Caleb

but instead

The Great Divide: i can't even pick a lyric example because that WHOLE song is literally James thinking about Evan post breakup. Oh my god. All of it.

Dashboard: "You're an asshole, after all". this song is james about Evan YEARS later, in Canon when he learns Evan’s joined the death eaters.

Doors: "I keep showing you doors, but you can't open them up/'Cause it gets harder to see me the closer you try to look" Evan being so unfamiliar with being loved and cared for, trying to get used to opening up to another. And james just wants to show evan that it's okay to be loved.

Downfall: "So call me when it goes to shit, I'll be keeping the house the way it was. I won't rub your face in it. I swear I won't tell anyone. I don't mind being your dead end. I think it's fine to never move on," Evan about James after their breakup, being angry at James for leaving but also knowing it was his fault and blaming his own brokenness.

Willing and Able: "Oh I wish you could know me. And I wish I could know you much more, sometimes." Both of them wanting to work out and communicate and fix their relationship but being unsure how or where to start.

Porch Light: "It is not irrelevant that you stopped taking your medicine. But I'm giving you the benefit 'cause it's raining out," James watching Evan push him away and grow distant, not understanding that Evan is panicking and trying to self isolate. James is also beginning to see a darker side of Evan, a part of him that he doesn't know how to regulate.

All Them Horses: "So tell me when it feels you cannot escape me. Just yell like dad would yell at all the noise I'm making. I'm just happy you still call." Evan really wanting to get better and sort himself out and create a future for himself because of the positive influence James has had on him.

A Few of Your Own: this whole song is both of them at the beginning/good parts of their relationship, knowing theyre both not perfect but wanting each other anyways and getting used to each other's prescense in their lives.

Okay sorry for so much. Again these are just some examples. This might just be their album. (Except for Lighthouse which is actually Rosekiller).

MLM

Flip it around, WLW