I let myself become "the other woman"
I never imagined these are words I would say aloud. I never imaged this is a situation I would ever be in in my entire life, but it's true. I let myself carry on with a man who wasn't mine. For almost an entire year, we had what I would call a relationship. While we never slept together in the sense that we both reached a climax, there were numerous intimate encounters that I am not proud of and would never boast about.Â
I am ashamed of myself, my actions, and I regret my decisions. But, this leads me to my question.... Do I regret my decisions only because I didn't end up with him? Would I have regretted my decisions if he left his girlfriend for me, like he had said he wanted to?Â
I am sure you know who I am talking about, of course this is The Main Character. Let's back ourselves up in this story, I have been too embarrassed to talk about it. Maybe now, though, after an afternoon of drinking endless pitchers of sangria and now a glass of wine on my own back patio I feel open enough to let you in on my secrets.
At the beginning of September of last year, maybe it was the end of August, regardless, it was the closing night party of the theatre we were working at. His girlfriend wasn't there and we got drunk and ended up mucking about, as he calls it. I had previously admitted to him my feelings were still intact and I was keeping my distance for a reason, but still, that happened and I was embarrassed. That was the first time I had ever, knowingly, been intimate with someone committed in a relationship before.Â
At the end of it all, we got into an argument and I moved on with The Hairdresser, as I am sure you all remember. Well, one night when I was talking about The Hairdresser to a large group of friends, including the Main Character, he texted me to tell me that he was jealous, that he still had feelings for me, and that he wanted to be with me. What was I supposed to do? He asked me not to make him commit to anything in that moment, because he had a busy week at work. I am in the same industry as him, so to speak, so I understood. I let him be for that week, he told me he wanted to break up with his girlfriend and be with me, but I had already moved on as well. I broke up with the Hairdresser in part because of this, because I wanted to be with him and I was ready.
Well, let's fast forward to eleven months later. He hasn't left his girlfriend. I am still by myself. But now, really, I am by myself. There has been eleven months of us fighting; because he tells me he wants to be with me but he won't leave his girlfriend. There has been eleven months of me crying, because when we are together it is anything but friendship, we naturally fall into a very intimate encounter. For the last eleven months, it has been nothing but us talking absolutely every single day, being there for each other emotionally and making plans to see each other physically.
It came to a halt when I got severely drunk at a Christmas party and made a fool of myself in front of everyone and I thought he realized just how severely this "affair" was affecting me. At that point, I wanted nothing more than to maintain a friendship with him. Throughout this entire charade, I always wanted to be just his friend. It is only now that I realize, I am too battered to be his friend. This has taken too much of a toll on me that I can't see him without hurting to the core.
Once January approached, we met up for a coffee where he admitted to me that he regretted not taking the opportunity to be with me when it arose. I tried to play this off as simply and cooly as possible but on the inside I was an actual disaster. I wanted to tell him he still had his chance, we could still be together, I was still there if he wanted me.
Our emotional and sometimes physical affair resumed when we began working together at the theatre. He always had a difficult time accepting it when I started dating other people, but on the same coin I have a yearning to be in something real and committed with someone and he wasn't offering that to me. He wished me a Happy Valentines Day and told me he wanted to buy me Flowers but didn't think it was appropriate. I spent the night cuddling with him on his couch late in the month, but slept on the couch because we knew we couldn't be in the same bed without it going further than it should. We fought over these things, because I so badly wanted to give myself to him again but knew I couldn't lose myself in that. Cuddling and kissing and friendly hands was enough for me, I couldn't do it all.Â
This cycle of fighting, not talking, talking, wanting to be together, quasi-dating each other, et cetera went on for months. Until, in the beginning of May when he finally told me that he was planning on moving in with his girlfriend. This is just a short week from the time where we were spending time together, intimately, cuddling, and talking about our own relationship and where it was going to go. Of course, I was heartbroken. I was crying on the phone when he told me, incoherently bawling my eyes out and he told me he was coming over.
