The position has finally been posted and I think I've decided I'm not going to apply.
Thinking about it, I don't think I'm ready for the promotion. Maybe I would be in a year or two, maybe never. I am not a decisive person, and this would be a position in which I would have to be more decisive. People ask me things all the time in my current position (even moreso now, since the position above me is currently vacant so they don't have the normal person to ask) and I am able to answer a lot of things, but when it comes to tricky situations that require subjectivity I tend to hesitate, and I don't think that would fit well into the promoted position. I don't like being wrong and I don't want to mislead oyher people. Not as an authority figure. Not ever, but especially not then.
I know I'll be disappointing some people. But from talking to others, I think they can tell I'm hesitating, and from the tone of their voice I think they think I don't really want the position and that it would be a bad fit. Someone who hesitates over applying to a job probably is not fit to have that job. I think they haven't told me I shouldn't apply because they don't want to hurt my feelings and want me to arrive at the conclusion myself, which I have.
It's a bit disappointing because I used to think I would really want to get into that promoted position, and I think eventually I could do a good job. Unfortunately, I don't think that eventually is now. Even more unfortunately, it's very possible this promotion will not open up again for many, many years. This is my shot. If I miss it, it's gone. But I don't want to burden people with someone who isn't a good fit, so I think it's better not to go for it.
You could definitely argue that the question of fit is something the interviewers should determine. I assume either all or all but one of the interviewers would know me, since it's an internal promotion (though they could grab someone from slightly outside my division, which has happened before). They would probably know how often I ask questions. They could probably factor that into the final decision. The question of whether I'm good enough should maybe be left to them and not me. But I can't help but think some think more highly of me than they should, because they don't interact with me 24/7 and don't see all the questions I put out, which get distributed through other people. I'd feel a bit like a sham.
I think my coworkers deserve someone more competent than me. We have hired people before that weren't good fits in the end, so the interview process is not infallible. I could trick them with a false display of competency.
I think one reason a promotion seems nice is that it would be an escape from my current situation, to an extent, into something more controlled. My job isn't the most regular. If I were promoted, there would be less external interaction and more internal interaction, which I would like. But again, it's a question of fit, and I think the answer is "not well enough."
I have another week to think about it before applications close. But I think I just won't apply. Hopefully whoever we get is competent. I really liked the person we had in that position, and the one before him was pleasant enough too. I would interact with that person all the time, so at a minimum please let them be bearable.
If anything, I'll be glad once the application closes, whether I apply or not. I think about it all the time. Every day. When out and about, when home, when trying to shower, when trying to sleep...I want to be free of the worry over whether or not I should apply (and whether or not I'm good enough).
The summary is that internally I think I've accepted the fact that I'm not a good fit after all, and that the people who've praised me have done so either because they don't interact with me enough to see my major faults, or because they're just so worried about getting someone HORRIBLE that I would be a consolation fill/bearable because at least I'm internal and wouldn't have to learn things from the ground up.
I think that's the core of it. I think if I got the position it would be a consolation prize. A fill because they needed someone. Acceptable because they only have pieces and not the full thing. I think once I got into the position my cracks would show.
Anyway. Gotta work. I have things to do. I'm just kind of tired at this point. I hope things go well in the future. I hope whoever the person hired in that position is, they work out.