stopped taking girls back to impress the guys, instead he would wait for most of the table to leave then he could sneak out with another guy. He no longer kept every intimate moment hidden behind closed doors, kissing people more openly in the bars he frequented. He didnât switch up the bars as much anymore, he didnât constantly check over his should.
It really shouldnât have come as a shock when rumors of an NHL player kissing boys in bars started spreading across Twitter and ended up on the deuxmoi Instagram page. None of them mentioned his name specifically or Toronto but it felt like a slap in the face.
Apparently there's an NHL player who's a regular at a few bars and has been seen leaving with different guys. No clue who it is but hockey Twitter is trying to figure it out.
He felt nauseous. He'd been so focused on not thinking about Jackson that he hadn't noticed people were paying attention.
Everything kept moving and so Gavin moved with it. He lessened up on the picking up guys in bars and traded it for hanging out with Easton Cowan. Despite the fact they had known each other before, their interactions werenât the most natural.
The first time they grabbed coffee together, Gavin was convinced neither of them actually wanted to be there.
"So..." Easton said, staring at his drink.
"So.â
Another period of long silence. Easton nodded and Gavin nodded back.
"Good talk,â Easton gritted out.
That finally got a laugh out of Gavin, "You're the one who invited me."
"Yeah, and?" was Eastonâs rebuttal.
"You don't have anything to say? At all?"
Easton shrugged, "I thought we'd figure it out when we got here. It takes two after all."
They had gotten better since then, but it was a rough first few meetings. Thankfully, the built-in awkwardness allowed Gavin to not think about how it all reminded him of Jackson.
------------
Winter turned into spring and the rumors fell to the wayside. They werenât forgotten but they no longer felt like they were crushing Gavinâs chest. Without new stories, people eventually got bored and moved on to the next piece of gossip.
Gavin was grateful but he was more careful afterward.
The whole thing had forced him to confront something he had spent months avoiding. The hookups werenât helping and neither was the alcohol, if anything it made it all worse. None of it was a meaningful connection, just something for both parties to forget, it made the loyal part of his brain scream. None of it made him miss Jackson less.
He hated the quiet nights, the ones with no games and no one coming over to bother him. He found himself scrolling through his camera roll with a slight smile plastered across his face.
There was a photo of Jackson asleep on the bus in Gavinâs hoodie, a blurry video of their locker room celebration with the smallest glimpse of Jackson. Gavin immediately closed the video before reopening it and rewatching it three times. He was pathetic.
His phone buzzed and he was tempted to ignore it but then he saw the name âJackson.â He could never ignore Jackson.
Jackson: are you alive?
Gavin: unfortunately :/
Jackson: damn
Jackson: i was hoping to inherit your shit
A smile tugged at Gavin's mouth. The next hour was spent texting about everything and nothing at the same time. He felt at peace, everything came easy when it was him and Jackson.
It only made the silence worse because he got the reminder of what was missing in his life. It was their agreement, their wishes, but why did it make him feel so miserable?
------------
Everyone kept asking what his offseason plans were and truly he didnât know. It was probably going to end up with him in Whitehorse for a few weeks before heading to Kelowna for training. He didnât have any plans to show anyone around his hometown unlike last year when Jackson came up.
Easton was sprawled across Gavin's couch one afternoon when he finally said it, "You know you're weird, right?" He said it like it as a fact.
Gavin looked up from his phone baffled, "That's rich coming from you."
"I'm serious."
"So am I."
Easton threw a pillow at his head but Gavin caught it, "You're doing that thing again."
Gavin couldnât hide the incredulous look that appeared on his face, "What thing?"
"The staring,â Easton said it as if he was dumb.
"I literally don't stare."
Easton rolled his eyes, "You absolutely stare."
Easton pointed toward the phone in his hand, "You get a text and suddenly you're smiling at your screen like you're in a rom-com."
"I do not,â he tried to futilely argue.
"You do."
"I don't."
Easton stared and Gavin stared back. Easton raised an eyebrow and Gavin conceded, âMaybe a little."
âOh just a little?â Easton teased Gavin.
âShut up!â Gavin lightly pushed Easton. They both devolved into laughter for a little bit.
Eastonâs laughter stopped, âYou ever gonna do something about it?"
Gavin froze, âWhat do you mean?â
Easton stared, âOh youâre gonna make me spell it out. The guy.â
Turns out he wasnât as good at hiding everything than he thought. He had barely gone out post-rumors and yet Easton still fucking knew. Simultaneously he wanted to laugh and to burst into tears.
