I am absolutely not joking at all when I say that The Sixth Sense should be required as teaching material when youāre trying to get kids to learn about why color matters.
No, the red DOESNāT mean love or violence or passion, however the creators set it up so that in this particular work red means OH NO A SCARY GHOST IS HERE.
When I was in college (as a lit major) I ended up sitting down and talking to a returning student who was having trouble in one of our classes. He liked books, and he had GI bill money so he decided to be a lit major.
He was VERY confused about the āThe Curtains Are Blue And It Means Somethingā approach to symbolism and I remember that he very seriously got out a notebook and a pen, sat down, and asked me āOkay so what to stars mean as a symbol?āĀ
And I was at a loss because of course I was! Stars-as-a-symbol can mean a thousand things and are heavily dependent on context. Are you reading a book about sea travel? Stars mean a map. Are you reading Maus? Stars represent faith and community and the way that the Nazis dehumanized Jewish people. Are you reading something by a romantic author who has a thing for the classics? Stars probably have something to do with heroism and destiny. Are you reading science fiction? Stars are probably just stars but if youāre reading Whipping Star by Frank Herbert they are literally people and our entire conception of stars is reexamined.
So one one the things that I think a lot of people are missing in their high school English classes is that whether the curtains are blue matters or not depends on the work.
The fact that Hamlet is wearing black is an important part of the story and the antagonist commenting on it it is almost the first thing that happens in the play.
What color dress is Lizzy wearing at the first dance in Pride & Prejudice? It doesnāt matter, the curtains are just blue.
And thatās one of those things that it takes a lot of time and a lot of exposure to different kinds of stories to learn and when youāre in high school you just donāt have that experience and your teachers are just now telling you for the first time āsometimes it matters why the curtains are blueā and I know youāre going āokay, sounds fakeā but the goal is to get you to look at blue curtains and ask if they do matter, which is why they hand you books with big obvious examples of the kind of shit theyāre talking about. You read A Tale of Two Cities because itās full of binaries and line motifs and itās the perfect thing to teach a fifteen year old how to look for a motif because there are a shitload of them. You readĀ The Scarlet Letter to look for color symbolism and to ferret out biblical allusions.
āThe curtains are just blueā is just āyet another day has gone by and I havenāt needed algebra.ā Most people arenāt going to need algebra in their day-to-day lives but itās handy to know how to do a bit when you need it and itās good to learn that the concept exists.
If youāre reading books just because theyāre fun and you like them then that is cool and Iām glad youāre having a good time and you absolutely do not have to give a fuck about symbolism.
But I am going to laugh my ass off at you if youāre one of those folks who is like āthe curtains are just blue it doesnāt matterā and then whines about why scifi and comics and cartoons and video games are all political these days. They were always political, you just couldnāt tell because the curtains were red.
(also because you were socialized to see certain things as apolitical and value neutral but if youāre going āWHY DO THEY PUT SERIOUS MORALS AND SHIT IN A KIDāS SHOW, STEPHEN UNIVERSE IS FOR TEN YEAR OLDS ITāS NOT THAT DEEP, LOONEY TUNES WASNāT LIKE THISā Iām afraid Iām going to have to refer you to all the actual war propaganda made by Disney and Warner Brothers.)