He came over and consoled me, telling me that it was how things had to be, he needed to give this a chance, despite us. I was actually inconsolable, I told him not to do it, that I loved him, that he should give us a chance, but of course I was drunk, blubbering, and it was past midnight when we both had to work in the morning.Â
We talked about things, or well, we meant to talk about things. And it just turned into his girlfriend being away for two weeks and me spending every night at his apartment, hanging out, cuddling, talking, and being together. Again, I am falling for his every move. Everything he does, I follow. He is my kryptonite, and I am powerless. I don't mean to make myself seem like a martyr here, but sometimes I feel I am, I don't know what power he has over me but he is entirely my achilles heal.Â
More fighting ensued when he then told me he never had any feelings for me and that the time we had been spending together meant nothing more than pure friendship. I went home at that point, I couldn't handle the emotional abuse that I was forcing myself into. I went to my parents, snuggled into my twin sized bed and cuddled with my dog. She knew I was upset because she would rarely leave my side. I spent time with old friends and college friends and tried to regain my sense of self again.Â
The following week I had to go back to work where I, of course, had to see him. No choice, we shared an office, we work in the same building, it's inevitable. We avoided each other at all costs and he got drunk enough that evening to tell me that he didn't like that we weren't talking. We met up a few day later and he apologized and told me he had said those things in the heat of an argument and that of course he didn't mean them.Â
That led back to us talking, constantly, again, and then it happened. On May 31st I was working reception at work and he and I went to get a few drinks when we were finished closing the building together. I was planning on meeting someone I had a brief fling with during a show at our theatre, so we parted ways after a few drinks and some hand-holding. He came to pick me up when I told him I wasn't having a good time and took me back to his place.Â
That's when it happened. IT. I know you can connect the dots. No, I am not proud. It lasted all of two minutes before I started crying and he stopped. I went to the washroom and proceeded to cry more where he tried to hug me and awkwardly console me. He drove me home and told me he wanted to break up with his girlfriend and be with me. I told him he needed to. He told me seeing me like this broke his heart and he realized he really need to make his decision. The following day I told him he needed to choose and he said he was trying to figure it out in his mind. Then he went on a camping trip with his girlfriend and my heart was even more broken than before. He didn't choose me.
We didn't talk throughout the entire trip which was somewhat painful but also therapeutic. One day before he came home, I went back to my parents place and old theatre for the opening night of their festival season. It was then that I decided "Fuck this guy". He texted me the day he arrived him, which I expected, and asked if we could get together to talk. I told him No. I then proceeded to have casual sex with a friend of his and he ended up finding out immediately, much to my dismay; I had no intention on sharing this with him. This was for me, I don't do things out of spite. I just wanted to have sex and he was willing. It had nothing to do with The Main Character at all.
The Main Character was upset and because he was so angry with me, I was even more hurt. It was never my intention to cause pain to him, I just wanted to do something for myself. Not to mention the fact that he had absolutely no right to impose judgment upon me for doing something that so similarly reflected his actions in the past.Â
Regardless, it was something we fought about and ending up working through. He and his girlfriend got an apartment which broke me even more, and he half-ass moved in. He brought clothes, and that was it. We continued to spend a lot of time together while I was working the Fringe Festival and he was busy building a set for a show we were close to producing at the theatre.Â
More hooking up ensued, no penetration mind you. Then I went away on vacation, where I didn't have cell phone reception and couldn't contact him. I must have forgot to tell him that I wouldn't have reception because I came home to numerous text messages and finally a message from him proclaiming he was having strong feelings for me and he felt stupid that he thought it was going to work this time. That he was thinking about ways to break up with his girlfriend for me and he wanted us to be together and he was upset that I was ignoring him. Of course, I wasn't. For this guy, I would fucking move planets for. Something about him causes me to have such a love for him, I can't describe it.
Back to the story, I explained to him I didn't have reception and that I was now stuck at my parents house to endure a little bit of doctor testing (a story about pre-cancerous cervix, wahoo, all clear!) When I came back to Toronto I came to visit him at work and we had a lovely evening drinking in the theatre talking about his work and how things were. When he drove me home we shared a warm embrace and he told me he missed me and he didn't want me to go in just yet. So we just sat there, holding each other, kissing each other, but not letting it go too far.