He tried to keep a straight face, âI donât know what youâre talking about.â
Easton rolled his eyes at his response, âBullshit.â
It felt like too much all at once, âItâs not like heâs around anyways,â Gavin immediately regretted the words that fell from his mouth.
Easton's expression softened, "Oh."
 âYeah.â Gavinâs sanity was holding on by a thread. Everything became all too real all too quickly.
Easton looked back over, âYou love him?â
His lower lip trembled just slightly, âI donât know.â
âThatâs not a no,â Easton snorted.
Gavin sighed, âNo, itâs not.â
------------
A few days later his phone lit up with a familiar picture, Jackson. He had sent a blurry photo from an awkward angle, the boy looked dead tired.
Gavin: you look dead
Jackson: damn thatâs fucked up man
Gavin: sometimes the truth hurts
He sent an equally bad photo back. Their conversations came naturally and as if no time had passed. They could just be and that was enough for him.
Maybe the problem hadnât been the break but the fact they never talked about what they were in the first place. They eventually needed to address the elephant in the room but Gavin wasnât good with difficult conversations and especially not starting them. On the ice everything was easy, off the ice it was more complicated.
------------
Summer had come and he packed his bags to go home to Whitehorse for some relaxation before going back to training. While he had gotten used to Toronto, he needed some extended time out in nature. It was always weird being back in his room, the one he hadnât spent most of his time in since he was twelve years old. The room was a relic, decked out in his various jerseys and achievements all mixed in with his Blackhawks gear.
His goal had always been to be drafted to an NHL team but he never got much farther than that. He didnât realize how hard it was going to be once he made it.
His phone buzzed, Jackson had sent a picture of what looked like airport coffee.
Gavin: looks disgusting
The typing bubble appeared immediately.
Jackson: it is
Jackson: pretty sure it's actively poisoning me
Gavin: thoughts and prayers
Jackson: appreciate it
The conversation had ended there but two days later there was a knock on his door. He wasnât expecting anyone and no one else was home but he dragged himself over to the door anyways.
He opened it and had to stop himself from immediately slamming it shut. Jackson was there with his stupid hat and his suitcase looking exhausted.
For a solid five seconds Gavin genuinely thought he was hallucinating, "Jackson?"
Jackson gave an awkward wave, "Hi."
"What the fuck?"
"That's fair."
They stood there for a bit as Gavin processed what he was seeing.
âUh you can come in I guess,â he remembered his manners. If his mom was here she would be scolding him for making Jackson stand outside for so long.
The problem was that Gavin had spent months imagining seeing Jackson again. None of those scenarios had included Jackson sitting across from him at the kitchen table while Gavin slowly lost his mind. Neither of them had touched the drinks sitting between them.
Jackson was the one who broke the silence, "Are you going to keep staring at me?" he asked.
Gavin blinked, "You showed up in Whitehorse without warning me."
"Yeah,â he kind of said it like it was obvious.
"You flew all the way to the Yukon."
Jackson nodded, "Yes."
Gavin threw his hands in the air, "What the fuck is wrong with you?"
To his surprise, Jackson laughed.
"Plenty of things," Jackson admitted, "That's kind of why I'm here. I think we need to talk."
Gavinâs stomach dropped. What if this was Jackson finally completely breaking it off with him? Whatever âitâ actually was. Fuck undefined relationships.
He suddenly wished he had cleaned the kitchen or changed out of the hoodie he'd slept in or maybe fled into the Yukon wilderness before Jackson had shown up on his doorstep. Instead, he sat frozen at the table while Jackson looked equally miserable across from him.
"Talk about what?" Gavin asked quietly as he braced himself for the inevitable.
Jackson stared down at his hands, "Us."
Fuck that was ominous, he totally was cutting him off.
"There isn't really an us, the second the words left his mouth he regretted them. He was just trying to protect himself.
Jackson's head snapped up, "That's bullshit."
âWhat?" Gavin questioned.
"That's bullshit," Jackson repeated, "And you know it."
Something sharp twisted in Gavin's chest, "Then what are we?" he shot back, "Because I'd genuinely love to know."
Jacksonâs mouth opened but just as quickly closed again with no words spoken.
Gavin laughed bitterly, "Yeah. That's what I thought."
"I saw the rumors,â Gavin froze, âat first I told myself it wasn't you and then I told myself even if it was you, it wasnât my business. I know we have our deal but it just made me angry. I was really fucking angry.â
"You were angry?"
Jackson looked at him like he'd lost his mind, "Of course I was angry."
"Why?" The deal was Jacksonâs idea in the first place, he only agreed to it because thatâs what Jackson wanted so why was he angry.
