Descent Into Sonadow Induced Madness

Cherry Wine by ShadowsCoffeeBeans (not everything on its page is fluffy or romantic but it all has a lot of feelings

Extremely soft and sweet, can be read as romantic ot otherwise but it’s on the top of my list for sweet stuff! It also made me cry!!!

What Do We Do with a Drunken Sailor? By StrydertheHedgehog (have not actually read anything else by this author YET but love this one)

Very cute and fluffy, lots of feelings. A bit angsty, but I think the romance is super cute

The Elephant is Pink by Sochks (highly recommend anything by them tbh)

I adore this one, it’s the whole “my friends have moved on without me but I’m Sonic!!” So a lil angst but mostly just thoughtful and fun

Rediscovering You by FreinchFryGirl (also rec Stars Don’t Fall Alone but there’s no smut in this one)

Probably the softest Shadow I’ve seen, this is unfinished but I am confident it will be done in the next year. They switch, it’s hot, they are so so in love it’s so cute

Doppelgänger: The Tale of Two Hedgehogs by queerwolf76 (all of her stuff hits but some of it is risqué themes)

This is so charming and cute. It’s not a lot of smut but the story is very sweet and I like what she did with the ensemble cast a lot

Going for Gold by PoppySeeds_and_CoffeeBeans (big rec for romance)

I am so real in saying I haven’t read this one yet but the author is very passionate about romantic stories and also very sweet, so it may be your cup of tea

Ardent Devotion by MalewifeShadow (a lot of smutty and romantic stories)

This one is a bit more kinky but it’s very sweet and romantic… to me at least. I think if you like the above fics you’d like this one. It’s ongoing as well, but I am confident it’ll be finished