I went inside, sad that he had to leave, that I had to leave his arms that I fit so perfectly inside of, and then he texted me. "I think I really am starting to fall for you Lucy"
"I don't know what to do".
I started panicking at that moment. I love this person. Will he finally leave his girlfriend for me? Can I finally have what I want? Can I finally let myself just be with him, passionately, and lovingly, and fiercely? I wanted nothing more than to have a real, honest relationship with him, and I had said that to him a few weeks earlier and he replied that he did too, we just needed to take it slow. Which I agreed with, stupidly, at the time.
I told him in that moment that we could figure it out. He said I hope so, and wished me goodnight. Goodnight hun. The following moron he sent me an email from work hoping that it hadn't fucked me up too much, that he really did like me and miss me and he didn't know what he should do. I told him, again, we could figure it out. If he was in, I am in. There is no doubt, I was in. I had dedicated so much time to this person, to making him happy, it became my job outside of my job.Â
We saw each other once more, at the end of July, he came over to my apartment and we had some beverages together and then we went to my bed. I told him before we did that, that I didn't trust myself and I knew what was going to happen would end bad but he assured me he had no expectations. In retrospect, I should have known better than to trust someone who had also had a bit to drink. But of course, it went too far and it was the attempt to have sex until things got too weird again. This time, however, I didn't cry in front of him. I probably would have, shamefully, let things progress until we both got our "fill" so to speak. He stopped and went to leave, and I told him I would be very upset if he left in that moment so he stayed for a little while.
That was essentially the demise. I told him the following day that I needed him to be in or out and he didn't respond; I assumed he was trying to figure it out because he was pleasant with me at work that night. A few days passed and I finally asked him if he was in or out and he told me he felt I was being pushy and pressuring and he wasn't going to be in if this is how it was going to be.Â
After that, we tried to have a friendly day and I couldn't handle it. The feeling I had during and after he left was just too much for me to handle, I want him in my life but I want him in my life in such a deeper way than just as a platonic friend.
I sent him a message explaining to him that I needed time to adjust from this relationship; because for me, this was a relationship.
I was committed to being with him every time he told me he wanted this and that he wanted to try. I just don't know how to date someone who is in a relationship with another woman. I don't know how to date someone and get closer to someone who lives with another woman.Â
His argument was that every time we get close I ask him to jump ahead more steps than he is ready for, but what he doesn't understand, is that if this were a normal relationship I wouldn't ask him that at all. If we were just "dating" or "seeing each other" than I wouldn't ask him to make a commitment to me. But it is because he is in a "committed" relationship with a woman he is living with and sleeping with on the regular that I had to ask him to be in or out.
I feel as though I have made the right decision, I know that in the long run I have. I know that of course there is someone out there for me who will love me, I just feel incredibly broken. I am not proud of this relationship in the least. I am ashamed that I became a woman I hate. I remember hearing my mother speak about her fathers affair and how it ruined an entire family and I can't believe I have done something so similar, so selfish, so cruel. If his girlfriend finds out, I have broken a person. I sometimes feel I deserve to be broken too, but I did this because I loved someone. Foolish as it was, I honestly believed in the things that he told me.Â
I got swept up, caught up, and taken under. I'm not proud, but I wanted you to know. Maybe I wanted to write about it to clear my conscious. Just to get the words out there, just to talk about it, but there is it. In black and white, or whatever colour my blog shows up as, it's there. For the whole world to see.Â
I let it happen, it is so incredibly painful to see the two of them together. I work with him, on Saturday he moved all of his belongings to the apartment with her and I spent the morning in bed listening to Tegan and Sara and crying. I am trying to consume my every waking moment with anyone and anything that has nothing to do with him but it becomes hard when I work such opposite hours of those I am friends with.
I still love him, so much. I still go to bed and think of him. I still wish he was laying beside me every night and every morning I still check my phone to see if he has wished me a good morning. I wish I could move on and not have a place for him in my heart but I don't know how to do that. I am moving on, I am going to date again, but pieces of me still belong to him and I honestly don't know if I even want them back.Â




