The answer came immediately, "Because every time I heard another story I wanted to punch someone."
Gavin stared blankly.
Jackson looked frustrated now, like the words were physically painful to say, "I hated hearing about it."
"You don't get to hate hearing about it,â The words escaped before Gavin could stop them.
"What?" Jackson almost shouted that one word.
"You don't,â months of hurt came rushing up all at once, âYou wanted the break."
Jackson's expression hardened, "We both wanted the break."
Gavin shot him a glare, "No. We both agreed to it."
Gavin laughed again, "You know what the worst part is? I actually tried," his voiced cracked, âI tried to do exactly what we agreed to. I went out. I met people. I hooked up with people."
Jackson flinched.
"Because that's what we said we were supposed to do and every single time," Gavin continued, "I ended up thinking about you."
Gavin immediately wished he could take the words back. The emotions so raw he didnât want to feel them.
"I couldn't get rid of you," he admitted, âI tried. I kept thinking itâd eventually stop hurting but it never did.â
The hurt on Jacksonâs face morphed into softness, âYouâre such a fucking idiot.â
âOkay well fuck you too,â Gavin spit back at him.
"No," Jackson said as he grabbed Gavinâs hands, "Listen to me. I spent almost an entire year trying not to call you every day. I spent months convincing myself that giving you space was the right thing.â
"You think you're the only one who was miserable? I hated every second of this,â Jackson stated.
"Then why?" Gavin asked quietly, "Why did we do it?"
Jackson let out a hollow laugh, "Because I was scared. We were about to go in completely different directions. You got drafted to Toronto and I was going to be at Penn State. It felt like it would be impossible," he swallowed, "Long distance. Hockey schedules. The whole nine-yards.â
"So your solution was to blow us up before anything could happen?" Gavin asked.
"I thought I was protecting us."
"That's so stupid,â Gavin said.
Jackson rolled his eyes, "I know."
"No, seriously. That's one of the dumbest things you've ever done and Iâve seen you try to drink beer from your nose.
Jackson barked out a laugh, "You're not wrong."
"I can't believe you flew to Whitehorse for this," Gavin muttered.
"I can,â Jackson quipped back.
"Well of course you can."
"I literally bought the ticket at three in the morning,â Gavin groaned at that.
"Gav,â his heart stuttered.
"Yeah?" he looked over to Jackson.
Jackson took a deep breath, "I don't want the break anymore."
"I don't care if we're in different cities," he continued, "I don't care if it's hard. I don't care if people have opinions about it. I just know that I spent an entire year pretending I could live without you and it sucked."
Gavinâs eyes burned, âJackson---.â
"No, let me finish,â Jackson squeezed his hands, "I don't want to be your almost, I want to be your boyfriend.â
"You flew all the way to the Yukon to tell me that?" Gavin asked, dumbfounded.
Jackson shrugged, "Seemed more effective than texting."
âWell would you hurry up and kiss me already?â
Jackson stared daggers at him, "The dramatic declaration followed by the kiss. That was supposed to be my move."
Gavin rolled his eyes so hard it almost hurt, âWell maybe you shouldnât have taken so long. Iâve only been waiting for like a year.â
Jackson leaned over, "Hi," he said softly.
"Hi,â Gavin had to stop himself from giggling like a schoolgirl.
Jackson smiled and then they finally kissed. His hands found Jackson's hoodie and held on.
Jackson made a small noise against his mouth before pulling him closer. When they finally separated, both breathing harder than before, Gavin rested his forehead against Jackson's.
Gavin laughed suddenly.
Jackson pulled back slightly, "What?"
"You flew to Whitehorse,â Jackson groaned immediately, "You actually got on multiple planes."
"Don't start."
"You crossed an entire continent."
"Gavin,â Jackson interrupted him.
Gavin continued on, "You came all the way to the Yukon because you couldn't communicate your feelings like a normal person."
Jackson covered his face with one hand clearly embarrassed, "I am literally pouring my heart out to you,â he complained.
"And I'm accepting it,â Gavin smiled.
The room fell quiet again, but it wasn't the painful silence Gavin had gotten used to over the last year.
"So, are we officially doing this?" Jackson asked.
Gavin rolled his eyes, "You literally flew here to ask me to be your boyfriend."
"Yeah, but I still feel like I should hear it."
"You're ridiculous."
Jackson smiled, "And?"
Gavin shook his head, "Yeah, Jackson."
"Yeah?"
"You're my boyfriend,â he conceded.
Jackson jumped up and pumped his arms, âLetâs go!â
âSo did you have a backup plan or were you going to stay over at my house no matter what?â










